Square Kilometre Array Science Data Challenge 1: analysis and results

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2020-09-29

Citations: 38

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/staa3023

Abstract

As the largest radio telescope in the world, the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) will lead the next generation of radio astronomy. The feats of engineering required to construct the telescope array will be matched only by the techniques developed to exploit the rich scientific value of the data. To drive forward the development of efficient and accurate analysis methods, we are designing a series of data challenges that will provide the scientific community with high-quality datasets for testing and evaluating new techniques. In this paper we present a description and results from the first such Science Data Challenge (SDC1). Based on SKA MID continuum simulated observations and covering three frequencies (560 MHz, 1400MHz and 9200 MHz) at three depths (8 h, 100 h and 1000 h), SDC1 asked participants to apply source detection, characterization and classification methods to simulated data. The challenge opened in November 2018, with nine teams submitting results by the deadline of April 2019. In this work we analyse the results for 8 of those teams, showcasing the variety of approaches that can be successfully used to find, characterise and classify sources in a deep, crowded field. The results also demonstrate the importance of building domain knowledge and expertise on this kind of analysis to obtain the best performance. As high-resolution observations begin revealing the true complexity of the sky, one of the outstanding challenges emerging from this analysis is the ability to deal with highly resolved and complex sources as effectively as the unresolved source population.

Locations

  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society - View
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • OSTI OAI (U.S. Department of Energy Office of Scientific and Technical Information) - View
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Square Kilometre Array Science Data Challenge 1 2018 Anna Bonaldi
Róbert Braun
+ Square Kilometre Array Science Data Challenge 1. 2018 Anna Bonaldi
Robert N. Braun
+ SKA data challenge 1 2020 Anna Bonaldi
+ SKA data challenge 1 2020 Anna Bonaldi
+ PDF Chat Synthetic observations with the Square Kilometre Array: Development towards an end-to-end pipeline 2023 Aishrila Mazumder
Abhirup Datta
Mayuri Sathyanarayana Rao
Arnab Chakraborty
Saurabh Singh
Anshuman Tripathi
Madhurima Choudhury
+ PDF Chat SKA Science Data Challenge 2: analysis and results 2023 Philippa Hartley
A Bonaldi
Róbert Braun
J. N. H. S. Aditya
Stéphane Aicardi
L. Alegre
Abhijit Chakraborty
Xuelei Chen
S Choudhuri
A. O. Clarke
+ Square Kilometre Array: a concept design for Phase 1 2010 Garrett
J. Jonas
J. M. Cordes
R. T. Schilizzi
Steve Rawlings
David R. DeBoer
+ PDF Chat Caesar source finder: Recent developments and testing 2019 S. Riggi
Fabio Vitello
U. Becciani
C. S. Buemi
F. Bufano
Antonio Calanducci
F. Cavallaro
Alessandro Costa
A. Ingallinera
P. Leto
+ The Square Kilometre Array 2011 Steve Rawlings
R. T. Schilizzi
+ PDF Chat YOLO-CIANNA: Galaxy detection with deep learning in radio data. I. A new YOLO-inspired source detection method applied to the SKAO SDC1 2024 David Cornu
P. Salomé
B. Semelin
A. Marchal
Jonathan Freundlich
S. Aicardi
Xing Lu
G. Sainton
Florent Mertens
F. Combes
+ PDF Chat Key Science Goals for the Next Generation Very Large Array (ngVLA): Update from the ngVLA Science Advisory Council (2024) 2024 David J. Wilner
Brenda C. Matthews
Brett A. McGuire
Jennifer B. Bergner
F. Walter
Rachel S. Somerville
Megan DeCesar
A. J. van der Horst
Rachel A. Osten
A. Corsi
+ The Astrophysics of Star Formation Across Cosmic Time at $\gtrsim$10 GHz with the Square Kilometre Array 2014 E. J. Murphy
M. Sargent
R. Beswick
C. Dickinson
Ian Heywood
L. K. Hunt
Minh T. Hyunh
M. J. Jarvis
A. Karim
M. Krause
+ The Astrophysics of Star Formation Across Cosmic Time at $\gtrsim$10 GHz with the Square Kilometre Array 2014 E. J. Murphy
M. Sargent
R. Beswick
C. Dickinson
Ian Heywood
L. K. Hunt
Minh T. Hyunh
M. J. Jarvis
A. Karim
M. Krause
+ High energy astrophysics with the next generation of radio astronomy facilities 2008 R. P. Fender
+ Square Kilometre Array key science: a progressive retrospective 2014 Christopher L. Carilli
+ Square Kilometre Array key science: a progressive retrospective 2014 Christopher L. Carilli
+ PDF Chat Characterization of the SKA1-Low prototype station Aperture Array Verification System 2 2022 G. Macario
G. Pupillo
G. Bernardi
Pietro Bolli
Paola Di Ninni
G. Comoretto
A. Mattana
Jader Monari
Federico Perini
Marco Schiaffino
+ Characterization of the SKA1-Low prototype station Aperture Array Verification System 2 2021 G. Macario
G. Pupillo
G. Bernardi
Pietro Bolli
Paola Di Ninni
G. Comoretto
A. Mattana
Jader Monari
Federico Perini
Marco Schiaffino
+ Realisation of a low frequency SKA Precursor: The Murchison Widefield Array 2012 S. J. Tingay
+ Realisation of a low frequency SKA Precursor: The Murchison Widefield Array 2012 S. J. Tingay
R. Goeke
Jacqueline N. Hewitt
E. Morgan
R. A. Remillard
Christopher Williams
Judd D. Bowman
D. Emrich
S. M. Ord
T. Booler

