Reconstructing air shower parameters with MGMR3D

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2023-10-27

Citations: 4

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevd.108.083041

Abstract

Measuring the radio emission from cosmic-ray particle cascades has proven to be a very efficient method to determine their properties such as the mass composition. Efficient modeling of the radio emission from air showers is crucial in order to extract the cosmic-ray physics parameters from the measured radio emission. MGMR3D is a fast semianalytic code that calculates the complete radio footprint, i.e., intensity, polarization, and pulse shapes, for a parametrized shower-current density and can be used in a chi-square optimization to fit a given radio data. It is many orders of magnitude faster than its Monte Carlo counterparts. We provide a detailed comparative study of MGMR3D to Monte Carlo simulations, where, with improved parametrizations, the shower maximum ${X}_{\mathrm{max}}$ is found to have very strong agreement with a small dependency on the incoming zenith angle of the shower. Another interesting feature we observe with MGMR3D is sensitivity to the shape of the longitudinal profile in addition to ${X}_{\mathrm{max}}$. This is achieved by probing the distinguishable radio footprint produced by a shower having a different longitudinal profile than usual. Furthermore, for the first time, we show the results of reconstructing shower parameters for Low-Frequency Array data using MGMR3D, and obtaining a ${X}_{\mathrm{max}}$ resolution of $22\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{g}/{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$ and energy resolution of 19%.

Locations

  • Physical review. D/Physical review. D. - View
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • University of Groningen research database (University of Groningen / Centre for Information Technology) - View - PDF
  • Radboud Repository (Radboud University) - View - PDF
  • Desy publication database (The Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron) - View - PDF
  • VUBIR (Vrije Universiteit Brussel) - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Reconstructing Air Shower Parameters with MGMR3D 2023 P. Mitra
O. Schölten
T. N. G. Trinh
S. Buitink
J. Bhavani
A. Corstanje
M. Desmet
H. Falcke
B. M. Hare
J. R. Hörandel
+ PDF Chat Particle content of very inclined air showers for radio signal modeling 2023 Marion Guelfand
Simon Chiche
Kumiko Kotera
S. Prunet
T. Pierog
+ RDSim, a fast and comprehensive simulation of radio detection of air showers 2023 W. R. Carvalho
Abha Khakurdikar
+ Radio Morphing - towards a fast computation of the radio signal from air-showers 2018 Anne Zilles
O. Martineau‐Huynh
Kumiko Kotera
M. Tueros
K. D. de Vries
W. Rodrigues de Carvalho
V. Niess
+ Air-Shower Radio Simulations - Where we stand and where we go 2023 T. Huege
+ PDF Chat An analytic description of the radio emission of air showers based on its emission mechanisms 2019 Christian GlÀser
S. J. de Jong
M. Erdmann
J.R. Hörandel
+ PDF Chat Radio Morphing - towards a fast computation of the radio signal from air-showers 2019 Anne Zilles
O. Martineau‐Huynh
Kumiko Kotera
M. Tueros
K. D. de Vries
W. Rodrigues de Carvalho
V. Niess
+ Particle content of very inclined air showers for radio signal modeling 2023 Marion Guelfand
Simon Chiche
Kumiko Kotera
S. Prunet
T. Pierog
+ RDSim, a fast and comprehensive simulation of radio detection of air showers 2023 Washington R. de Carvalho
Abha Khakurdikar
+ Radio Morphing - towards a full parametrisation of the radio signal from air showers 2018 Anne Zilles
Didier Charrier
Kumiko Kotera
Sandra Le Coz
O. Martineau‐Huynh
C. Medina
V. Niess
M. Tueros
K. D. de Vries
+ RDSim: A fast, accurate and flexible framework for the simulation of the radio emission and detection of downgoing air showers 2023 Washington R. de Carvalho
Abha Khakurdikar
+ PDF Chat Particle content of very inclined air showers for radio signal modeling 2024 Marion Guelfand
Simon Chiche
Kumiko Kotera
S. Prunet
T. Pierog
+ Air-Shower Radio Simulations -- Where we stand and where we go 2023 T. Huege
+ Radio-Morphing: a fast, efficient and accurate tool to compute the radio signals from air-showers 2022 Simon Chiche
O. Martineau‐Huynh
Kumiko Kotera
M. Tueros
K. D. de Vries
+ A detailed comparison of REAS3 and MGMR simulations for radio emission from EAS 2012 M. Ludwig
T. Huege
O. Schölten
K. D. de Vries
+ PDF Chat Analytic description of the radio emission of air showers based on its emission mechanisms 2017 Christian GlÀser
S. J. de Jong
M. Erdmann
J.R. Hörandel
Erik Willems
+ Proof of principle for template synthesis approach for the radio emission from vertical extensive air showers 2023 M. Desmet
S. Buitink
T. Huege
David Butler
Ralph Engel
O. Schölten
+ RDSim: A fast, accurate and flexible framework for the simulation of the radio emission and detection of downgoing air showers. 2023 W. R. Carvalho
Abha Khakurdikar
+ Radio Measurements of the Depth of Air-Shower Maximum at the Pierre Auger Observatory 2023 The Pierre Auger Collaboration
A. Abdul Halim
P. Abreu
M. Aglietta
I. Allekotte
KĂ©vin Almeida Cheminant
A. Almela
Roberto Aloisio
J. Alvarez‐Muñiz
Juan Ammerman Yebra
+ PDF Chat Radio-Morphing: a fast, efficient and accurate tool to compute the radio signals from air-showers 2021 Simon Chiche
O. Martineau‐Huynh
Kumiko Kotera
M. Tueros
K. D. de Vries

