Reflection on modern methods: Dynamic prediction using joint models of longitudinal and time-to-event data

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2021-02-26

Citations: 24

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyab047

Abstract

Individualized prediction is a hallmark of clinical medicine and decision making. However, most existing prediction models rely on biomarkers and clinical outcomes available at a single time. This is in contrast to how health states progress and how physicians deliver care, which relies on progressively updating a prognosis based on available information. With the use of joint models of longitudinal and survival data, it is possible to dynamically adjust individual predictions regarding patient prognosis. This article aims to introduce the reader to the development of dynamic risk predictions and to provide the necessary resources to support their implementation and assessment, such as adaptable R code, and the theory behind the methodology. Furthermore, measures to assess the predictive performance of the derived predictions and extensions that could improve the predictions are presented. We illustrate personalized predictions using an online dataset consisting of patients with chronic liver disease (primary biliary cirrhosis).

Locations

  • International Journal of Epidemiology - View - PDF
  • PubMed Central - View
  • EUR Research Repository (Erasmus University Rotterdam) - View - PDF
  • Data Archiving and Networked Services (DANS) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat A Tutorial on Evaluating the Time-Varying Discrimination Accuracy of Survival Models Used in Dynamic Decision Making 2018 Aasthaa Bansal
Patrick J. Heagerty
+ PDF Chat Individual dynamic prediction of clinical endpoint from large dimensional longitudinal biomarker history: a landmark approach 2022 Anthony Devaux
Robin Genuer
Karine PĂ©rĂšs
CĂ©cile Proust‐Lima
+ A tutorial on evaluating time-varying discrimination accuracy for survival models used in dynamic decision-making 2017 Aasthaa Bansal
Patrick J. Heagerty
+ A tutorial on evaluating time-varying discrimination accuracy for survival models used in dynamic decision-making 2017 Aasthaa Bansal
Patrick J. Heagerty
+ Dynamic Predictions 2016 CĂ©cile Proust‐Lima
Paul Blanche
+ Predictive abilities comparison from multiple dynamic prediction models 2023 C Moreau
Jérémie Riou
Marine Roux
+ Dynamic risk score modeling for multiple longitudinal risk factors and survival 2023 Cuihong Zhang
Jing Ning
Jianwen Cai
James E. Squires
Steven H. Belle
Ruosha Li
+ A Dynamic Prediction Model Supporting Individual Life Expectancy Prediction Based on Longitudinal Time-Dependent Covariates 2023 Chengfeng Zhang
Zhaojin Li
Zijing Yang
Baoyi Huang
Yawen Hou
Zheng Chen
+ PDF Chat Joint modeling versus discriminant analysis for dynamic prediction of a binary outcome based on longitudinal data: A simulation study 2020 Rana Dandis
Joanna IntHout
Kit C. B. Roes
Steven Teerenstra
+ Dynamic Methods for the Prediction of Survival Outcomes using Longitudinal Biomarkers 2018 Krithika Suresh
+ Optimizing Dynamic Predictions from Joint Models using Super Learning 2023 Dimitris Rizopoulos
Jeremy M. G. Taylor
+ PDF Chat Optimizing dynamic predictions from joint models using super learning 2024 Dimitris Rizopoulos
Jeremy M. G. Taylor
+ pencal: an R Package for the Dynamic Prediction of Survival with Many Longitudinal Predictors 2023 Mirko Signorelli
+ PDF Chat Dynamic prediction of an event using multiple longitudinal markers: a model averaging approach 2024 Reza Hashemi
Taban Baghfalaki
Viviane Philipps
HĂ©lĂšne Jacqmin‐Gadda
+ Dynamic risk prediction of survival in liver cirrhosis: A comparison of landmarking approaches 2024 Mitchell Paukner
Daniela P. Ladner
Lihui Zhao
+ jmBIG: enhancing dynamic risk prediction and personalized medicine through joint modeling of longitudinal and survival data in big routinely collected data 2024 Atanu Bhattacharjee
Bhrigu Kumar Rajbongshi
Gajendra K. Vishwakarma
+ PDF Chat Dynamic predictions using flexible joint models of longitudinal and time‐to‐event data 2017 Jessica Barrett
Li Su
+ Backward joint model and dynamic prediction of survival with multivariate longitudinal data 2021 Fan Shen
Liang Li
+ Dynamic Risk Prediction 2019 Dimitris Rizopoulos
+ A comparison of two approaches to dynamic prediction: Joint modeling and landmark modeling 2023 Wenhao Li
Liang Li
Brad C. Astor

