Spatial and Temporal Hotspot Analysis of COVID-19 in Toronto

Type: Preprint

Publication Date: 2024-08-31

Citations: 0

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.30.24312852

Abstract

ABSTRACT The COVID-19 pandemic in Toronto, Canada was unequal for its 2.7 million residents. As a dynamic pandemic, COVID-19 trends might have also varied over space and time. We conducted a spatiotemporal hotspot analysis of COVID-19 over the first four major waves of COVID-19 using three different applications of Moran’s I to highlight the variable experience of COVID-19 infections in Toronto, while describing the potential impact of socioeconomic and sociodemographic factors on increased risk of COVID-19 exposure and infection. Results highlight potential clustering of COVID-19 case rate hot spots in areas with higher concentrations of immigrant and low-income residents and cold spots in areas with more affluent and non-immigrant residents during the first three waves. By the fourth wave, case rate clustering patterns were more dynamic. In all, a better understanding of the unequal COVID-19 pandemic experience in Toronto needs to also consider the dynamic nature of the pandemic. HIGHLIGHTS - The COVID-19 pandemic was spatially and temporarily dynamic in the City of Toronto. - At first, hotspots were concentrated in areas with more marginalized residents. - Later, COVID-19 spatial trends diverged from initially identified patterns. - East Asian enclaves in the city disproportionally had lower COVID-19 case counts. - COVID-19 studies need to consider the dynamic nature of the pandemic.

Locations

  • medRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 case rates, spatial mobility, and neighbourhood socioeconomic characteristics in Toronto: a spatial–temporal analysis 2023 Jack Forsyth
Lu Wang
Andrea Thomas-Bachli
+ PDF Chat Exploring the Differential Impact of COVID-19 on the Greater Toronto Area: A Literature Review 2022 Praveen Nadesan
+ Spatiotemporal socioeconomic analysis of COVID-19 case rates and mobility in Toronto neighbourhoods 2024 Jack Forsyth
+ Spatiotemporal socioeconomic analysis of COVID-19 case rates and mobility in Toronto neighbourhoods 2024 Jack Forsyth
+ Spatiotemporal clusters and the socioeconomic determinants of COVID-19 in Toronto neighbourhoods, Canada 2022 Nushrat Nazia
Jane Law
Zahid A Butt
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 in Toronto: A Spatial Exploratory Analysis 2021 Eric Vaz
+ COVID-19 in Toronto: A Spatial Exploratory Analysis 2023 Eric Vaz
+ COVID-19 in Toronto: A Spatial Exploratory Analysis 2023 Eric Vaz
+ Increasing concentration of COVID-19 by socioeconomic determinants and geography in Toronto, Canada: an observational study 2021 Sharmistha Mishra
Huiting Ma
Gary Moloney
Kristy C.Y. Yiu
Dariya Darvin
David Landsman
Jeffrey C. Kwong
Andrew Calzavara
Sharon E. Straus
Adrienne K. Chan
+ PDF Chat Likely community transmission of COVID-19 infections between neighboring, persistent hotspots in Ontario, Canada 2021 Eliseos J. Mucaki
Ben C. Shirley
Peter K. Rogan
+ PDF Chat Likely community transmission of COVID-19 infections between neighboring, persistent hotspots in Ontario, Canada 2022 Eliseos J. Mucaki
Ben C. Shirley
Peter K. Rogan
+ Modelling the spatiotemporal spread of COVID-19 outbreaks and prioritization of the risk areas in Toronto, Canada 2023 Nushrat Nazia
Jane Law
Zahid A Butt
+ PDF Chat Likely community transmission of COVID-19 infections between neighboring, persistent hotspots in Ontario, Canada 2021 Eliseos J. Mucaki
Ben C. Shirley
Peter K. Rogan
+ Increasing concentration of COVID-19 by socioeconomic determinants and geography in Toronto, Canada: an observational study 2021 Sharmistha Mishra
Huiting Ma
Gary Moloney
Kristy C.Y. Yiu
Dariya Darvin
David Landsman
Jeffrey C. Kwong
Andrew Calzavara
Sharon E. Straus
Adrienne K. Chan
+ Covid-19's spatiotemporal patterns within cities: a global comparative study 2023 Emanuele Sciuva
+ PDF Chat Socioeconomic and immigration status and COVID-19 testing in Toronto, Ontario: retrospective cross-sectional study 2022 Braden O’Neill
Sumeet Kalia
Susan Hum
Peter Gill
Michelle Greiver
Abirami Kirubarajan
David Eisen
Jacob Ferguson
Sheila Dunn
+ A spatio-temporal modelling of Covid-19 infections in Toronto’s neighbourhoods 2021 Sze Hang Fu
+ PDF Chat Spatial variations of COVID-19 risk by age in Toronto, Canada 2022 Nushrat Nazia
+ Geographical concentration of COVID-19 cases by social determinants of health in 16 large metropolitan areas in Canada – a cross-sectional study 2021 Yiqing Xia
Huiting Ma
Gary Moloney
Héctor Alexander Velásquez García
Monica Sirski
Naveed Z. Janjua
David Vickers
Tyler Williamson
Alan Katz
Kristy Yu
+ PDF Chat Identifying spatiotemporal patterns of COVID-19 transmissions and the drivers of the patterns in Toronto: a Bayesian hierarchical spatiotemporal modelling 2022 Nushrat Nazia
Jane Law
Zahid A Butt

