A hybrid Neural Network-SEIR model for forecasting intensive care occupancy in Switzerland during COVID-19 epidemics

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2022-03-03

Citations: 16

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0263789

Abstract

Anticipating intensive care unit (ICU) occupancy is critical in supporting decision makers to impose (or relax) measures that mitigate COVID-19 transmission. Mechanistic approaches such as Susceptible-Infected-Recovered (SIR) models have traditionally been used to achieve this objective. However, formulating such models is challenged by the necessity to formulate equations for plausible causal mechanisms between the intensity of COVID-19 transmission and external epidemic drivers such as temperature, and the stringency of non-pharmaceutical interventions. Here, we combined a neural network model (NN) with a Susceptible-Exposed-Infected-Recovered model (SEIR) in a hybrid model and attempted to increase the prediction accuracy of existing models used to forecast ICU occupancy. Between 1 st of October, 2020 - 1 st of July, 2021, the hybrid model improved performances of the SEIR model at different geographical levels. At a national level, the hybrid model improved, prediction accuracy (i.e., mean absolute error) by 74%. At the cantonal and hospital levels, the reduction on the forecast’s mean absolute error were 46% and 50%, respectively. Our findings illustrate those predictions from hybrid model can be used to anticipate occupancy in ICU, and support the decision-making for lifesaving actions such as the transfer of patients and dispatching of medical personnel and ventilators.

Locations

  • PLoS ONE - View - PDF
  • PubMed Central - View
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) - View
  • Repository for Publications and Research Data (ETH Zurich) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Forecasting the number of intensive care beds occupied by COVID-19 patients through the use of Recurrent Neural Networks, mobility habits and epidemic spread data 2022 Emiliano Valente
Martina Roiati
Francesco Pugliese
+ PDF Chat icumonitoring.ch : a platform for short-term forecasting of intensive care unit occupancy during the COVID-19 epidemic in Switzerland 2020 Cheng Zhao
Burcu Tepekule
Nicola G. Criscuolo
Pedro David Wendel‐Garcia
Matthias P. Hilty
RISC- -ICU Investigators for Switzerland
Thierry Fumeaux
Thomas P. Van Boeckel
+ PDF Chat Multi-wave modelling and short-term prediction of ICU bed occupancy by patients with COVID-19 in regions of Italy 2024 Frederico José Ribeiro Pelogia
Henrique Mohallem Paiva
Roberson Saraiva Polli
+ PDF Chat Covid-19 Patients’ Hospital Occupancy Prediction During the Recent Omicron Wave via some Recurrent Deep Learning Architectures 2022 Heni Bouhamed
Monia Hamdi
R. Gargouri
+ A multistate model and its standalone tool to predict hospital and ICU occupancy by patients with COVID-19 2023 Miguel Lafuente
F. Javier López
Pedro M. Mateo
Ana C. Cebrián
Jesús Asín
José Antonio Moler
Ángel Borque‐Fernando
Luis Esteban
Ana Pérez-Palomares
Gerardo Sanz
+ Incorporation of near-real-time hospital occupancy data to improve hospitalization forecast accuracy during the COVID-19 pandemic 2022 Alexander Preiss
Emily Hadley
Kasey Jones
Marie C. D. Stoner
Caroline Kery
Peter Baumgartner
Georgiy Bobashev
Jessica D. Tenenbaum
Charles W. Carter
K. Clément
+ PDF Chat <i>ABV-CoViD</i>: An Ensemble Forecasting Model to Predict Availability of Beds and Ventilators for COVID-19 Like Pandemics 2022 Vivek Kumar Prasad
Pronaya Bhattacharya
Madhuri Bhavsar
Ashwin Verma
Sudeep Tanwar
Gulshan Sharma
Pitshou N. Bokoro
Ravi Sharma
+ PDF Chat Hospitalization forecast to inform COVID-19 pandemic planning and resource allocation using mathematical models 2022 Philip Wikman‐Jorgensen
Ángel Ruiz
V. Giner
Jara Llenas‐García
José Miguel Seguí‐Ripoll
José María Salinas
E Borrajo
José María Ibarra Sánchez
José P. García-Sabater
Juán A. Marín-García
+ Evaluation of a pragmatic approach to predicting COVID-19-positive hospital bed occupancy 2025 Derryn Lovett
Thomas Woodcock
Jacques Naudé
Julian Redhead
Azeem Majeed
Paul Aylin
+ An ensemble approach to short-term forecast of COVID-19 intensive care occupancy in Italian Regions. 2020 Alessio Farcomeni
Antonello Maruotti
Fabio Divino
Giovanna Jona Lasinio
Gianfranco Lovison
+ Comparison of ARIMA, ETS, NNAR and hybrid models to forecast the second wave of COVID-19 hospitalizations in Italy 2020 Gaetano Perone
+ PDF Chat An ensemble approach to short‐term forecast of COVID‐19 intensive care occupancy in Italian regions 2020 Alessio Farcomeni
Antonello Maruotti
Fabio Divino
Giovanna Jona Lasinio
Gianfranco Lovison
+ PDF Chat Comparison of ARIMA, ETS, NNAR and Hybrid Models to Forecast the Second Wave of COVID-19 Hospitalizations in Italy 2020 Gaetano Perone
+ PDF Chat A Tri-Model Prediction Approach for COVID-19 ICU Bed Occupancy: A Case Study 2023 Nikolaos Stasinos
Anestis Kousis
Vangelis Sarlis
Aristeidis Mystakidis
Dimitrios Rousidis
Paraskevas Koukaras
Ioannis Kotsiopoulos
Christos Tjortjis
+ A Machine Learning-enabled SIR Model for Adaptive and Dynamic Forecasting of COVID-19 2024 Peter Mortensen
Katharina B. Lauer
Stefan Petrus Rautenbach
Marco Gallotta
Natasha Sharapova
Ioannis Takkides
Mike Wright
Mathew Linley
+ PDF Chat Locally Informed Modeling to Predict Hospital and Intensive Care Unit Capacity During the COVID-19 Epidemic 2020 Daniel Fort
Leonardo Seoane
Graham D. Unis
Eboni G. Price‐Haywood
+ PDF Chat Real-time forecasting of COVID-19-related hospital strain in France using a non-Markovian mechanistic model 2024 Alexander Massey
Corentin Boennec
Claudia Ximena Restrepo‐Ortiz
Christophe Blanchet
Samuel Alizon
Mircea T. Sofonea
+ Gecko: A time-series model for COVID-19 hospital admission forecasting 2022 Mark J. Panaggio
Kaitlin Rainwater‐Lovett
Paul J. Nicholas
Mike Fang
Hyunseung Bang
Jeffrey Freeman
Elisha Peterson
Samuel Imbriale
+ PDF Chat A review of mathematical modeling, artificial intelligence and datasets used in the study, prediction and management of COVID-19 2020 Youssoufa Mohamadou
Aminou Halidou
Pascalin Tiam Kapen
+ PDF Chat A data-driven combined prediction method for the demand for intensive care unit healthcare resources in public health emergencies 2024 Weiwei Zhang
Xinchun Li

