Structural analysis of massive galaxies using HST deep imaging at <i>z</i> &lt; 0.5

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2019-12-13

Citations: 11

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201936276

View Chat PDF

Abstract

Context. The most massive galaxies ( M stellar ≥ 10 11 M ⊙ ) in the local Universe are characterized by a bulge-dominated morphology and old stellar populations, in addition to being confined to a tight mass-size relation. Identifying their main components can provide insights into their formation mechanisms and subsequent mass assembly. Aims. Taking advantage of Hubble Space Telescope (HST) CANDELS data, we analyze the lowest redshift ( z &lt; 0.5) massive galaxies in the H and I band in order to disentangle their structural constituents and study possible faint non-axisymmetric features. Methods. Our final sample consists of 17 massive galaxies. Due to the excellent HST spatial resolution for intermediate redshift objects, they are hard to model by purely automatic parametric fitting algorithms. We performed careful single and double (bulge-disk decompositions) Sérsic fits to their galaxy surface brightness profiles. We compare the model color profiles with the observed ones and also derive multi-component global effective radii attempting to obtain a better interpretation of the mass-size relation. Additionally, we test the robustness of our measured structural parameters via simulations. Results. We find that the Sérsic index does not offer a good proxy for the visual morphological type for our sample of massive galaxies. Our derived multi-component effective radii give a better description of the size of our sample galaxies than those inferred from single Sérsic models with GALFIT . Our galaxy population lies on the scatter of the local mass-size relation, indicating that these massive galaxies have not experienced a significant growth in size since z ∼ 0.5. Interestingly, the few outliers are late-type galaxies, indicating that spheroids must reach the local mass-size relation earlier. For most of our sample galaxies, both single- and multi-component Sérsic models with GALFIT show substantial systematic deviations from the observed surface brightness profiles in the outskirts. These residuals may be partly due to several factors, namely a nonoptimal data reduction for low surface brightness features or the existence of prominent stellar haloes for massive galaxies, or they could also arise from conceptual shortcomings of parametric 2D image decomposition tools. They consequently propagate into galaxy color profiles. This is a significant obstacle to the exploration of the structural evolution of galaxies, which calls for a critical assessment and refinement of existing surface photometry techniques.

Locations

  • Astronomy and Astrophysics - View - PDF
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat EPOCHS VI: the size and shape evolution of galaxies since <i>z</i> ∼ 8 with <i>JWST</i> Observations 2023 Katherine Ormerod
Christopher J. Conselice
Nathan Adams
Thomas Harvey
Duncan Austin
