Design of Phase I Combination Trials: Recommendations of the Clinical Trial Design Task Force of the NCI Investigational Drug Steering Committee

Type: Review

Publication Date: 2014-08-13

Citations: 64

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1158/1078-0432.ccr-14-0521

Abstract

Anticancer drugs are combined in an effort to treat a heterogeneous tumor or to maximize the pharmacodynamic effect. The development of combination regimens, while desirable, poses unique challenges. These include the selection of agents for combination therapy that may lead to improved efficacy while maintaining acceptable toxicity, the design of clinical trials that provide informative results for individual agents and combinations, and logistic and regulatory challenges. The phase I trial is often the initial step in the clinical evaluation of a combination regimen. In view of the importance of combination regimens and the challenges associated with developing them, the Clinical Trial Design (CTD) Task Force of the National Cancer Institute Investigational Drug Steering Committee developed a set of recommendations for the phase I development of a combination regimen. The first two recommendations focus on the scientific rationale and development plans for the combination regimen; subsequent recommendations encompass clinical design aspects. The CTD Task Force recommends that selection of the proposed regimens be based on a biologic or pharmacologic rationale supported by clinical and/or robust and validated preclinical evidence, and accompanied by a plan for subsequent development of the combination. The design of the phase I clinical trial should take into consideration the potential pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic interactions as well as overlapping toxicity. Depending on the specific hypothesized interaction, the primary endpoint may be dose optimization, pharmacokinetics, and/or pharmacodynamics (i.e., biomarker).

Locations

  • Clinical Cancer Research - View - PDF
  • PubMed Central - View
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat An Overview of the Optimal Planning, Design, and Conduct of Phase I Studies of New Therapeutics 2010 Patricia LoRusso
Scott A. Boerner
Lesley Seymour
+ An Innovative Phase I Trial Design Allowing for the Identification of Multiple Potential Maximum Tolerated Doses with Combination Therapy of Targeted Agents 2010 Sarina A. Piha‐Paul
+ Phase I Trial Design and Methodology for Anticancer Drugs 2004 Patrick V. Acevedo
Deborah Toppmeyer
Eric H. Rubin
+ Phase I Trial Design and Methodology 1997 Deborah Toppmeyer
+ PDF Chat The Design of Phase II Clinical Trials Testing Cancer Therapeutics: Consensus Recommendations from the Clinical Trial Design Task Force of the National Cancer Institute Investigational Drug Steering Committee 2010 Lesley Seymour
S. Percy Ivy
Daniel J. Sargent
David R. Spriggs
Laurence Baker
Larry Rubinstein
Mark J. Ratain
M Blanc
David B. Stewart
John Crowley
+ PDF Chat Evaluation of phase I clinical trial designs for combinational agents along with guidance based on simulation studies 2022 Shu Wang
Elias Sayour
Ji‐Hyun Lee
+ PDF Chat The evolution of phase I trials in cancer medicine: a critical review of the last decade 2011 Anthony W. Tolcher
+ PDF Chat Phase I Trial Design for Solid Tumor Studies of Targeted, Non-Cytotoxic Agents: Theory and Practice 2004 Wendy R. Parulekar
Elizabeth A. Eisenhauer
+ PDF Chat Practical designs for Phase I combination studies in oncology 2015 Nolan A. Wages
Anastasia Ivanova
Olga Marchenko
+ PDF Chat Phase I Cancer Clinical Trials 2015
+ The evolution of phase I trials in cancer medicine: a critical review of the last decade 2011 Anthony
Tolcher
+ PDF Chat Seamless Phase I-II Trial Design for Assessing Toxicity and Efficacy for Targeted Agents 2010 Antje Hoering
Mike LeBlanc
John Crowley
+ PDF Chat Phase I Clinical Trials in Oncology 2020 Prasanth Ganesan
+ PDF Chat Phase I Drug Combination Trial Design: Walking the Tightrope 2009 Paul Hamberg
Jaap Verweij
+ PDF Chat Design of phase II oncology trials evaluating combinations of experimental agents 2023 Elad Sharon
Jared C. Foster
+ Design and conduct of phase II studies of targeted anticancer therapy: Recommendations from the task force on methodology for the development of innovative cancer therapies (MDICT) 2007 Christopher M. Booth
A. Hilary Calvert
Giuseppe Giaccone
Marinus W. Lobbezoo
Elizabeth A. Eisenhauer
Lesley Seymour
+ Seamless Phase I/II Trial Design for Assessing Toxicity and Efficacy for Targeted Agents 2012 Antje Hoering
Michael LeBlanc
John Crowley
+ PDF Chat Impact of the 2010 Consensus Recommendations of the Clinical Trial Design Task Force of the NCI Investigational Drug Steering Committee 2015 Lesley Seymour
Susan Groshen
Gary L. Rosner
Daniel M. Sullivan
David R. Spriggs
Steven A. Reeves
Amy Gravell
S. Percy Ivy
Mark J. Ratain
+ Oncology phase I trial design and conduct: time for a change - MDICT Guidelines 2022 2022 Daniel Vilarim Araújo
Alastair Greystoke
SE Bates
A. Bayle
Emiliano Calvo
Luis Castelo‐Branco
Johann S. de Bono
Alexander Drilon
Elena Garralda
Percy Ivy
+ PDF Chat Practical designs for Phase I combination studies in oncology 2016 Nolan A. Wages
Anastasia Ivanova
Olga Marchenko

