Cross-country evidence on the association between contact tracing and COVID-19 case fatality rates

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2021-01-25

Citations: 46

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-78760-x

Abstract

Abstract The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) outbreak has killed over a million people since its emergence in late 2019. However, there has been substantial variability in the policies and intensity of diagnostic efforts between countries. In this paper, we quantitatively evaluate the association between national contact tracing policies and case fatality rates of COVID-19 in 138 countries. Our regression analyses indicate that countries that implement comprehensive contact tracing have significantly lower case fatality rates. This association of contact tracing policy and case fatality rates is robust in our longitudinal regression models, even after controlling for the number of tests conducted and non-pharmaceutical control measures adopted by governments. Our results suggest that comprehensive contact tracing is instrumental not only to curtailing transmission but also to reducing case fatality rates. Contact tracing achieves the early detection and isolation of secondary cases which are particularly important given that the peak in infectiousness occurs during the presymptomatic phase. The early detection achieved by contact tracing accelerates the rate at which infected individuals receive medical care they need to maximize their chance of recovery. In addition, the combination of reduced transmission and more rapid recovery diminishes the burden on the healthcare system which in turn ensures that the resources remain available for individuals who do become infected.

Locations

  • Scientific Reports - View - PDF
  • PubMed Central - View
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) - View
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Contact Tracing is Associated with Lower COVID-19 Case Fatality Rates: Evidence from 40 countries 2020 Abdullah Yalaman
Gökçe BaƟbuğ
Ceyhun Elgin
Alison P. Galvani
+ Effectiveness of Contact Tracing on Viral Disease Mitigation and Suppression: An Evidence-Based Review (Preprint) 2021 Kelly Jean Thomas Craig
Rubina Rizvi
Van C. Willis
William J. Kassler
Gretchen Purcell Jackson
+ COVID-19 Isolation and Contact Tracing with Country Samples: A Systematic Review 2021 Cemal Koçak
+ Impact of contact tracing on COVID-19 mortality: An impact evaluation using surveillance data from Colombia 2021 Andres I. Vecino‐Ortiz
Juliana Villanueva
Silvana Zapata-Bedoya
Zulma M. CucunubĂĄ
+ PDF Chat Contribution of Testing Strategies and Contact Tracing towards COVID-19 Outbreaks Control: A Mathematical Modeling Study 2022 Shu‐Chen Kuo
Byron Fan
Hongye Zhu
Meng-Hsuan Wu
Fang-Jing Lee
Yu‐Chieh Cheng
Chin‐Fu Hsiao
Ya‐Ting Hsu
Chao A. Hsiung
Shiow‐Ing Wu
+ PDF Chat Effectiveness of Contact Tracing for Viral Disease Mitigation and Suppression: Evidence-Based Review 2021 Kelly Jean Thomas Craig
Rubina Rizvi
Van C. Willis
William J. Kassler
Gretchen Purcell Jackson
