Proofs for a price: Tomorrow’s ultra-rigorous mathematical culture

Type: Article
Publication Date: 2024-05-15
Citations: 1
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1090/bull/1823

Abstract

Computational tools might tempt us to renounce complete certainty. By forgoing of rigorous proof, we could get (very) probable results for a fraction of the cost. But is it really true that proofs (as we know and love them) can lead us to certainty? Maybe not. Proofs do not wear their correctness on their sleeve, and we are not infallible in checking them. This suggests that we need help to check our results. When our fellow mathematicians will be too tired or too busy to scrutinize our putative proofs, computer proof assistants could help. But feeding a mathematical argument to a computer is hard. Still, we might be willing to undertake the endeavor in view of the extra perks that formalization may bring—chiefly among them, an enhanced mathematical understanding.

Locations

  • PhilPapers (PhilPapers Foundation)
  • Bulletin of the American Mathematical Society

Ask a Question About This Paper

Summary

Login to see paper summary

Similar Works

Action Title Date Authors
+
The Beauty (?) of Mathematical Proofs 2019-01-01 Catarina Dutilh Novaes
+
Mathematical Proofs: The Genesis of Reasonable Doubt 1976-06-04 Gina Kolata
+
Ugly Mathematics: Why Do Mathematicians Dislike Computer-Assisted Proofs? 2012-10-19 Ulianov Montaño
+
Large-Scale Formal Proof for the Working Mathematician 2017-09-01
+
Formal Versus Rigorous Mathematics: How to Get Your Papers Published 2005-01-01 Erik Rosenthal
Hard Proofs and Good Reasons 2024-10-11 Simon DeDeo
+
Rigorous proof and the history of mathematics: Comments on Crowe 1990-06-01 Douglas Jesseph
+
Understanding mathematical proof — Beyond “Eureka!” 1990-03-01 Ian Winchester
MOTIVATED PROOFS: WHAT THEY ARE, WHY THEY MATTER AND HOW TO WRITE THEM 2019-11-07 Rebecca Lea Morris
Accepted proofs: Objective truth, or culturally robust 2023-01-01 Andrew Granville
Do We Need a Calculus of Weight to Understand Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt? 1988-01-01 David H. Kaye
Mathematics in the Age of the Turing Machine 2013-01-01 Thomas Hales
Mathematics in the Age of the Turing Machine 2013-02-12 Thomas Hales
+
A Joyful Passion for Proofs: The Pied Piper of Mathematics 2000-01-01 Lynn Arthur Steen Paul Hoffman
+
Formal Proofs in Mathematical Practice 2024-01-01 Danielle Macbeth
+
Formal Proofs in Mathematical Practice 2021-01-01 Danielle Macbeth
Revisiting the reliability of published mathematical proofs: where do we go next? 2014-08-22 Joachim Frans Laszlo Kosolosky
Theorems for a Price: Tomorrow's Semi-Rigorous Mathematical Culture 1993-01-01 Doron Zeilberger
+
A Legacy of Elusive Proofs 2011-01-01 Steven G. Krantz
+
In the Eye of the Beholder: Which Proofs are Best? 2020-01-01 Stefan Borgwardt Anke Hirsch Alisa Kovtunova Frederik Wiehr

Cited by (0)

Action Title Date Authors