Measuring cavity powers of active galactic nuclei in clusters using a hybrid X-ray–radio method

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2022-09-12

Citations: 11

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202243936

Abstract

Measurements of the quantity of radio-mode feedback injected by an active galactic nucleus into the cluster environment have mostly relied on X-ray observations, which reveal cavities in the intracluster medium excavated by the radio lobes. However, the sensitivity required to accurately constrain the dimensions of these cavities has proven to be a major limiting factor and is the main bottleneck on high-redshift measurements. We describe a hybrid method based on a combination of X-ray and radio observations, which aims to enhance our ability to study radio-mode feedback. In this paper, we present one of the first samples of galaxy clusters observed with the International LOFAR Telescope (ILT) at 144 MHz and use this sample to test the hybrid method at lower frequencies than before. By comparing our measurements with results found in literature based on the traditional method using only X-ray observations, we find that the hybrid method provides consistent results to the traditional method. In addition, we find that the correlation between the traditional method and the hybrid method improves as the X-ray cavities are more clearly defined. This suggests that using radio lobes as proxies for cavities may help to circumvent systematic uncertainties in the cavity volume measurements. Encouraged by the high volume of unique ILT observations successfully processed, this hybrid method enables radio-mode feedback to be studied at high redshifts for the first time even for large samples of clusters.