James Trussler
Leonardo Ferreira
Joseph Caruana
Geferson Lucatelli
Qiong Li
+ PDF Chat THE STELLAR MASS STRUCTURE OF MASSIVE GALAXIES FROM<i>z</i>= 0 TO<i>z</i>= 2.5: SURFACE DENSITY PROFILES AND HALF-MASS RADII 2013 Daniel Szomoru
Marijn Franx
Pieter van Dokkum
Michele Trenti
G. D. Illingworth
Ivo Labbé
Pascal A. Oesch
+ PDF Chat The structural and size evolution of star-forming galaxies over the last 11 Gyr 2016 Ana Paulino-Afonso
David Sobral
F. Buitrago
J. Afonso
+ PDF Chat A<i>Hubble Space Telescope</i>NICMOS and ACS morphological study of<i>z</i>∼ 2 submillimetre galaxies 2010 A. M. Swinbank
Ian Smail
S. C. Chapman
C. Borys
D. M. Alexander
A. W. Blain
Christopher J. Conselice
L. J. Hainline
R. J. Ivison
+ Galaxy Sizes Since z = 2 from the Perspective of Stellar Mass Distribution within Galaxies 2020 Moein Mosleh
Shiva Hosseinnejad
S. Zahra Hosseini-ShahiSavandi
Sandro Tacchella
+ EPOCHS VI: The Size and Shape Evolution of Galaxies since z ~ 8 with JWST Observations 2023 K. Ormerod
Christopher J. Conselice
Nathan J. Adams
Thomas Harvey
D. Austin
James Trussler
Leonardo Ferreira
Joseph Caruana
Geferson Lucatelli
Qiong Li
+ Stellar masses, sizes, and radial profiles for 465 nearby early-type galaxies: An extension to the<i>Spitzer</i>survey of stellar structure in Galaxies (S<sup>4</sup>G) 2022 A. E. Watkins
H. Salo
E. Laurikainen
S. Díaz-García
Sébastien Comerón
Joachim Janz
A. H. Su
R. Buta
E. Athanassoula
A. Bosma
+ PDF Chat MIDIS. Near-infrared rest-frame morphology of massive galaxies at $3<z<5.5$ in the Hubble eXtreme Deep Field 2024 Luca Costantin
Steven Gillman
Leindert Boogaard
Pablo G. Pérez‐González
E. Iani
Pierluigi Rinaldi
J. Melinder
A. Crespo Gómez
L. Colina
T. R. Greve
+ PDF Chat MORPHOLOGIES OF ∼190,000 GALAXIES AT <i>z</i> = 0–10 REVEALED WITH <i>HST</i> LEGACY DATA. I. SIZE EVOLUTION 2015 Takatoshi Shibuya
Masami Ouchi
Yuichi Harikane
+ PDF Chat <i>HST</i>/WFC3 CONFIRMATION OF THE INSIDE-OUT GROWTH OF MASSIVE GALAXIES AT 0 &lt;<i>z</i>&lt; 2 AND IDENTIFICATION OF THEIR STAR-FORMING PROGENITORS AT<i>z</i>∼ 3 2013 Shannon G. Patel
Pieter van Dokkum
Marijn Franx
Ryan Quadri
Adam Muzzin
Danilo Marchesini
R. Williams
B. Holden
Mauro Stefanon
+ PDF Chat High-redshift Massive Quiescent Galaxies Are as Flat as Star-forming Galaxies: The Flattening of Galaxies and the Correlation with Structural Properties in CANDELS/3D-<i>HST</i> 2019 Allison R. Hill
Arjen van der Wel
Marijn Franx
Adam Muzzin
Rosalind E. Skelton
Iva Momcheva
Pieter van Dokkum
Katherine E. Whitaker
+ PDF Chat The morphologies of massive galaxies at 1 &lt;<i>z</i>&lt; 3 in the CANDELS-UDS field: compact bulges, and the rise and fall of massive discs 2012 V. A. Bruce
J. S. Dunlop
M. Cirasuolo
R. J. McLure
T. A. Targett
Eric F. Bell
Darren Croton
Avishai Dekel
S. M. Faber
Henry C. Ferguson
+ PDF Chat The evolution of the galaxy stellar-mass function over the last 12 billion years from a combination of ground-based and <i>HST</i> surveys 2021 D J McLeod
R. J. McLure
J. S. Dunlop
Fergus Cullen
A C Carnall
K. J. Duncan