Works That Cite This (15)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Epidemic modeling using differential equations with implementation in R 2023 Liang Kong
+ PDF Chat Design of effective outpatient sentinel surveillance for COVID-19 decision-making: a modeling study 2023 Kok Ben Toh
Manuela Runge
Reese AK Richardson
Thomas J. Hladish
Jaline Gerardin
+ PDF Chat There is a need for more precise models to assess the determinants of health crises like COVID-19 2023 Alessandro Rovetta
+ Dynamically adjustable SVEIR(MH) model of multiwave epidemics: Estimating the effects of public health measures against COVID‐19 2023 Zuojing Yin
Xiao Han
Stuart McDonald
Vladimir Brusić
Tianyi Qiu
+ PDF Chat Estimating time-varying epidemiological parameters and underreporting of Covid-19 cases in Brazil using a mathematical model with fuzzy transitions between epidemic periods 2024 Hélder Seixas Lima
Unaí Tupinambás
Frederico Gadelha Guimarães
+ A COVID-19 vaccine effectiveness model using the susceptible-exposed-infectious-recovered model 2023 Sabariah Saharan
C J Tee
+ PDF Chat Reproduction number projection for the COVID-19 pandemic 2023 Ryan Lester Benjamin
+ PDF Chat Hybrid Prediction Model Based on Decomposed and Synthesized COVID-19 Cumulative Confirmed Data 2023 Zongyou Xia
Gonghao Duan
Ting Xu
+ A multistate model and its standalone tool to predict hospital and ICU occupancy by patients with COVID-19 2023 Miguel Lafuente
F. Javier López
Pedro M. Mateo
Ana C. Cebrián
Jesús Asín
José Antonio Moler
Ángel Borque‐Fernando
Luis Esteban
Ana Pérez-Palomares
Gerardo Sanz
+ A case for ongoing structural support to maximise infectious disease modelling efficiency for future public health emergencies: A modelling perspective 2023 Epke A. Le Rutte
Andrew J. Shattock
Cheng Zhao
Soushieta Jagadesh
Miloš Balać
Sebastian Alexander Müller
Kai Nagel
Alexander Erath
Kay W. Axhausen
Thomas P. Van Boeckel