Works That Cite This (24)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Factors Affecting Combination Trial Success (FACTS): Investigator Survey Results on Early-Phase Combination Trials 2019 Channing J. Paller
Erich P. Huang
Thomas Luechtefeld
Holly A. Massett
Christopher Williams
Jinxiu Zhao
Amy Gravell
Tami Tamashiro
Steven A. Reeves
Gary L. Rosner
+ PDF Chat Randomized dose-escalation designs for drug combination cancer trials with immunotherapy 2018 Pavel Mozgunov
Thomas Jaki
Xavier Paolettí
+ PDF Chat Early Phase Clinical Trial Designs – State of Play and Adapting for the Future 2017 Jennifer Harrington
T.C. Hernandez-Guerrero
Bristi Basu
+ PDF Chat Impact of the 2010 Consensus Recommendations of the Clinical Trial Design Task Force of the NCI Investigational Drug Steering Committee 2015 Lesley Seymour
Susan Groshen
Gary L. Rosner
Daniel M. Sullivan
David R. Spriggs
Steven A. Reeves
Amy Gravell
S. Percy Ivy
Mark J. Ratain
+ Dynamic ordering design for dose finding in <scp>drug‐combination</scp> trials 2020 Teng Zhang
Zhao Yang
Guosheng Yin
+ Challenges and Opportunities in Dose Finding in Oncology and Immuno‐oncology 2018 Yan Ji
Jin Y. Jin
David M. Hyman
Geoffrey Kim
Ajit Suri
+ PDF Chat Early drug development in solid tumours: analysis of National Cancer Institute-sponsored phase 1 trials 2022 Dai Chihara
Ruitao Lin
Christopher R. Flowers
Shanda Finnigan
Lisa M. Cordes
Yoko Fukuda
Erich P. Huang
Larry Rubinstein
Loretta J. Nastoupil
S. Percy Ivy
+ Improving early phase oncology clinical trial design: An opportunity for statisticians 2022 Alan Phillips
Shalini Mondal
+ PDF Chat Seamless Designs: Current Practice and Considerations for Early-Phase Drug Development in Oncology 2018 Brian P. Hobbs
Pedro C. Barata
Yada Kanjanapan
Channing J. Paller
Jane Perlmutter
Gregory R. Pond
Tatiana M. Prowell
Eric H. Rubin
Lesley Seymour
Nolan A. Wages
+ PDF Chat Dosage Optimization: A Regulatory Perspective for Developing Oncology Drugs 2024 Atiqur Rahman
Mirat Shah
Stacy S. Shord

Works Cited by This (9)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Dose-escalation models for combination phase I trials in oncology 2010 Paul Hamberg
Mark J. Ratain
Emmanuel Lesaffre
Jaap Verweij
+ Adaptive designs for dual-agent phase I dose-escalation studies 2013 Jennifer Harrington
Graham Wheeler
Michael Sweeting
Adrian Mander
Duncan I. Jodrell
+ PDF Chat Evaluation of Utility of Pharmacokinetic Studies in Phase I Trials of Two Oncology Drugs 2013 Kehua Wu
Larry House
Jacqueline Ramı́rez
Michael J. Seminerio
Mark J. Ratain
+ PDF Chat Dose Escalation Methods in Phase I Cancer Clinical Trials 2009 Christophe Le Tourneau
J. Jack Lee
Lillian L. Siu
+ PDF Chat The Design of Phase II Clinical Trials Testing Cancer Therapeutics: Consensus Recommendations from the Clinical Trial Design Task Force of the National Cancer Institute Investigational Drug Steering Committee 2010 Lesley Seymour
S. Percy Ivy
Daniel J. Sargent
David R. Spriggs
Laurence Baker
Larry Rubinstein
Mark J. Ratain
M Blanc
David B. Stewart
John Crowley
+ Dose‐Finding Based on Efficacy–Toxicity Trade‐Offs 2004 Peter F. Thall
John D. Cook
+ An adaptive phase I design for identifying a biologically optimal dose for dual agent drug combinations 2006 Sumithra J. Mandrekar
Yue Cui
Daniel J. Sargent
+ PDF Chat An Overview of the Optimal Planning, Design, and Conduct of Phase I Studies of New Therapeutics 2010 Patricia LoRusso
Scott A. Boerner
Lesley Seymour
+ PDF Chat How valid are claims for synergy in published clinical studies? 2012 Alberto Ocaña
Eitan Amir
Celine Yeung
Boštjan Šeruga
Ian F. Tannock