Testing exchangeability in the batch mode with e-values and Markov alternatives

Authors

Type: Article
Publication Date: 2025-02-21
Citations: 0
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10994-024-06720-x

Abstract

Abstract The topic of this paper is testing the assumption of exchangeability, which is the standard assumption in mainstream machine learning. The common approaches are online testing by betting (such as conformal testing) and the older batch testing using p-values (as in classical hypothesis testing). The approach of this paper is intermediate in that we are interested in batch testing by betting; as a result, p-values are replaced by e-values. As a first step in this direction, this paper concentrates on the Markov model as alternative. The null hypothesis of exchangeability is formalized as a Kolmogorov-type compression model, and the Bayes mixture of the Markov model w.r. to the uniform prior is taken as simple alternative hypothesis. Using e-values instead of p-values leads to a computationally efficient testing procedure. Two appendixes discuss connections with the algorithmic theory of randomness; in particular, the test proposed in this paper can be interpreted as a poor man’s version of Kolmogorov’s deficiency of randomness.

Locations

  • arXiv (Cornell University)
  • Machine Learning

Ask a Question About This Paper

Summary

This paper addresses the problem of testing exchangeability in statistical data using e-values instead of the more traditional p-values. The core idea is to formalize the null hypothesis of exchangeability using a Kolmogorov-type compression model and to use a Bayes mixture of the Markov model with a uniform prior as a simple alternative hypothesis. By using e-values, the author demonstrates that the testing procedure becomes computationally more efficient.

Key innovations include:

  1. E-value based exchangeability testing: The paper shifts the focus from p-values to e-values for testing exchangeability. E-values facilitate computations and offer a more efficient testing procedure.
  2. Markov alternative: The Bayes mixture of the Markov model is used as a simple alternative hypothesis to exchangeability.
  3. Algorithm and Optimality: It provides an efficient algorithm for calculating the corresponding e-variable and proves a simple optimality property.

Prior ingredients needed for this paper include:

  1. Exchangeability: The concept of exchangeability in statistics.
  2. Kolmogorov Complexity: The basis for defining randomness and compression models. The paper requires an understanding of algorithmic information theory.
  3. E-values: The use of e-values (martingales) in sequential hypothesis testing.
  4. Markov Models: Basic understanding of Markov chains and their properties.
  5. Hypothesis Testing: The basic machinery of statistical hypothesis testing.

Similar Works

Action Title Date Authors
Testing exchangeability in the batch mode with e-values and Markov alternatives 2023-01-01 Vladimir Vovk
Testing Randomness Online 2021-10-11 Vladimir Vovk
Testing randomness. 2019-06-21 Vladimir Vovk
Theoretical Foundations of Conformal Prediction 2024-11-18 Anastasios N. Angelopoulos Rina Foygel Barber Stephen Bates
Hypothesis testing with e-values 2024-10-30 Aaditya Ramdas Ruodu Wang
Power and limitations of conformal martingales. 2019-06-21 Vladimir Vovk
Randomness, exchangeability, and conformal prediction 2025-01-20 Vladimir Vovk
Exchangeability, Conformal Prediction, and Rank Tests 2020-05-13 Arun Kumar Kuchibhotla
Exchangeability, Conformal Prediction, and Rank Tests 2020-01-01 Arun Kumar Kuchibhotla
Cross-conformal e-prediction 2020-01-01 Vladimir Vovk
Model-X Sequential Testing for Conditional Independence via Testing by Betting 2022-01-01 Shalev Shaer Gal Maman Yaniv Romano
Testing Independence of Exchangeable Random Variables 2022-01-01 Marcus HĂźtter
+
Prediction-based uncertainty quantification for exchangeable sequences 2023-03-27 Sandra Fortini Sonia Petrone
+
Statistical inference with exchangeability and martingales 2023-03-27 Chris Holmes Stephen G. Walker
+
Model assessment: Bayes assisted tests and tests for discrete data 2014-01-23 Zheng Sun
Enhancing Conformal Prediction Using E-Test Statistics 2024-03-27 Alexander Balinsky Alexandr Balinsky
+
Probability and statistics 2007-07-26 Henk Tijms
+
Probability and statistics 2013-03-06 KĂŠvin Cahill
+
Probability and statistics 2013-05-05 Daniel W. Bliss Siddhartan Govindasamy
+
Probability and statistics 2013-04-25 Jan Rak M. J. Tannenbaum

Cited by (0)

Action Title Date Authors