Household COVID-19 risk and in-person schooling

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2021-04-29

Citations: 216

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abh2939

Abstract

In-person schooling has proved contentious and difficult to study throughout the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) pandemic. Data from a massive online survey in the United States indicate an increased risk of COVID-19-related outcomes among respondents living with a child attending school in person. School-based mitigation measures are associated with significant reductions in risk, particularly daily symptoms screens, teacher masking, and closure of extracurricular activities. A positive association between in-person schooling and COVID-19 outcomes persists at low levels of mitigation, but when seven or more mitigation measures are reported, a significant relationship is no longer observed. Among teachers, working outside the home was associated with an increase in COVID-19-related outcomes, but this association is similar to that observed in other occupations (e.g., health care or office work). Although in-person schooling is associated with household COVID-19 risk, this risk can likely be controlled with properly implemented school-based mitigation measures.

Locations

  • PubMed Central - View
  • Science - View - PDF
  • medRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory) - View
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Household COVID-19 risk and in-person schooling 2021 Justin Lessler
M. Kate Grabowski
Kyra H. Grantz
Elena Badillo‐Goicoechea
C. Jessica E. Metcalf
Carly Lupton‐Smith
Andrew S. Azman
Elizabeth A. Stuart
+ In-person schooling and associated COVID-19 risk in the United States over spring semester 2021 2022 Kirsten E. Wiens
Claire P. Smith
Elena Badillo‐Goicoechea
Kyra H. Grantz
M. Kate Grabowski
Andrew S. Azman
Elizabeth A. Stuart
Justin Lessler
+ In-person schooling and associated COVID-19 risk in the United States over Spring Semester 2021 2021 Kirsten E. Wiens
Claire P. Smith
Elena Badillo‐Goicoechea
Kyra H. Grantz
M. Kate Grabowski
Andrew S. Azman
Elizabeth A. Stuart
Justin Lessler
+ Children and COVID-19 in schools 2021 Shamez Ladhani
+ The Risk Of Severe COVID-19 Within Households Of School Employees And School-Age Children 2020 Thomas M. Selden
Terceira A. Berdahl
Zhengyi Fang
+ The incidence and magnitude of the health costs of in-person schooling during the COVID-19 pandemic 2021 Casey B. Mulligan
+ The Impact of School Opening Model on SARS-CoV-2 Community Incidence and Mortality: A Nationwide Cohort Study 2021 Zeynep Ertem
Elissa M. Schechter‐Perkins
Emily Oster
Polly van den Berg
Isabella Epshtein
Nathorn Chaiyakunapruk
Fernando A. Wilson
Elli Perenchevich
Warren Pettey
Westyn Branch‐Elliman
+ The role of children in the transmission chain of SARS-CoV-2: a systematic review and update of current evidence 2020 Jonathan E. Suk
Constantine Vardavas
Katerina Nikitara
Revati Phalkey
Jo Leonardi‐Bee
Anastasia Pharris
Emma Wiltshire
Tjede Funk
Lisa Ferland
Nick Bundle
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 mitigation measures in primary schools and association with infection and school staff wellbeing: An observational survey linked with routine data in Wales, UK 2022 Emily Marchant
Lucy Griffiths
Tom Crick
Richard Fry
Joe Hollinghurst
Michaela James
Laura Cowley
Hoda Abbasizanjani
Fatemeh Torabi
Daniel Thompson
+ PDF Chat Low In-School COVID-19 Transmission and Asymptomatic Infection Despite High Community Prevalence 2021 Sophie E. Katz
Rendie McHenry
Lauren G. Mauer
James D. Chappell
Laura S Stewart
Jonathan E. Schmitz
Natasha Halasa
Kathryn M. Edwards
Ritu Banerjee
+ PDF Chat North Carolina public school teachers’ contact patterns and mask use within and outside of school during the prevaccine phase of the COVID-19 pandemic 2021 Kimberly A. Powers
Kristin M. Sullivan
Sabrina Zadrozny
Bonnie E. Shook‐Sa
Rosemary Byrnes
David A. Bogojevich
Douglas Lee Lauen
Peyton Thompson
Whitney R. Robinson
Penny Gordon‐Larsen
+ The role of educational settings in the transmission chain of SARS-CoV-2 in 2020: a systematic review 2021 Constantine Vardavas
Katerina Nikitara
Alexander G. Mathioudakis
Michele Hilton-Boon
Revati Phalkey
Jo Leonardi‐Bee
Anastasia Pharris
Charlotte Deogan
Jonathan E. Suk
+ Preventing COVID-19 Transmission in Education Settings 2021 Sunitha V. Kaiser
Annalisa Watson
BaƟak E. Doğan
Akash Karmur
Kristen Warren
Phoebe Wang
Melisa Camano Sosa
Apryl Olarte
Sherrice Dorsey
Maria Su
+ In-person learning low risk for COVID-19 acquisition: Findings from a population-based analysis of the 2020–2021 school year in Saskatchewan, Canada 2022 Molly A. Trecker
Leanne McLean
Stephanie Konrad
Dharma Yalamanchili
Kristi Langhorst
Maureen Anderson
+ COVID‐19, children and schools: overlooked and at risk 2021 Alasdair Munro
Asha C Bowen
MĂŒge Çevik
+ In-person schooling and COVID-19 transmission in Canada’s three largest cities 2021 Simona Bignami
Yacine Boujija
David N. Fisman
John Sandberg
+ School closures and effective in-person learning during COVID-19 2023 André Kurmann
Étienne LalĂ©
+ PDF Chat Environmental and behavioral factors associated with household transmission of SARS-CoV-2 in children and adolescents 2023 Faétila dos Santos Oliveira
Rafael Alves GuimarĂŁes
Eliane Terezinha Afonso
Lusmaia Damaceno Camargo Costa
Karina Machado Siqueira
Solomar Martins Marques
Claci FĂĄtima Weirich Rosso
Paulo Sucasas Costa
Alessandra Vitorino Naghettini
MarĂ­a Alves Barbosa
+ In-Person Schooling and Juvenile Violence 2025 Benjamin Hansen
Kyutaro Matsuzawa
Joseph J. Sabia
+ PDF Chat School Closures and Effective In-Person Learning during COVID-19: When, Where and for Whom 2021 André Kurmann
Étienne LalĂ©