Works That Cite This (0)

Action Title Year Authors

Works Cited by This (21)

Action Title Year Authors
+ A brief review of spatial analysis concepts and tools used for mapping, containment and risk modelling of infectious diseases and other illnesses 2013 Graziella Caprarelli
Stephanie Fletcher
+ CAN-NPI: A Curated Open Dataset of Canadian Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions in Response to the Global COVID-19 Pandemic 2020 Liam G. McCoy
Jonathan Smith
Kavya Anchuri
Isha Berry
Joanna A. Pineda
Vinyas Harish
Andrew C. L. Lam
Seung Eun Yi
Sophie Hu
Benjamin Fine
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 in Toronto: A Spatial Exploratory Analysis 2021 Eric Vaz
+ The characteristics of multi-source mobility datasets and how they reveal the luxury nature of social distancing in the U.S. during the COVID-19 pandemic 2021 Xiao Huang
Zhenlong Li
Yuqin Jiang
Xinyue Ye
Chengbin Deng
Jiajia Zhang
Xiaoming Li
+ PDF Chat Spatial and temporal trends in social vulnerability and COVID-19 incidence and death rates in the United States 2021 Brian Neelon
Fedelis Mutiso
Noel T. Mueller
John L. Pearce
Sara E. Benjamin‐Neelon
+ Staying at Home Is a Privilege: Evidence from Fine-Grained Mobile Phone Location Data in the United States during the COVID-19 Pandemic 2021 Xiao Huang
Junyu Lu
Song Gao
Sicheng Wang
Zhewei Liu
Hanxue Wei
+ Increasing concentration of COVID-19 by socioeconomic determinants and geography in Toronto, Canada: an observational study 2021 Sharmistha Mishra
Huiting Ma
Gary Moloney
Kristy C.Y. Yiu
Dariya Darvin
David Landsman
Jeffrey C. Kwong
Andrew Calzavara
Sharon E. Straus
Adrienne K. Chan
+ A disproportionate epidemic: COVID-19 cases and deaths among essential workers in Toronto, Canada 2021 Amrita Rao
Huiting Ma
Gary Moloney
Jeffrey C. Kwong
Peter Jüni
Beate Sander
Rafal Kustra
Stefan Baral
Sharmistha Mishra
+ COVID-19 Case Age Distribution: Correction for Differential Testing by Age 2021 David N. Fisman
Amy L. Greer
Gabrielle Brankston
Michael Hillmer
Sheila F. O’Brien
Steven J. Drews
Ashleigh R. Tuite
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 Deaths in the United States: Shifts in Hot Spots over the Three Phases of the Pandemic and the Spatiotemporally Varying Impact of Pandemic Vulnerability 2021 Yoo Min Park
Gregory D. Kearney
Bennett Wall
Katherine A. Jones
Robert Howard
Ray Hylock