Starspot rotation rates versus activity cycle phase: Butterfly diagrams of<i>Kepler</i>stars are unlike that of the Sun

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2019-01-11

Citations: 18

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201834373

Abstract

During the solar magnetic activity cycle the emergence latitudes of sunspots change, leading to the well-known butterfly diagram. This phenomenon is poorly understood for other stars as starspot latitudes are generally unknown. The related changes in starspot rotation rates caused by latitudinal differential rotation can however be measured. Using the set of 3093 Kepler stars with activity cycles identified by Reinhold et al. (2017), we aim to study the temporal change in starspot rotation rates over magnetic activity cycles, and how this relates to the activity level, mean rotation rate, and effective temperature of the star. We measure the photometric variability as a proxy for the magnetic activity and the spot rotation rate in each quarter over the duration of the Kepler mission. We phase-fold these measurements with the cycle period. We perform averages over stars with comparable mean rotation rates and effective temperature at fixed activity-cycle phases. We detect a clear correlation between the variation of activity level and the variation of the starspot rotation rate. The sign and amplitude of this correlation depends on the mean stellar rotation and, to a lesser extent, on the effective temperature. For slowly rotating stars (with periods between 15-28 days) the starspot rotation rates are clearly anti-correlated with the level of activity during the activity cycles. A transition is seen at periods of 10-15 days, where stars with effective temperature above 4200K instead show positive correlation. Our results can be interpreted in terms of a stellar "butterfly diagram", but these appear different from the Sun's as the starspot rotation rates are either in phase or anti-phase with the activity level. Alternatively, the activity cycles seen by Kepler are short (around 2.5 years) and may therefore be secondary cycles, perhaps analogous to the solar quasi-biennial oscillations.

Locations

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics - View - PDF
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • GoeScholar The Publication Server of the Georg-August-UniversitĂ€t Göttingen (Georg-August-UniversitĂ€t Göttingen) - View - PDF
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat ACTIVITY ANALYSES FOR SOLAR-TYPE STARS OBSERVED WITH <i>KEPLER</i> . I. PROXIES OF MAGNETIC ACTIVITY 2015 Han He
Huaning Wang
Duo Yun
+ PDF Chat Stellar magnetic activity and variability of oscillation parameters: An investigation of 24 solar-like stars observed by<i>Kepler</i> 2016 René Kiefer
Ariane Schad
G. R. Davies
M. Roth
+ PDF Chat Kepler main-sequence solar-like stars: surface rotation and magnetic-activity evolution 2024 A. R. G. Santos
D. Godoy-Rivera
Adam J. Finley
S. Mathur
R. A. GarcĂ­a
Sylvain Breton
A.-M. Broomhall
+ PDF Chat Stellar activity and rotation of the planet host Kepler-17 from long-term space-borne photometry 2019 A. F. Lanza
Yuri Netto
A. S. Bonomo
H. Parviainen
Adriana VĂĄlio
S. Aigrain
+ PDF Chat Glimpses of stellar surfaces - I. Spot evolution and differential rotation of the planet host star Kepler-210 2016 P. Ioannidis
J. H. M. M. Schmitt
+ Stellar magnetic cycles in the solar-like stars Kepler-17 and Kepler-63 2016 Raissa Estrela
Adriana VĂĄlio
+ Stellar magnetic cycles in the solar-like stars Kepler-17 and Kepler-63 2016 Raissa Estrela
Adriana VĂĄlio
+ PDF Chat STELLAR MAGNETIC CYCLES IN THE SOLAR-LIKE STARS KEPLER-17 AND KEPLER-63 2016 Raissa Estrela
Adriana VĂĄlio
+ PDF Chat Multiscale behaviour of stellar activity and rotation of the planet host Kepler-30 2021 D. B. de Freitas
A. F. Lanza
F. O. da Silva Gomes
M. L. Das Chagas
+ PDF Chat Starspot activity and rotation of the planet-hosting star Kepler-17 2012 A. S. Bonomo
A. F. Lanza
+ PDF Chat Photometric magnetic-activity metrics tested with the Sun: application to<i>Kepler</i>M dwarfs 2014 S. Mathur
D. Salabert
R. A. GarcĂ­a
T. Ceillier
+ Properties of stellar activity cycles 2015 H. Korhonen
+ Properties of stellar activity cycles 2015 H. Korhonen
+ PDF Chat Long-term stellar activity of M dwarfs: A combined K2 and TESS study of two early M-type stars 2024 St. Raetz
B. Stelzer
+ PDF Chat Temporal variation of the photometric magnetic activity for the Sun and <i>Kepler</i> solar-like stars 2023 A. R. G. Santos
S. Mathur
R. A. GarcĂ­a
A.-M. Broomhall
Ricky Egeland
A. Jiménez
D. Godoy-Rivera
Sylvain Breton
Zachary R. Claytor
΀. S. Metcalfe
+ PDF Chat Investigating magnetic activity of F stars with the <i>Kepler</i> mission 2013 S. Mathur
R. A. GarcĂ­a
J. Ballot
T. Ceillier
D. Salabert
΀. S. Metcalfe
C. RĂ©gulo
A. Jiménez
S. Bloemen
+ PDF Chat Time evolution of magnetic activity cycles in young suns: The curious case of <i>Îș</i> Ceti 2021 S. Boro Saikia
T. LĂŒftinger
C. P. Folsom
A. Antonova
E. Alécian
J.‐F. Donati
M. GĂŒedel
J. C. Hall
S. V. Jeffers
O. Kochukhov
+ PDF Chat Looking for activity cycles in late-type Kepler stars using time-frequency analysis 2014 K. Vida
Katalin OlĂĄh
R. SzabĂł
+ PDF Chat Spectroscopic and photometric analysis of 21 chromospherically active variables: Activity cycles and differential rotation 2021 O. Özdarcan
+ PDF Chat Asteroseismic signatures of magnetic activity variations in solar-type stars 2013 ΀. S. Metcalfe