Locations

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics - View - PDF
  • Durham Research Online (Durham University) - View - PDF
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • Springer Link (Chiba Institute of Technology) - View - PDF
  • Leiden Repository (Leiden University) - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Measuring cavity powers of active galactic nuclei in clusters using a hybrid X-ray-radio method -- A new window on feedback opened by subarcsecond LOFAR-VLBI observations 2022 R. Timmerman
R. J. van Weeren
A. Botteon
H. J. A Röttgering
B. R. McNamara
F. Sweijen
L. Bîrzan
L. K. Morabito
+ PDF Chat The first high-redshift cavity power measurements of cool-core galaxy clusters with the International LOFAR Telescope 2024 R. Timmerman
R. J. van Weeren
A. Botteon
H. J. A. Röttgering
L. K. Morabito
F. Sweijen
+ PDF Chat The first high-redshift cavity power measurements of cool-core galaxy clusters with the International LOFAR Telescope 2024 R. Timmerman
R. J. van Weeren
A. Botteon
H. J. A. Röttgering
L. K. Morabito
F. Sweijen
+ PDF Chat LOFAR observations of X-ray cavity systems 2020 L. Bırzan
D. A. Rafferty
M. Brüggen
A. Botteon
G. Brunetti
V. Cuciti
A. C. Edge
R. Morganti
H. J. A. Röttgering
T. W. Shimwell
+ PDF Chat PROSPECTS OF HIGH-RESOLUTION X-RAY SPECTROSCOPY FOR ACTIVE GALACTIC NUCLEUS FEEDBACK IN GALAXY CLUSTERS 2009 Sebastian Heinz
M. Brüggen
Brian J. Morsony
+ PDF Chat LOFAR MSSS: The scaling relation between AGN cavity power and radio luminosity at low radio frequencies 2017 G. Kokotanekov
M. W. Wise
G. Heald
J. P. McKean
L. Bırzan
D. A. Rafferty
L. Godfrey
Martijn de Vries
H. T. Intema
J. W. Broderick
+ PDF Chat ViCTORIA project: The LOFAR-MeerKAT view of AGN in Virgo cluster early-type galaxies 2024 Ana Spasić
H. W. Edler
Yan Su
M. Brüggen
F. de Gasperin
T. Pasini
V. Heesen
M. Simonte
A. Boselli
H. J. A. Röttgering
+ PDF Chat Constraining radio mode feedback in galaxy clusters with the cluster radio AGNs properties to <i>z</i> ∼ 1 2020 N. Gupta
M. Pannella
J. J. Mohr
Matthias Klein
E. S. Rykoff
J. Annis
S. Àvila
F. Bianchini
D. Brooks
E. Buckley‐Geer
+ ViCTORIA project: The LOFAR-MeerKAT view of active galactic nuclei in Virgo cluster early-type galaxies 2024 Ana Spasić
H. W. Edler
Yan Su
M. Brüggen
F. de Gasperin
T. Pasini
V. Heesen
M. Simonte
A. Boselli
H. J. A. Röttgering
+ PDF Chat Revived fossil plasma sources in galaxy clusters 2019 S. Mandal
H. T. Intema
R. J. van Weeren
T. W. Shimwell
A. Botteon
G. Brunetti
F. de Gasperin
M. Brüggen
G. Di Gennaro
Ralph Kraft
+ PDF Chat The relation between the diffuse X-ray luminosity and the radio power of the central AGN in galaxy groups 2020 T. Pasini
M. Brüggen
F. de Gasperin
L. Bırzan
Ewan O’Sullivan
A. Finoguenov
M. J. Jarvis
Myriam Gitti
Fabrizio Brighenti
I. H. Whittam
+ PDF Chat Extended X-Ray Emission around FR II Radio Galaxies: Hot Spots, Lobes, and Galaxy Clusters 2021 A. Jimenez-Gallardo
F. Massaro
A. Paggi
R. D’Abrusco
M. Prieto
H. A. Peña-Herazo
Vittoria Berta
F. Ricci
C. Stuardi
B. J. Wilkes
+ Exploring diffuse radio emission in galaxy clusters and groups with the uGMRT and the SKA 2022 Surajit Paul
Ruta Kale
Abhirup Datta
Aritra Basu
Sharanya Sur
Viral Parekh
Prateek Gupta
Swarna Chatterjee
Sameer Salunkhe
Asif Iqbal
+ The eROSITA Final Equatorial-Depth Survey (eFEDS): LOFAR view of brightest cluster galaxies and AGN feedback 2021 T. Pasini
M. Brüggen
D. N. Hoang
V. Ghirardini
Esra Bülbül
Matthias Klein
A. Liu
T. W. Shimwell
M. J. Hardcastle
W. L. Williams
+ PDF Chat X-ray cavities in TNG-Cluster: AGN phenomena in the full cosmological context 2024 Marine Prunier
Julie Hlavacek-Larrondo
Annalisa Pillepich
Katrin Lehle
Dylan Nelson
+ CHEX-MATE: A LOFAR pilot X-ray – radio study on five radio halo clusters 2024 M. Balboni
F. Gastaldello
A. Bonafede
A. Botteon
I. Bartalucci
H. Bourdin
G. Brunetti
R. Cassano
S. De Grandi
Federico De Luca
+ PDF Chat HEATING THE HOT ATMOSPHERES OF GALAXY GROUPS AND CLUSTERS WITH CAVITIES: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN JET POWER AND LOW-FREQUENCY RADIO EMISSION 2011 Ewan O’Sullivan
S. Giacintucci
Laurence David
Myriam Gitti
J. M. Vrtilek
Somak Raychaudhury
T. J. Ponman
+ PDF Chat From outskirts to core: the suppression and activation of radio AGN around galaxy clusters 2024 K de Vos
N. A. Hatch
M. R. Merrifield
+ PDF Chat Particle acceleration in a nearby galaxy cluster pair: the role of cluster dynamics 2019 A. Botteon
R. Cassano
D. Eckert
G. Brunetti
D. Dallacasa
T. W. Shimwell
R. J. van Weeren
F. Gastaldello
A. Bonafede
M. Brüggen
+ PDF Chat First evidence of diffuse ultra-steep-spectrum radio emission surrounding the cool core of a cluster 2018 F. Savini
A. Bonafede
M. Brüggen
R. J. van Weeren
G. Brunetti
H. T. Intema
A. Botteon
T. W. Shimwell
A. Wilber
D. A. Rafferty

Works That Cite This (8)