Works That Cite This (23)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Astronomical source detection in radio continuum maps with deep neural networks 2022 S. Riggi
Daniel Magro
Renato Sortino
Andrea De Marco
Cristobal Bordiu
Thomas Cecconello
Andrew Hopkins
Joshua Marvil
G. Umana
‬‬‬‬‬‬Eva Sciacca
+ PDF Chat The MeerKAT Absorption Line Survey (MALS) Data Release. I. Stokes I Image Catalogs at 1–1.4 GHz 2024 P. P. Deka
N. Gupta
P. Jagannathan
Srikrishna Sekhar
Emmanuel Momjian
S. Bhatnagar
J. D. Wagenveld
H.-R. Klöckner
J. Jose
S. A. Balashev
+ PDF Chat Intermediate-mass black holes: finding of episodic, large-scale, and powerful jet activity in a dwarf galaxy 2023 Jun Yang
Z. Paragi
S. Frey
Leonid Gurvits
Mai Liao
Xiang Liu
Lang Cui
Xiaolong Yang
Wen Chen
E. Varenius
+ Simulating images of radio galaxies with diffusion models 2024 T. Vičánek Martínez
Nicolás Barón Pérez
M. Brüggen
+ PDF Chat The tiered radio extragalactic continuum (T-RECS) simulation II: H <scp>i</scp> emission and continuum-H <scp>i</scp> cross-correlation 2023 Anna Bonaldi
Philippa Hartley
Tommaso Ronconi
Gianfranco De Zotti
M. Bonato
+ PDF Chat Detecting galaxies in a large H i spectral cube 2022 Abinash Kumar Shaw
Manoj Jagannath
Aishrila Mazumder
Arnab Chakraborty
Narendra Nath Patra
Rajesh Mondal
Samir Choudhuri
+ PDF Chat Morphological classification of radio galaxies with Wasserstein generative adversarial network-supported augmentation 2023 L. Rustige
Janis Kummer
Florian Griese
K. Borras
M. Brüggen
Patrick Connor
Frank Gaede
Gregor Kasieczka
Tobias Knopp
Peter Schleper
+ PDF Chat Radio astronomical images object detection and segmentation: a benchmark on deep learning methods 2023 Renato Sortino
Daniel Magro
Giuseppe Fiameni
‬‬‬‬‬‬Eva Sciacca
S. Riggi
Andrea DeMarco
Concetto Spampinato
Andrew Hopkins
F. Bufano
F. Schillirò
+ PDF Chat Radio source-component association for the LOFAR Two-metre Sky Survey with region-based convolutional neural networks 2022 R. I. J. Mostert
K. J. Duncan
L. Alegre
H. J. A. Röttgering
W. L. Williams
P. N. Best
M. J. Hardcastle
R. Morganti
+ PDF Chat Deep radio-interferometric imaging with POLISH: DSA-2000 and weak lensing 2022 Liam Connor
Katherine L. Bouman
Vikram Ravi
Gregg Hallinan

Works Cited by This (43)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Batch Normalization: Accelerating Deep Network Training by Reducing Internal Covariate Shift 2015 Sergey Ioffe
Christian Szegedy
+ PDF Chat The ALADIN interactive sky atlas 2000 F. Bonnarel
P. Fernique
O. Bienaymé
D. Egret
F. Genova
Mireille Louys
F. Ochsenbein
M. Wenger
J. G. Bartlett
+ PDF Chat RESOLVING THE RADIO SOURCE BACKGROUND: DEEPER UNDERSTANDING THROUGH CONFUSION 2012 J. J. Condon
W. D. Cotton
E. B. Fomalont
K. I. Kellermann
Neal A. Miller
R. A. Perley
D. Scott
Tessa Vernstrom
J. V. Wall
+ scikit-image: image processing in Python 2014 Stéfan van der Walt
Johannes L. Schönberger
Juan Nunez-Iglesias
François Boulogne
Joshua Warner
Neil Yager
Emmanuelle Gouillart
Tony Yu
+ PDF Chat GalSim: The modular galaxy image simulation toolkit 2015 Barnaby Rowe
Mike Jarvis
Rachel Mandelbaum
G. M. Bernstein
James Bosch
Melanie Simet
J. Meyers
Tomasz Kacprzak
R. Nakajima
J. Zuntz
+ PDF Chat THE WIDE-FIELD INFRARED SURVEY EXPLORER (WISE): MISSION DESCRIPTION AND INITIAL ON-ORBIT PERFORMANCE 2010 E. L. Wright
Peter Eisenhardt
Amy Mainzer
Michael E. Ressler
R. M. Cutri
T. H. Jarrett
J. Davy Kirkpatrick
Deborah Padgett
R. S. McMillan
Michael F. Skrutskie
+ PDF Chat Source detection in astronomical images by Bayesian model comparison 2014 Marcus Frean
Anna Friedlander
M. Johnston‐Hollitt
Christopher Hollitt
+ PDF Chat Source extraction and photometry for the far-infrared and sub-millimeter continuum in the presence of complex backgrounds 2011 S. Molinari
E. Schisano
F. Faustini
M. Pestalozzi
A. M. Di Giorgio
S. J. Liu
+ PDF Chat Radio Galaxy Zoo: host galaxies and radio morphologies derived from visual inspection 2015 Julie Banfield
O. I. Wong
Kyle Willett
R. P. Norris
L. Rudnick
Stanislav S. Shabala
Brooke Simmons
C Snyder
Avery Garon
N. Seymour
+ PDF Chat blobcat: software to catalogue flood-filled blobs in radio images of total intensity and linear polarization 2012 C. A. Hales
Tara Murphy
Jonathan Curran
E. Middelberg
B. M. Gaensler
R. P. Norris