Programmable Control of Nucleation for Algorithmic Self-Assembly

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2009-12-04

Citations: 90

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1137/070680266

Abstract

Algorithmic self-assembly, a generalization of crystal growth processes, has been proposed as a mechanism for autonomous DNA computation and for bottom-up fabrication of complex nanostructures. A "program" for growing a desired structure consists of a set of molecular "tiles" designed to have specific binding interactions. A key challenge to making algorithmic self-assembly practical is designing tile set programs that make assembly robust to errors that occur during initiation and growth. One method for the controlled initiation of assembly, often seen in biology, is the use of a seed or catalyst molecule that reduces an otherwise large kinetic barrier to nucleation. Here we show how to program algorithmic self-assembly similarly, such that seeded assembly proceeds quickly but there is an arbitrarily large kinetic barrier to unseeded growth. We demonstrate this technique by introducing a family of tile sets for which we rigorously prove that, under the right physical conditions, linearly increasing the size of the tile set exponentially reduces the rate of spurious nucleation. Simulations of these "zig-zag" tile sets suggest that under plausible experimental conditions, it is possible to grow large seeded crystals in just a few hours such that less than 1 percent of crystals are spuriously nucleated. Simulation results also suggest that zig-zag tile sets could be used for detection of single DNA strands. Together with prior work showing that tile sets can be made robust to errors during properly initiated growth, this work demonstrates that growth of objects via algorithmic self-assembly can proceed both efficiently and with an arbitrarily low error rate, even in a model where local growth rules are probabilistic.

Locations

  • SIAM Journal on Computing - View
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • CiteSeer X (The Pennsylvania State University) - View - PDF
  • CaltechAUTHORS (California Institute of Technology) - View - PDF
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Pattern recognition in the nucleation kinetics of non-equilibrium self-assembly 2022 Constantine G. Evans
Jackson O’Brien
Erik Winfree
Arvind Murugan
+ Fast algorithmic self-assembly of simple shapes using random agitation 2014 Ho-Lin Chen
David Doty
Dhiraj Holden
Chris Thachuk
Damien Woods
Chun-Tao Yang
+ Optimizing Tile Concentrations to Minimize Errors and Time for DNA Tile Self-Assembly Systems 2012 Ho-Lin Chen
Ming‐Yang Kao
+ PDF Chat Intrinsic universality and the computational power of self-assembly 2015 Damien Woods
+ The Impacts of Dimensionality, Diffusion, and Directedness on Intrinsic Cross-Model Simulation in Tile-Based Self-Assembly 2023 Daniel Hader
Matthew J. Patitz
+ A Limit to the Power of Multiple Nucleation in Self-Assembly (full version) 2009 Aaron Sterling
+ Self-Assembly of Shapes at Constant Scale using Repulsive Forces 2016 Austin Luchsinger
Robert Schweller
Tim Wylie
+ Self-Replication via Tile Self-Assembly 2021 Andrew Alseth
Daniel Hader
Matthew J. Patitz
+ PDF Chat Multi-scale coarse-graining for the study of assembly pathways in DNA-brick self-assembly 2018 Pedro Fonseca
Flavio Romano
John S. Schreck
Thomas E. Ouldridge
Jonathan P. K. Doye
Ard A. Louis
+ PDF Chat The Tile Assembly Model is Intrinsically Universal 2012 David Doty
Jack H. Lutz
Matthew J. Patitz
Robert Schweller
Scott M. Summers
Damien Woods
+ The tile assembly model is intrinsically universal 2011 David Doty
Jack H. Lutz
Matthew J. Patitz
Robert Schweller
Scott M. Summers
Damien Woods
+ Randomized Self-Assembly for Exact Shapes 2009 David Doty
+ Randomized Self-Assembly for Exact Shapes 2009 David Doty
+ Simulations of DNA-Origami Self-Assembly Reveal Design-Dependent Nucleation Barriers 2022 Alexander Cumberworth
Daan Frenkel
Aleks Reinhardt
+ PDF Chat Nondeterministic self-assembly with asymmetric interactions 2016 S. Tesoro
Kerstin GĂśpfrich
Tadas Kartanas
Ulrich F. Keyser
Sebastian E. Ahnert
+ PDF Chat Nondeterministic self-assembly of two tile types on a lattice 2016 S. Tesoro
Sebastian E. Ahnert
+ Temperature 1 Self-Assembly: Deterministic Assembly in 3D and Probabilistic Assembly in 2D 2009 Matthew Cook
Yunhui Fu
Robert Schweller
+ Temperature 1 Self-Assembly: Deterministic Assembly in 3D and Probabilistic Assembly in 2D 2011 Matthew Cook
Yunhui Fu
Robert Schweller
+ A Time Lower Bound for Multiple Nucleation on a Surface 2009 Aaron Sterling
+ PDF Chat Randomized Self-Assembly for Exact Shapes 2010 David Doty

Works That Cite This (25)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Computing properties of stable configurations of thermodynamic binding networks 2018 Keenan Breik
Chris Thachuk
Marijn J. H. Heule
David Soloveichik
+ PDF Chat Thermodynamically Favorable Computation via Tile Self-assembly 2018 Cameron Chalk
Jacob Hendricks
Matthew J. Patitz
Michael Sharp
+ PDF Chat Programming Substrate-Independent Kinetic Barriers With Thermodynamic Binding Networks 2019 Keenan Breik
Cameron Chalk
David Doty
David Haley
David Soloveichik
+ Strong Fault-Tolerance for Self-Assembly with Fuzzy Temperature 2010 David Doty
Matthew J. Patitz
Dustin Reishus
Robert Schweller
Scott M. Summers
+ Ternary and senary representations using DNA double-crossover tiles 2016 Byeong‐Hoon Kim
Soojin Jo
Junyoung Son
Jung-Hoon Kim
Min Hyeok Kim
Si Un Hwang
Sreekantha Reddy Dugasani
Byung-Dong Kim
Wing Kam Liu
Moon Ki Kim
+ PDF Chat Ternary and senary representations using DNA double-crossover tiles 2014 Byeong‐Hoon Kim
Soojin Jo
Junyoung Son
Jung-Hoon Kim
Min Hyeok Kim
Si Un Hwang
Sreekantha Reddy Dugasani
Byung-Dong Kim
Wing Kam Liu
Moon Ki Kim
+ Ternary and senary representations using DNA double-crossover tiles 2016 Byeong‐Hoon Kim
Soojin Jo
Junyoung Son
Jung‐Hoon Kim
Si Un Hwang
Sreekantha Reddy Dugasani
Min Hyeok Kim
Byung-Dong Kim
Iksoo Chang
Wing Kam Liu
+ Polyominoes simulating arbitrary-neighborhood zippers and tilings 2011 Lila Kari
BenoĂŽt Masson
+ PDF Chat Parallelism and Time in Hierarchical Self-Assembly 2017 Ho-Lin Chen
David Doty
+ PDF Chat Thermodynamic Binding Networks 2017 David Doty
Trent A. Rogers
David Soloveichik
Chris Thachuk
Damien Woods

Works Cited by This (1)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Complexity of Self‐Assembled Shapes 2007 David Soloveichik
Erik Winfree