+ PDF Chat CANDELS: THE CORRELATION BETWEEN GALAXY MORPHOLOGY AND STAR FORMATION ACTIVITY AT<i>z</i>∼ 2 2013 Bomee Lee
Mauro Giavalisco
Christina C. Williams
Yicheng Guo
Jennifer M. Lotz
Arjen van der Wel
Henry C. Ferguson
S. M. Faber
Anton M. Koekemoer
Norman A. Grogin
+ PDF Chat The Number Densities and Stellar Populations of Massive Galaxies at 3 &lt; z &lt; 6: A Diverse, Rapidly Forming Population in the Early Universe 2022 Z. Cemile Marsan
Adam Muzzin
Danilo Marchesini
Mauro Stefanon
Nicholas Martis
Marianna Annunziatella
J. Chan
Michael C. Cooper
Ben Forrest
Percy Gómez
+ PDF Chat 3D-HST+CANDELS: THE EVOLUTION OF THE GALAXY SIZE-MASS DISTRIBUTION SINCE<i>z</i>= 3 2014 Arjen van der Wel
Marijn Franx
Pieter van Dokkum
Rosalind E. Skelton
Ivelina Momcheva
Katherine E. Whitaker
Gabriel Brammer
Eric F. Bell
Hans‐Walter Rix
Stijn Wuyts
+ PDF Chat The SLUGGS Survey: stellar masses and effective radii of early-type galaxies from<i>Spitzer Space Telescope</i>3.6 μm imaging 2016 Duncan A. Forbes
Luciana Sinpetru
G. Savorgnan
Aaron J. Romanowsky
Christopher Usher
Jean P. Brodie
+ Measuring galaxy morphology at $z&gt;1$. I - calibration of automated proxies 2014 Marc Huertas-Company
Anton M. Koekemoer
A. Raichoor
Nimish P. Hathi
S. Mei
R. W. O’Connell
R. Licitra
Rogier A. Windhorst
Seth H. Cohen
Sugata Kaviraj
+ Evolution of Massive Galaxy Structural Properties and Sizes via Star Formation 2012 Jamie R. Ownsworth
Christopher J. Conselice
Alice Mortlock
William G. Hartley
F. Buitrago
+ CEERS: MIRI deciphers the spatial distribution of dust-obscured star formation in galaxies at $0.1 2023 B. Magnelli
Carlos Gómez-Guijarro
D. Elbaz
E. Daddi
Casey Papovich
Lu Shen
Pablo Arrabal Haro
Micaela B. Bagley
Eric F. Bell
V. Buat

Cited by (9)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Hyper Suprime-Cam Subaru Strategic Program: A Mass-dependent Slope of the Galaxy Size−Mass Relation at z &lt; 1 2021 Lalitwadee Kawinwanichakij
J. D. Silverman
Xuheng Ding
Angelo George
Ivana Damjanov
Marcin Sawicki
Masayuki Tanaka
Dan S. Taranu
Simon Birrer
Song Huang
+ Sub-millimetre galaxies with <i>Webb</i> 2023 Steven Gillman
B. Gullberg
Gabriel Brammer
Aswin P. Vijayan
Minju Lee
David Blánquez Sesé
Malte Brinch
T. R. Greve
Iris Jermann
Shuowen Jin
+ <i>Euclid</i>preparation 2022 H. Bretonnière
Ulrike Kuchner
Marc Huertas-Company
E. Merlin
M. Castellano
D. Tuccillo
F. Buitrago
Christopher J. Conselice
A. Boucaud
Boris Häußler
+ PDF Chat Deep extragalactic visible legacy survey (DEVILS): the emergence of bulges and decline of disc growth since <i>z</i> = 1 2022 Abdolhosein Hashemizadeh
Simon P. Driver
L. J. M. Davies
A. S. G. Robotham
Sabine Bellstedt
Caroline Foster
Benne W. Holwerda
M. J. Jarvis
S. Phillipps
M. Siudek
+ PDF Chat Low-surface-brightness Galaxies are Missing in the Observed Stellar Mass Function 2023 Juhan Kim
Jaehyun Lee
C. Laigle
Yohan Dubois
Yonghwi Kim
Changbom Park
Christophe Pichon
B. K. Gibson
C. Gareth Few
Jihye Shin
+ PDF Chat A possible signature of the influence of tidal perturbations in dwarf galaxy scaling relations 2023 A. E. Watkins
H. Salo
Sugata Kaviraj
C A Collins
J H Knapen
A. Venhola
Javier Román