+ Impact of contact tracing on COVID-19 mortality: An impact evaluation using surveillance data from Colombia 2020 Andres I. Vecino‐Ortiz
Juliana Villanueva
Silvana Zapata-Bedoya
Zulma M. CucunubĂĄ
+ PDF Chat Comparative effectiveness of contact tracing interventions in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic: a systematic review 2023 Francisco Pozo-Martin
Miguel BeltrĂĄn
Sophie Alice MĂŒller
Viorela Diaconu
Kilian Weil
Charbel El Bcheraoui
+ Effectiveness of contact tracing in the control of infectious diseases: a systematic review 2022 Azfar Hossain
Jana Jarolimova
Ahmed Elnaiem
Cher X. Huang
Aaron Richterman
Louise C. Ivers
+ PDF Chat Global strategies and effectiveness for COVID-19 prevention through contact tracing, screening, quarantine, and isolation: a systematic review 2020 Tadele Girum
Kifle Lentiro
Mulugeta Geremew
Biru Migora
Sisay Shewamare
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 contact tracing in Belgium: main indicators and performance, January – September 2021 2022 Kristiaan Proesmans
Sharon Hancart
Toon Braeye
Sofieke Klamer
Emmanuel Robesyn
Achille Djiena
Frances De Leeuw
Romain Mahieu
Alex Dreuw
NaĂŻma Hammami
+ PDF Chat Effectiveness of contact tracing for COVID-19 in Belgium 2023 Lander Willem
CĂ©cile Kremer
Jorden Boone
Wouter Arråzola de Oñate
NaĂŻma Hammami
Christel Faes
Niel Hens
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 Contact Tracing in Belgium: Main Indicators and Performance, January - September 2021. 2022 Kristiaan Proesmans
Sharon Hancart
Toon Braeye
Sofieke Klamer
Emmanuel Robesyn
Achille Djiena
Frances De Leeuw
Romain Mahieu
Alex Dreuw
NaĂŻma Hammami
+ Empirical evidence on the efficiency of bidirectional contact tracing in COVID-19 2021 Joren Raymenants
Caspar Geenen
Nelissen
Sarah Gorissen
Emmanuel André
+ A rapid systematic review and case study on test, contact tracing, testing, and isolation policies for Covid-19 prevention and control 2020 Sheng‐Chia Chung
Sushila Marlow
Nicholas Tobias
Ivano Alogna
Alessio Alogna
San‐Lin You
+ Evidence of the importance of contact tracing in fighting COVID-19 2022 Okyu Kwon
+ PDF Chat Contact tracing indicators for COVID-19: Rapid scoping review and conceptual framework 2022 Florian Vogt
Karishma Krishna Kurup
Paul Mussleman
Caroline Habrun
Madeleine Crowe
Alexandra Woodward
Giovanna Jaramillo-Gutierrez
John Kaldor
Sirenda Vong
Victor Del Rio Vilas
+ Contact tracing indicators for COVID-19: rapid scoping review and conceptual framework 2021 Florian Vogt
Karishma Krishna Kurup
Paul Mussleman
Caroline Habrun
Madeleine Crowe
Alistair Woodward
Giovanna Jaramillo-Gutierrez
John Kaldor
Sreytouch Vong
VJ Del Rio Vilas
+ PDF Chat Key performance indicators of COVID-19 contact tracing in Belgium from September 2020 to December 2021 2023 CĂ©cile Kremer
Lander Willem
Jorden Boone
Wouter Arråzola de Oñate
NaĂŻma Hammami
Christel Faes
Niel Hens
+ Effectiveness of contact tracing to reduce fatality from COVID-19: preliminary evidence from Colombia 2021 Juliån Alfredo Fernåndez-Niño
C. Peña-Maldonado
Maylen Liseth Rojas-Botero
Laura A. RodrĂ­guez-Villamizar