Works That Cite This (16)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat A New Method for Estimating Starspot Lifetimes Based on Autocorrelation Functions 2022 Gibor Basri
Tristan Streichenberger
Connor McWard
Lawrence Edmond
Joanne Tan
Minjoo Larry Lee
Trey Melton
+ PDF Chat Starspot activity of HD199178 Doppler images from 1994-2017 2019 T. Hackman
I. Ilyin
J. Lehtinen
O. Kochukhov
M. J. KÀpylÀ
N. Piskunov
T. Willamo
+ PDF Chat The ExoTETHyS Package: Tools for Exoplanetary Transits around Host Stars 2020 Giuseppe Morello
A. Claret
Marine Martin-Lagarde
Christophe Cossou
Angelos Tsiaras
Pierre-Olivier Lagage
+ Closeby Habitable Exoplanet Survey (CHES). I. Astrometric Noise and Planetary Detection Efficiency Due to Stellar Spots and Faculae 2024 Chunhui Bao
Jianghui Ji
Dongjie Tan
G. Chen
Xiumin Huang
Su Wang
Yao Dong
+ PDF Chat Spot and Facula Activity Variations of the Eccentric Detached Eclipsing Binary KIC 8098300 Based on the Time-series Orbital Solutions 2021 Hubiao Niu
Jian-Ning Fu
Jiaxin Wang
Chunqian Li
+ PDF Chat Flaring latitudes in ensembles of low-mass stars 2023 Ekaterina Ilin
Ruth Angus
Rodrigo Luger
Brett M. Morris
Florian Ulrich Jehn
+ PDF Chat Dynamical Surface Imaging of λ Andromedae 2021 Arturo O. Martinez
Fabien Baron
John D. Monnier
Rachael M. Roettenbacher
J. R. Parks
+ Stellar activity and transits 2021 G. Bruno
M. Deleuil
+ PDF Chat Recovery of TESS Stellar Rotation Periods Using Deep Learning 2022 Zachary R. Claytor
Jennifer L. van Saders
Joe Llama
Peter Sadowski
Brandon Quach
Ellis A. Avallone
+ PDF Chat 10 Years of Stellar Activity for GJ 1243 2020 James R. A. Davenport
Guadalupe Tovar Mendoza
Suzanne L. Hawley

Works Cited by This (29)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Making Sense of Sunspot Decay I: Parabolic Decay Law and Gnevyshev-Waldmeier Relation 1997 K. Petrovay
L. van Driel‐Gesztelyi
+ PDF Chat Testing the recovery of stellar rotation signals from Kepler light curves using a blind hare-and-hounds exercise 2015 S. Aigrain
J. Llama
T. Ceillier
Maria LiduĂ­na das Chagas
James R. A. Davenport
R. A. GarcĂ­a
K. L. Hay
A. F. Lanza
A. McQuillan
T. Mazeh
+ PDF Chat MERIDIONAL CIRCULATION IN SOLAR AND STELLAR CONVECTION ZONES 2015 Nicholas A. Featherstone
Mark S. Miesch
+ PDF Chat Rapidly Rotating Suns and Active Nests of Convection 2008 Benjamin P. Brown
Matthew K. Browning
A. S. Brun
Mark S. Miesch
Juri Toomre
+ PDF Chat Stellar differential rotation from direct star-spot tracking 2002 A. Collier Cameron
J.‐F. Donati
M. Semel
+ PDF Chat PHOTOMETRIC VARIABILITY IN<i>KEPLER</i>TARGET STARS. II. AN OVERVIEW OF AMPLITUDE, PERIODICITY, AND ROTATION IN FIRST QUARTER DATA 2010 Gibor Basri
Lucianne M. Walkowicz
Natalie M. Batalha
Ronald L. Gilliland
Jon M. Jenkins
W. J. Borucki
D. Koch
Douglas A. Caldwell
A. K. Dupree
David W. Latham
+ PDF Chat The dependence of differential rotation on temperature and rotation 2005 J. R. Barnes
A. Collier Cameron
J.‐F. Donati
D. J. James
S. C. Marsden
P. Petit
+ PDF Chat From solar-like to antisolar differential rotation in cool stars 2013 T. Gastine
Rakesh K. Yadav
J. Morin
A. Reiners
J. Wicht
+ PDF Chat A SEISMIC SIGNATURE OF A SECOND DYNAMO? 2010 Stephen T. Fletcher
A.-M. Broomhall
D. Salabert
Sarbani Basu
W. J. Chaplin
Y. Elsworth
R. A. GarcĂ­a
R. New
+ PDF Chat Photospheric magnetic field and surface differential rotation of the FK Com star HD 199178 2004 P. Petit
J.‐F. Donati
J. M. Oliveira
M. AuriĂšre
S. Bagnulo
J. D. Landstreet
F. LigniĂšres
T. LĂŒftinger
S. C. Marsden
D. Mouillet