+ PDF Chat <i>Gaia</i>Data Release 3 2022 C. Ducourant
A. Krone-Martins
L. Galluccio
R. Teixeira
J.-F. Le Campion
E. Slezak
R. de Souza
P. Gavras
F. Mignard
J. Guiraud
+ Machine learning technique for morphological classification of galaxies from SDSS. II. The image-based morphological catalogs of galaxies at 0.02&lt;z&lt;0.1 2022 I. B. Vavilova
Vladislav Khramtsov
D. V. Dobrycheva
M. Yu. Vasylenko
A. Elyiv
О. V. Мelnyk
+ PDF Chat Inside-out star formation quenching and the need for a revision of bulge-disk decomposition concepts for spiral galaxies 2021 P. Papaderos
Iris Breda
A. Humphrey
J. M. Gomes
B. Ziegler
C. Pappalardo

Citing (63)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Statistical Properties of Bright Galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Photometric System 2001 Kazuhiro Shimasaku
M. Fukugita
Mamoru Doi
M. Hamabe
Takashi Ichikawa
Sadanori Okamura
M. Sekiguchi
Naoki Yasuda
J. Brinkmann
István Csabai
+ PDF Chat The influence of diffuse scattered light II. Observations of galaxy haloes and thick discs and hosts of BCGs 2015 C. Sandín
+ Astrophysics Source Code Library 2012 Alice Allen
Kimberly DuPrie
G. Bruce Berriman
R. J. Hanisch
Jessica Mink
Peter Teuben
+ PDF Chat Galaxy merger histories and the role of merging in driving star formation at<i>z</i> &gt; 1 2015 Sugata Kaviraj
Julien Devriendt
Yohan Dubois
Adrianne Slyz
Charlotte Welker
Christophe Pichon
Sébastien Peirani
D. Le Borgne
+ PDF Chat Satellites around massive galaxies since z∼ 2 2012 E. Mármol-Queraltó
Ignacio Trujillo
Pablo G. Pérez‐González
J. Varela
Guillermo Barro
+ PDF Chat Astrophysically motivated bulge-disc decompositions of Sloan Digital Sky Survey galaxies 2012 Claire Lackner
James E. Gunn
+ PDF Chat Compact high-redshift galaxies are the cores of the most massive present-day spheroids 2009 Philip F. Hopkins
Kevin Bundy
Norman Murray
Eliot Quataert
Tod R. Lauer
Chung‐Pei Ma
+ PDF Chat The ALADIN interactive sky atlas 2000 F. Bonnarel
P. Fernique
O. Bienaymé
D. Egret
F. Genova
Mireille Louys
F. Ochsenbein
M. Wenger
J. G. Bartlett
+ PDF Chat Bulge mass is king: the dominant role of the bulge in determining the fraction of passive galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey 2014 Asa F. L. Bluck
J. Trevor Mendel
Sara L. Ellison
Jorge Moreno
Luc Simard
David R. Patton
Else Starkenburg
+ PDF Chat GEMS: The Surface Brightness and Surface Mass Density Evolution of Disk Galaxies 2005 M. Barden
Hans‐Walter Rix
Rachel S. Somerville
Eric F. Bell
B. Häusler
Chien Y. Peng
A. Borch
Steven V. W. Beckwith
J. A. R. Caldwell
Catherine Heymans
+ PDF Chat THE MINOR ROLE OF GAS-RICH MAJOR MERGERS IN THE RISE OF INTERMEDIATE-MASS EARLY TYPES AT<i>z</i>⩽ 1 2010 C. López-Sanjuán
M. Balcells
Pablo G. Pérez‐González
Guillermo Barro
C. E. García-Dabó
J. Gallego
J. Zamorano
+ PDF Chat GEMS: Galaxy Fitting Catalogs and Testing Parametric Galaxy Fitting Codes: GALFIT and GIM2D 2007 Boris Häußler
Daniel H. McIntosh
M. Barden
Eric F. Bell
Hans‐Walter Rix
A. Borch
Steven V. W. Beckwith
J. A. R. Caldwell
Catherine Heymans
K. Jahnkę