Works That Cite This (133)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Prevalence of risk behaviors and correlates of SARS-CoV-2 positivity among in-school contacts of confirmed cases in a Georgia school district in the pre-vaccine era, December 2020–January 2021 2022 Marisa Hast
Megan Swanson
Colleen Scott
Emeka Oraka
Catherine Espinosa
Eleanor Burnett
Esther A. Kukielka
Marion E. Rice
Lemlem Mehari
Jazmyn McCloud
+ COVID-19 false dichotomies and a comprehensive review of the evidence regarding public health, COVID-19 symptomatology, SARS-CoV-2 transmission, mask wearing, and reinfection 2021 Kevin EscandĂłn-Vargas
Angela L. Rasmussen
Isaac I. Bogoch
Eleanor J. Murray
Karina EscandĂłn
Saskia Popescu
Jason Kindrachuk
+ Global Monitoring of the Impact of COVID-19 Pandemic through Online Surveys Sampled from the Facebook User Base 2021 Christina M. Astley
Gaurav Tuli
Kimberly A. Mc Cord
Emily Cohn
Benjamin Rader
Samantha Chiu
Xiaoyi Deng
Kathleen Stewart
Tamer H. Farag
Kris M. Barkume
+ PDF Chat Reducing societal impacts of SARS-CoV-2 interventions through subnational implementation 2022 Mark Dekker
Luc E. Coffeng
F. P. Pijpers
Debabrata Panja
Sake J. de Vlas
+ PDF Chat SARS-CoV-2 infection prevention and control measures in Belgian schools between December 2020 and June 2021 and their association with seroprevalence: a cross-sectional analysis of a prospective cohort study 2023 Milena Callies
Ines Kabouche
Isabelle Desombere
Joanna Merckx
Mathieu Roelants
Melissa Vermeulen
Els Duysburgh
+ School District Prevention Policies and Risk of COVID-19 Among In-Person K–12 Educators, Wisconsin, 2021 2022 Peter M. DeJonge
Ian W. Pray
Ronald E. Gangnon
Katherine E. McCoy
Carrie Tomasallo
Jonathan Meiman
+ PDF Chat The Safe Return of Face-to-Face Teaching in the Post-COVID-19 Era at a University in Southern Italy: Surface Monitoring as an Early Warning System 2023 Osvalda De Giglio
Francesco Triggiano
Francesca Apollonio
Canio Buonavoglia
Loredana Capozzi
Michele Camero
Giuseppe Colafemmina
Raffaele Del Prete
Fabrizio Fasano
Gianvito Lanave
+ PDF Chat Effects of School-Based Preventive Measures on COVID-19 Incidence, Hong Kong, 2022 2023 Tim K. Tsang
Xiaotong Huang
Min Whui Fong
Can Wang
Eric H. Y. Lau
Peng Wu
Benjamin J. Cowling
+ Unrepresentative Big Surveys Significantly Overestimate US Vaccine Uptake. 2021 Valerie C. Bradley
Shiro Kuriwaki
Michael Isakov
Dino Sejdinović
Xiao‐Li Meng
Seth Flaxman
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy and Vaccination Coverage in India: An Exploratory Analysis 2022 Pritu Dhalaria
Himanshu Arora
Ajeet Kumar Singh
Mansi Mathur
Ajai Kumar S.