Works Cited by This (19)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Monte Carlo simulations of radio pulses in atmospheric showers using ZHAireS 2011 J. Alvarez‐Muñiz
W. Rodrigues de Carvalho
E. Zas
+ PDF Chat KIC 11285625: A double-lined spectroscopic binary with a<i>Îł</i>Doradus pulsator discovered from<i>Kepler</i>space photometry 2013 J. Debosscher
C. Aerts
A. Tkachenko
K. Pavlovski
C. Maceroni
D. W. Kurtz
P. G. Beck
S. Bloemen
P. Degroote
R. Lombaert
+ PDF Chat An Adaptive Nonlinear Least-Squares Algorithm 1981 J. E. Dennis
David M. Gay
Roy E. Walsh
+ PDF Chat One-dimensional hybrid approach to extensive air shower simulation 2006 Thaisa Storchi‐Bergmann
R. Engel
D. Heck
Н. Н. ĐšĐ°Đ»ĐŒŃ‹ĐșĐŸĐČ
S. Ostapchenko
T. Pierog
T. Thouw
K. Werner
+ PDF Chat LORA: A scintillator array for LOFAR to measure extensive air showers 2014 S. Thoudam
S. Buitink
A. Corstanje
J. Emilio Enriquez
H. Falcke
W. Frieswijk
J.R. Hörandel
A. Horneffer
M. Krause
A. Nelles
+ PDF Chat The air shower maximum probed by Cherenkov effects from radio emission 2013 K. D. de Vries
O. Schölten
K. Werner
+ PDF Chat A macroscopic description of coherent geo-magnetic radiation from cosmic-ray air showers 2007 O. Schölten
K. Werner
Febdian Rusydi
+ PDF Chat Method for high precision reconstruction of air shower<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" display="inline"><mml:mrow><mml:msub><mml:mrow><mml:mi>X</mml:mi></mml:mrow><mml:mrow><mml:mi>max</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:msub></mml:mrow></mml:math>using two-dimensional radio intensity profiles 2014 S. Buitink
A. Corstanje
J. Emilio Enriquez
H. Falcke
J.R. Hörandel
T. Huege
A. Nelles
J. P. Rachen
P. Schellart
O. Schölten
+ PDF Chat Measuring a Cherenkov ring in the radio emission from air showers at 110–190MHz with LOFAR 2014 A. Nelles
P. Schellart
S. Buitink
A. Corstanje
K. D. de Vries
J. Emilio Enriquez
H. Falcke
W. Frieswijk
J.R. Hörandel
O. Schölten
+ PDF Chat Influence of atmospheric electric fields on the radio emission from extensive air showers 2016 T. N. G. Trinh
O. Schölten
S. Buitink
A. M. van den Berg
A. Corstanje
Ute Ebert
J. Emilio Enriquez
H. Falcke
J.R. Hörandel
Christoph Köhn