+ PDF Chat DETAILED DECOMPOSITION OF GALAXY IMAGES. II. BEYOND AXISYMMETRIC MODELS 2010 Chien Y. Peng
Luis C. Ho
Chris Impey
Hans‐Walter Rix
+ PDF Chat A CATALOG OF BULGE+DISK DECOMPOSITIONS AND UPDATED PHOTOMETRY FOR 1.12 MILLION GALAXIES IN THE SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY 2011 Luc Simard
J. Trevor Mendel
David R. Patton
Sara L. Ellison
Alan W. McConnachie
+ THE STRUCTURES AND TOTAL (MINOR + MAJOR) MERGER HISTORIES OF MASSIVE GALAXIES UP TO<i>z</i>∼ 3 IN THE<i>HST</i>GOODS NICMOS SURVEY: A POSSIBLE SOLUTION TO THE SIZE EVOLUTION PROBLEM 2012 Asa F. L. Bluck
Christopher J. Conselice
F. Buitrago
Ruth Grützbauch
C. Hoyos
Alice Mortlock
A. Bauer
+ PDF Chat The DEEP Groth Strip Survey. II. <i>Hubble Space Telescope</i> Structural Parameters of Galaxies in the Groth Strip 2002 Luc Simard
Christopher N. A. Willmer
Nicole P. Vogt
Vicki L. Sarajedini
Andrew C. Phillips
Benjamin J. Weiner
David C. Koo
Myungshin Im
G. D. Illingworth
S. M. Faber
+ PDF Chat The VIMOS VLT Deep Survey 2011 C. López-Sanjuán
O. Le Fèvre
L. de Ravel
O. Cucciati
O. Ilbert
L. Tresse
S. Bardelli
M. Bolzonella
T. Contini
B. Garilli
+ A CATALOG OF BULGE, DISK, AND TOTAL STELLAR MASS ESTIMATES FOR THE SLOAN DIGITAL SKY SURVEY 2013 J. Trevor Mendel
Luc Simard
Michael J. D. Palmer
Sara L. Ellison
David R. Patton
+ Size Evolution of the Most Massive Galaxies at 1.7 &lt; <i>z</i> &lt; 3 from GOODS NICMOS Survey Imaging 2008 F. Buitrago
Ignacio Trujillo
Christopher J. Conselice
R. J. Bouwens
Mark Dickinson
Haojing Yan
+ Early-type galaxies have been the predominant morphological class for massive galaxies since only z ∼ 1 2012 F. Buitrago
Ignacio Trujillo
Christopher J. Conselice
Boris Häußler
+ Detailed Structural Decomposition of Galaxy Images 2002 Chien Y. Peng
Luis C. Ho
Chris Impey
Hans‐Walter Rix
+ STRUCTURAL PARAMETERS OF GALAXIES IN CANDELS 2012 Arjen van der Wel
Eric F. Bell
Boris Häußler
Elizabeth J. McGrath
Yu-Yen Chang
Yicheng Guo
Daniel H. McIntosh
Hans‐Walter Rix
M. Barden
Edmond Cheung
+ PDF Chat THE RELATION BETWEEN COMPACT, QUIESCENT HIGH-REDSHIFT GALAXIES AND MASSIVE NEARBY ELLIPTICAL GALAXIES: EVIDENCE FOR HIERARCHICAL, INSIDE-OUT GROWTH 2009 Rachel Bezanson
Pieter van Dokkum
Tomer Tal
Danilo Marchesini
Mariska Kriek
Marijn Franx
P. Coppi
+ PDF Chat The size distribution of galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey 2003 Shiyin Shen
H. J. Mo
S. D. M. White
Michael R. Blanton
G. Kauffmann
W. Voges
J. Brinkmann
István Csabai
+ PDF Chat Constraints on the merging channel of massive galaxies since z ∼ 1 2014 Ignacio Ferreras
Ignacio Trujillo
E. Mármol-Queraltó
Pablo G. Pérez‐González
A. Cava
Guillermo Barro
J. Cenarro
A. Hernán-Caballero
N. Cardiel
J. Rodriguez-Zaurín
+ PDF Chat The dominant role of mergers in the size evolution of massive early-type galaxies since<i>z</i> ~ 1 2012 C. López-Sanjuán
O. Le Fèvre
O. Ilbert
L. Tasca
Carrie Bridge
O. Cucciati
P. Kampczyk
L. Pozzetti
C. K. Xu
C. M. Carollo
+ PDF Chat Astropy: A community Python package for astronomy 2013 Thomas Robitaille
Erik Tollerud
P. Greenfield
Michael Droettboom
Erik M. Bray
Tom Aldcroft