Works Cited by This (14)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Changes in contact patterns shape the dynamics of the COVID-19 outbreak in China 2020 Juanjuan Zhang
Maria Litvinova
Yuxia Liang
Yan Wang
Wei Wang
Shanlu Zhao
Qianhui Wu
Stefano Merler
CĂ©cile Viboud
Alessandro Vespignani
+ PDF Chat Estimating the effects of non-pharmaceutical interventions on COVID-19 in Europe 2020 Seth Flaxman
Swapnil Mishra
Axel Gandy
H. Juliette T. Unwin
Thomas A. Mellan
Helen Coupland
Charles Whittaker
Harrison Zhu
Tresnia Berah
Jeffrey W. Eaton
+ PDF Chat A large COVID-19 outbreak in a high school 10 days after schools’ reopening, Israel, May 2020 2020 Chen Stein‐Zamir
Nitza Abramson
Hanna Shoob
Erez Libal
Menachem Bitan
Tanya Cardash
Refael Cayam
Ian Miskin
+ PDF Chat SARS-CoV-2 Transmission and Infection Among Attendees of an Overnight Camp — Georgia, June 2020 2020 Christine M. Szablewski
Karen Chang
M. M. Lane Brown
Victoria Chu
Anna Yousaf
Ndubuisi Anyalechi
Peter A. Aryee
Hannah L. Kirking
Maranda Lumsden
Erin Mayweather
+ PDF Chat Transmission Dynamics of COVID-19 Outbreaks Associated with Child Care Facilities — Salt Lake City, Utah, April–July 2020 2020 Adriana Lopez
Mary Hill
Jessica Antezano
Dede Vilven
Tyler Rutner
Linda Bogdanow
Carlene Claflin
Ian Kracalik
Victoria L. Fields
Angela Dunn
+ Susceptibility to SARS-CoV-2 Infection Among Children and Adolescents Compared With Adults 2020 Russell Viner
Oliver Mytton
Chris Bonell
G. J. MelĂ©ndez‐Torres
Joseph Ward
Lee Hudson
Claire S. Waddington
James Thomas
Simon Russell
Fiona van der Klis
+ The temporal association of introducing and lifting non-pharmaceutical interventions with the time-varying reproduction number (R) of SARS-CoV-2: a modelling study across 131 countries 2020 You Li
Harry Campbell
Durga Kulkarni
Alice Harpur
Madhurima Nundy
Xin Wang
Harish Nair
+ Effect of specific non-pharmaceutical intervention policies on SARS-CoV-2 transmission in the counties of the United States 2020 Bingyi Yang
Angkana T. Huang
Bernardo García‐Carreras
William E. Hart
Andrea Staid
Matt D. T. Hitchings
Elizabeth C. Lee
Chanelle J. Howe
Kyra H. Grantz
Amy Wesolowksi
+ Household Transmission of SARS-CoV-2: Insights from a Population-based Serological Survey 2020 Qifang Bi
Justin Lessler
Isabella Eckerle
Stephen A. Lauer
Laurent Kaiser
Nicolas Vuilleumier
Derek A. T. Cummings
Antoine Flahault
Duơan Petrović
Idris Guessous
+ SARS-CoV-2 infection and transmission in educational settings: a prospective, cross-sectional analysis of infection clusters and outbreaks in England 2020 Sharif Ismail
Vanessa Saliba
Jamie Lopez Bernal
Mary Ramsay
Shamez Ladhani