Works That Cite This (28)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Empirical evidence on the efficiency of backward contact tracing in COVID-19 2022 Joren Raymenants
Caspar Geenen
Jonathan Thibaut
Klaas Nelissen
Sarah Gorissen
Emmanuel André
+ Leveraging the Digital Tracing Alert in Virus Fight: The Impact of COVID-19 Cell Broadcast on Population Movement 2023 Anindya Ghose
Heeseung Andrew Lee
Wonseok Oh
Yoonseock Son
+ PDF Chat Demographic study of patients' mortality rate before and after the COVID‐19 outbreak: A cross‐sectional study 2024 Mehran Kouchek
Kamran Aghakhani
Azadeh Memarian
+ Lessons Learned From COVID-19 Contact Tracing During a Public Health Emergency: A Prospective Implementation Study 2021 Tyler Shelby
Christopher Schenck
Brian Weeks
Justin Goodwin
Rachel Hennein
Xin Zhou
Donna Spiegelman
Lauretta E. Grau
Linda M. Niccolai
Maritza Bond
+ Is There Any Relationship Between the Number of COVID-19 Tests by Country with the Income Inequality of Countries? A Comparison with Income Inequality Metrics 2022 Necati Çıtak
Atilla Pekçolaklar
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 contact tracing during first delta wave, Lebanon, 2021 2022 Maryo Baakliny
Julia Naim
A. Hage
Tatiana Tohmeh
Reem Abdel Malak
Joelle Bassila
Hawraa Sweidan
Mohamad Zein
Darine Wehbeh
Kassem Chaalan
+ Leveraging the Digital Tracing Alert in Virus Fight: The Impact of COVID-19 Cell Broadcast on Population Movement 2024 Anindya Ghose
Heeseung Andrew Lee
Wonseok Oh
Yoonseock Son
+ Integrated PCR testing and extended window contact tracing system for COVID-19 to improve comprehensiveness and speed 2021 Joren Raymenants
Caspar Geenen
Jonathan Thibaut
Sarah Gorissen
Klaas Nelissen
+ PDF Chat “I can’t do it”: A qualitative study exploring case and contact experiences with COVID-19 contact tracing 2022 Tyler Shelby
Cailin Arechiga
Amanda J. Gupta
Rachel Hennein
Christopher Schenck
Brian Weeks
Maritza Bond
Linda M. Niccolai
J. Lucian Davis
Lauretta E. Grau
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 case-fatality variations with application to the Middle East countries 2022 Sami Khedhiri

Works Cited by This (20)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Contact tracing and disease control 2003 Ken Eames
Matt J. Keeling
+ Updated understanding of the outbreak of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019‐nCoV) in Wuhan, China 2020 Weier Wang
Jianming Tang
Fangqiang Wei
+ PDF Chat Feasibility of controlling COVID-19 outbreaks by isolation of cases and contacts 2020 Joel Hellewell
Sam Abbott
Amy Gimma
Nikos I Bosse
Christopher I Jarvis
Timothy Russell
James D. Munday
Adam J. Kucharski
W. John Edmunds
Sebastian Funk
+ PDF Chat COVID-19 epidemic in Switzerland: on the importance of testing, contact tracing and isolation 2020 Marcel Salath
Christian L. Althaus
Richard A. Neher
Silvia Stringhini
Emma B. Hodcroft
Jacques Fellay
Marcel Zwahlen
Gabriela Senti
Manuel Battegay
Annelies Wilder‐Smith
+ PDF Chat Quantifying SARS-CoV-2 transmission suggests epidemic control with digital contact tracing 2020 Luca Ferretti
Chris Wymant
Michelle Kendall
Lele Zhao
Anel Nurtay
Lucie Abeler‐Dörner
Michael Parker
David Bonsall
Christophe Fraser
+ PDF Chat Estimating case fatality rates of COVID-19 2020 Piotr Spychalski
Agata BƂaĆŒyƄska‐Spychalska
Jarek Kobiela
+ Projecting hospital utilization during the COVID-19 outbreaks in the United States 2020 Seyed M. Moghadas
Affan Shoukat
Meagan C. Fitzpatrick
Chad R. Wells
Pratha Sah
Abhishek Pandey
Jeffrey D. Sachs
Zheng Wang
Lauren Ancel Meyers
Burton H. Singer
+ PDF Chat Temporal dynamics in viral shedding and transmissibility of COVID-19 2020 Xi He
Eric H. Y. Lau
Peng Wu
Xilong Deng
Jian Wang
Xinxin Hao
Yiu Chung Lau
Jessica Y. Wong
Yujuan Guan
Xinghua Tan
+ PDF Chat Impact of contact tracing on SARS-CoV-2 transmission 2020 Kaiyuan Sun
CĂ©cile Viboud
+ PDF Chat Epidemiology and transmission of COVID-19 in 391 cases and 1286 of their close contacts in Shenzhen, China: a retrospective cohort study 2020 Qifang Bi
Yongsheng Wu
Shujiang Mei
Chenfei Ye
Xuan Zou
Zhen Zhang
Xiaojian Liu
Lan Wei
Shaun Truelove
Tong Zhang