Action Title Year Authors
+ HETDEX-LOFAR Spectroscopic Redshift Catalog∗ 2024 Maya H. Debski
Gregory R. Zeimann
Gary J. Hill
Donald P. Schneider
L. K. Morabito
Gavin Dalton
M. J. Jarvis
Erin Mentuch Cooper
Robin Ciardullo
Eric Gawiser
+ PDF Chat Cosmic evolution of radio-AGN feedback: confronting models with data 2023 R. Kondapally
P. N. Best
Mojtaba Raouf
Nicole Thomas
Romeel Davé
Stanislav S. Shabala
H. J. A. Röttgering
M. J. Hardcastle
M. Bonato
R. K. Cochrane
+ Radio-AGN activity across the galaxy population: dependence on stellar mass, star-formation rate, and redshift 2024 R. Kondapally
P. N. Best
K. J. Duncan
H. J. A. Röttgering
D. J. B. Smith
I. Prandoni
M. J. Hardcastle
Tanja Holc
A. L. Patrick
Marina I Arnaudova
+ PDF Chat The first high-redshift cavity power measurements of cool-core galaxy clusters with the International LOFAR Telescope 2024 R. Timmerman
R. J. van Weeren
A. Botteon
H. J. A. Röttgering
L. K. Morabito
F. Sweijen
+ PDF Chat A novel radio imaging method for physical spectral index modelling 2023 E. Ceccotti
A. R. Offringa
L. V. E. Koopmans
R. Timmerman
S. A. Brackenhoff
B. K. Gehlot
Florent Mertens
S. Munshi
V. N. Pandey
R. J. van Weeren
+ X-ray cavities in TNG-Cluster: AGN phenomena in the full cosmological context 2024 Marine Prunier
Julie Hlavacek-Larrondo
Annalisa Pillepich
Katrin Lehle
Dylan Nelson
+ First evidence of a connection between cluster-scale diffuse radio emission in cool-core galaxy clusters and sloshing features 2024 N. Biava
A. Bonafede
F. Gastaldello
A. Botteon
M. Brienza
T. W. Shimwell
G. Brunetti
L. Bruno
K. Rajpurohit
C. J. Riseley
+ Central radio galaxies in galaxy clusters: Joint surveys by eROSITA and ASKAP 2023 K. Böckmann
M. Brüggen
B. Koribalski
A. Veronica
T. H. Reiprich
Esra Bülbül
Y. E. Bahar
Frank Balzer
Johan Comparat
C. Garrel

Works Cited by This (57)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Extreme active galactic nucleus feedback and cool-core destruction in the X-ray luminous galaxy cluster MACS J1931.8−2634 2010 Steven R. Ehlert
S. W. Allen
Anja von der Linden
A. Simionescu
Norbert Werner
G. B. Taylor
G. Gentile
H. Ebeling
M. Allen
Douglas Applegate
+ PDF Chat Observational Evidence of Active Galactic Nuclei Feedback 2012 A. C. Fabian
+ PDF Chat Chandra imaging of the complex X-ray core of the Perseus cluster 2000 A. C. Fabian
J. S. Sanders
S. Ettori
G. B. Taylor
S. W. Allen
C. S. Crawford
K. Iwasawa
R. M. Johnstone
P. Ogle
+ The Feedback‐regulated Growth of Black Holes and Bulges through Gas Accretion and Starbursts in Cluster Central Dominant Galaxies 2006 D. A. Rafferty
B. R. McNamara
P. E. J. Nulsen
M. W. Wise
+ PDF Chat Evolution of Buoyant Bubbles in M87 2001 E. Churazov
M. Brüggen
Christian Kaiser
H. Böhringer
W. Forman
+ PDF Chat Baryons at the Edge of the X-ray–Brightest Galaxy Cluster 2011 A. Simionescu
S. W. Allen
A. Mantz
Norbert Werner
Yoh Takei
R. Glenn Morris
A. C. Fabian
J. S. Sanders
P. E. J. Nulsen
Matthew R. George
+ PDF Chat A deep Chandra observation of the active galactic nucleus outburst and merger in Hickson compact group 62 2012 D. A. Rafferty
L. Bırzan
P. E. J. Nulsen
B. R. McNamara
W. N. Brandt
M. W. Wise
H. J. A. Röttgering
+ PDF Chat Galaxy cluster mass profiles 2006 L. M. Voigt
A. C. Fabian
+ PDF Chat Cosmological Effects of Powerful AGN Outbursts in Galaxy Clusters: Insights from an<i>XMM‐Newton</i>Observation of MS 0735+7421 2007 Myriam Gitti
B. R. McNamara
P. E. J. Nulsen
M. W. Wise
+ PDF Chat The Hot Gas Environment of the Radio Galaxy 3C 388: Quenching the Accumulation of Cool Gas in a Cluster Core by a Nuclear Outburst 2006 Ralph Kraft
J. Azcona
W. Forman
M. J. Hardcastle
C. Jones
S. S. Murray