Works That Cite This (12)

Action Title Year Authors
+ A Dynamic Prediction Model Supporting Individual Life Expectancy Prediction Based on Longitudinal Time-Dependent Covariates 2023 Chengfeng Zhang
Zhaojin Li
Zijing Yang
Baoyi Huang
Yawen Hou
Zheng Chen
+ A comparison of two approaches to dynamic prediction: Joint modeling and landmark modeling 2023 Wenhao Li
Liang Li
Brad C. Astor
+ PDF Chat Illustration of association between change in prostate-specific antigen (PSA) values and time to tumor status after treatment for prostate cancer patients: a joint modelling approach 2023 Madiha Liaqat
Shahid Kamal
Florian Fischer
+ PDF Chat Joint modeling of varying-disease-state longitudinal ordinal data and time-to-event data with application to alzheimer’s disease 2024 XIAOLIN CHANG
M. Chen
+ Bayesian predictive model averaging approach to joint longitudinal‐survival modeling: Application to an immuno‐oncology clinical trial 2023 Zixuan Yao
Satoshi Morita
Sumiyuki Nishida
Haruo Sugiyama
+ PDF Chat Factors associated to the duration of COVID-19 lockdowns in Chile 2022 Jessica Pavani
Jaime Cerda
Luis Gutiérrez
Inés M. Varas
Ivån Gutiérrez
Leonardo Jofré
Oscar Olarte Ortiz
Gabriel Arriagada
+ PDF Chat Fast and flexible inference for joint models of multivariate longitudinal and survival data using integrated nested Laplace approximations 2023 Denis Rustand
Janet van Niekerk
Elias Teixeira Krainski
HĂ„vard Rue
CĂ©cile Proust‐Lima
+ Dynamic risk prediction of survival in liver cirrhosis: A comparison of landmarking approaches 2024 Mitchell Paukner
Daniela P. Ladner
Lihui Zhao
+ PDF Chat Illustration of association between change in prostate-specific antigen (PSA) values and time to tumor status after treatment for prostate cancer patients: A joint modelling approach 2023 Madiha Liaqat
Shahid Kamal
Florian Fischer
+ A sample size analysis of a mathematical model of longitudinal tumor volume and progression‐free survival for Bayesian individual dynamic predictions in recurrent high‐grade glioma 2024 Daniel J. Glazar
Solmaz Sahebjam
Ya-Yu Tsai
Dung‐Tsa Chen
Menal Bhandari
Heiko Enderling

Works Cited by This (27)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data: With Applications in R 2012 Dimitris Rizopoulos
+ PDF Chat Dynamic predictions with time‐dependent covariates in survival analysis using joint modeling and landmarking 2017 Dimitris Rizopoulos
Geert Molenberghs
Emmanuel Lesaffre
+ PDF Chat Individual Prediction in Prostate Cancer Studies Using a Joint Longitudinal Survival–Cure Model 2008 Menggang Yu
Jeremy M. G. Taylor
Howard M. Sandler
+ PDF Chat Combining Dynamic Predictions From Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data Using Bayesian Model Averaging 2014 Dimitris Rizopoulos
Laura A. Hatfield
Bradley P. Carlin
Johanna J.M. Takkenberg
+ Dynamic Predictions and Prospective Accuracy in Joint Models for Longitudinal and Time-to-Event Data 2011 Dimitris Rizopoulos
+ A Joint Model for Survival and Longitudinal Data Measured with Error 1997 Michael Wulfsohn
Anastasios A. Tsiatis
+ PDF Chat Personalized screening intervals for biomarkers using joint models for longitudinal and survival data 2015 Dimitris Rizopoulos
Jeremy M. G. Taylor
Joost van Rosmalen
Ewout W. Steyerberg
Johanna J.M. Takkenberg
+ PDF Chat Individualized Predictions of Disease Progression Following Radiation Therapy for Prostate Cancer 2005 Jeremy M. G. Taylor
Menggang Yu
Howard M. Sandler
+ Regression Modeling Strategies 2015 Frank E. Harrell
+ Assessing the Performance of Prediction Models 2009 Ewout W. Steyerberg
Andrew J. Vickers
Nancy R. Cook
Thomas A. Gerds
Mithat Gönen
Nancy A. Obuchowski
Michael Pencina
Michael W. Kattan