M. Ryleigh Davis
Adam Ginsburg
Adrian M. Price-Whelan
Wolfgang Kerzendorf
+ PDF Chat The Millennium Galaxy Catalogue: bulge-disc decomposition of 10 095 nearby galaxies 2006 Paul Allen
Simon P. Driver
Alister W. Graham
Ewan Cameron
J. Liske
R. De Pietri
+ PDF Chat Strong size evolution of the most massive galaxies since <i>z</i> ∼ 2 2007 Ignacio Trujillo
Christopher J. Conselice
Kevin Bundy
Michael C. Cooper
Peter Eisenhardt
Richard S. Ellis
+ PDF Chat The ionized gas in the CALIFA early-type galaxies I. Mapping two representative cases: NGC 6762 and NGC 5966 2012 C. Kehrig
A. Monreal‐Ibero
P. Papaderos
J. M. Vı́lchez
J. M. Gomes
J. Masegosa
S. F. Sánchez
M. D. Lehnert
R. Cid Fernandes
Joss Bland‐Hawthorn
+ PDF Chat A catalogue of 2D photometric decompositions in the SDSS-DR7 spectroscopic main galaxy sample: preferred models and systematics 2014 A. Meert
V. Vikram
Mariangela Bernardi
+ PDF Chat RED NUGGETS AT<i>z</i>∼ 1.5: COMPACT PASSIVE GALAXIES AND THE FORMATION OF THE KORMENDY RELATION 2009 Ivana Damjanov
Patrick J. McCarthy
Roberto Abraham
Karl Glazebrook
Haojing Yan
Erin Mentuch Cooper
D. Le Borgne
S. Savaglio
D. Crampton
Richard Murowinski
+ CANDELS: THE COSMIC ASSEMBLY NEAR-INFRARED DEEP EXTRAGALACTIC LEGACY SURVEY 2011 Norman A. Grogin
Dale D. Kocevski
S. M. Faber
Henry C. Ferguson
Anton M. Koekemoer
Adam G. Riess
Viviana Acquaviva
D. M. Alexander
O. Almaini
M. L. N. Ashby
+ CANDELS: THE COSMIC ASSEMBLY NEAR-INFRARED DEEP EXTRAGALACTIC LEGACY SURVEY—THE <i>HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE</i> OBSERVATIONS, IMAGING DATA PRODUCTS, AND MOSAICS 2011 Anton M. Koekemoer
S. M. Faber
Henry C. Ferguson
Norman A. Grogin
Dale D. Kocevski
David C. Koo
K. Lai
Jennifer M. Lotz
Ray A. Lucas
Elizabeth J. McGrath
+ PDF Chat THE GROWTH OF MASSIVE GALAXIES SINCE<i>z</i>= 2 2010 Pieter van Dokkum
Katherine E. Whitaker
Gabriel Brammer
Marijn Franx
Mariska Kriek
Ivo Labbé
Danilo Marchesini
Ryan Quadri
Rachel Bezanson
G. D. Illingworth
+ PDF Chat Accurate photometric redshifts for the CFHT legacy survey calibrated using the VIMOS VLT deep survey 2006 O. Ilbert
S. Arnouts
H. J. McCracken
M. Bolzonella
E. Bertin
O. Le Fèvre
Y. Mellier
G. Zamorani
R. Pellò
A. Iovino
+ PDF Chat The cosmic assembly of stellar haloes in massive Early-Type Galaxies 2017 F. Buitrago
Ignacio Trujillo
Emma Curtis-Lake
Mireia Montes
Andrew P. Cooper
Victoria Bruce
Pablo G. Pérez‐González
Michele Cirasuolo
+ PDF Chat The fate of high-redshift massive compact galaxies 2016 I. G. de la Rosa
F. La Barbera
Ignacio Ferreras
J. Sánchez Alméida
Claudio Dalla Vecchia
Inma Martínez-Valpuesta
Martin Stringer
+ PDF Chat Red galaxies with pseudo-bulges in the SDSS: closer to disc galaxies or to classical bulges? 2016 B. Ribeiro
C. Lobo
Sonia Antón
J. M. Gomes
P. Papaderos
+ PDF Chat Galaxy And Mass Assembly (GAMA): $\mathcal {M_\star }\text{--}R_{\rm e}$ relations of<i>z</i>= 0 bulges, discs and spheroids 2016 Rebecca Lange
Amanda J. Moffett
Simon P. Driver
A. S. G. Robotham
Claudia del P. Lagos
L. S. Kelvin
Christopher J. Conselice
Berta Margalef-Bentabol
Mehmet Alpaslan
I. K. Baldry