Maximum likelihood estimation of influenza vaccine effectiveness against transmission from the household and from the community

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2017-11-28

Citations: 9

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/sim.7558

Abstract

Influenza vaccination is recommended as the best way to protect against influenza infection and illness. Due to seasonal changes in influenza virus types and subtypes, a new vaccine must be produced, and vaccine effectiveness (VE) must be estimated, annually. Since 2010, influenza vaccination has been recommended universally in the United States, making randomized clinical trials unethical. Recent studies have used a monitored household cohort study design to determine separate VE estimates against influenza transmission from the household and community. We developed a probability model and accompanying maximum likelihood procedure to estimate vaccine-related protection against transmission of influenza from the household and the community. Using agent-based stochastic simulations, we validated that we can obtain maximum likelihood estimates of transmission parameters and VE close to their true values. Sensitivity analyses to examine the effect of deviations from our assumptions were conducted. We used our method to estimate transmission parameters and VE from data from a monitored household study in Michigan during the 2012-2013 influenza season and were able to detect a significant protective effect of influenza vaccination against community-acquired transmission.

Locations

  • PubMed Central - View
  • Deep Blue (University of Michigan) - View - PDF
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View
  • Statistics in Medicine - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Estimated Effectiveness of Influenza Vaccines in Preventing Secondary Infections in Households 2024 Carlos G. Grijalva
Huong Q. Nguyen
Yuwei Zhu
Alexandra M. Mellis
Trey McGonigle
Jennifer K. Meece
Jessica E. Biddle
Natasha Halasa
Carrie Reed
Alicia M. Fry
+ PDF Chat Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness in the Community and the Household 2013 Suzanne E. Ohmit
Joshua G. Petrie
Ryan E. Malosh
Benjamin J. Cowling
Mark G. Thompson
David K. Shay
Arnold S. Monto
+ PDF Chat Application of an Individual-Based Transmission Hazard Model for Estimation of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness in a Household Cohort 2017 Joshua G. Petrie
Marisa C. Eisenberg
Sophia Ng
Ryan E. Malosh
Kyu Han Lee
Suzanne E. Ohmit
Arnold S. Monto
+ PDF Chat Toward unbiased assessment of treatment and prevention: modeling household transmission of pandemic influenza 2012 Gerardo Chowell
Hiroshi Nishiura
+ PDF Chat Estimating Direct and Indirect Protective Effect of Influenza Vaccination in the United States 2017 Nimalan Arinaminpathy
Inkyu Kevin Kim
Paul Gargiullo
Michael Haber
Ivo Foppa
Manoj Gambhir
Joseph S. Bresee
+ PDF Chat An evaluation and update of methods for estimating the number of influenza cases averted by vaccination in the United States 2018 Jerome I. Tokars
Melissa A. Rolfes
Ivo Foppa
Carrie Reed
+ PDF Chat Projecting influenza vaccine effectiveness: A simulation study 2020 Thomas N. Vilches
Affan Shoukat
ClƔudia Pio Ferreira
Seyed M. Moghadas
+ PDF Chat A Bayesian model for evaluating influenza antiviral efficacy in household studies with asymptomatic infections 2009 Yang Yang
M. Elizabeth Halloran
Ira M. Longini
+ PDF Chat Accounting for the spread of vaccination behavior to optimize influenza vaccination programs 2021 Dor Kahana
Dan Yamin
+ PDF Chat Inferring influenza dynamics and control in households 2015 Max S. Y. Lau
Benjamin J. Cowling
Alex R. Cook
Steven Riley
+ PDF Chat A Dynamic Model for Evaluation of the Bias of Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness Estimates From Observational Studies 2018 Kylie E. C. Ainslie
Meng Shi
Michael Haber
Walter A. Orenstein
+ Additional file 3 of Seasonal influenza vaccination in Kenya: an economic evaluation using dynamic transmission modelling 2020 Jeanette Dawa
Gideon O. Emukule
Edwine Barasa
Marc Widdowson
Omu Anzala
Edwin van Leeuwen
Marc Baguelin
Sandra S. Chaves
Rosalind M. Eggo
+ PDF Chat Influenza virus shedding and symptoms: Dynamics and implications from a multi-season household transmission study 2024 Sinead E. Morris
Huong Q. Nguyen
Carlos G. Grijalva
Kayla E. Hanson
Yuwei Zhu
Jessica E Biddle
Jennifer K. Meece
Natasha Halasa
James D. Chappell
Alexandra M. Mellis
+ PDF Chat Predicting the impact of low influenza activity in 2020 on population immunity and future influenza season in the United States 2021 Kyueun Lee
Hawre Jalal
Jonathan M. Raviotta
Mary G. Krauland
Richard K. Zimmerman
Donald S. Burke
Mark S. Roberts
+ PDF Chat Critical Review and Uncertainty Analysis of Factors Influencing Influenza Transmission 2011 Rachael M. Jones
+ Household Transmission of Influenza A Viruses in 2021-2022 2023 Melissa A. Rolfes
H. Keipp Talbot
Huong Q. McLean
Melissa S. Stockwell
Katherine Ellingson
Karen Lutrick
Natalie M. Bowman
Emily E. Bendall
Ayla Bullock
James D. Chappell
+ Influenza virus shedding and symptoms: Dynamics and implications from a multi-season household transmission study 2024 Sinead E. Morris
Huong Q. Nguyen
Carlos G. Grijalva
Kayla E. Hanson
Yuwei Zhu
Jessica E Biddle
Jennifer K. Meece
Natasha Halasa
James D. Chappell
Alexandra M. Mellis
+ PDF Chat Projected Population Benefit of Increased Effectiveness and Coverage of Influenza Vaccination on Influenza Burden in the United States 2019 Michelle M. Hughes
Carrie Reed
Brendan Flannery
Shikha Garg
James A. Singleton
Alicia M. Fry
Melissa A. Rolfes
+ Additional file 1 of Seasonal influenza vaccination in Kenya: an economic evaluation using dynamic transmission modelling 2020 Jeanette Dawa
Gideon O. Emukule
Edwine Barasa
Marc Widdowson
Omu Anzala
Edwin van Leeuwen
Marc Baguelin
Sandra S. Chaves
Rosalind M. Eggo
+ Estimating the generation time for influenza transmission using household data in the United States 2024 Louis Yat Hin Chan
Sinead E. Morris
Melissa S. Stockwell
Natalie M. Bowman
Edwin J. Asturias
Suchitra Rao
Karen Lutrick
Katherine Ellingson
Huong Q. Nguyen
Yvonne Maldonado

Works That Cite This (6)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Mathematical Modeling of Vaccines That Prevent SARS-CoV-2 Transmission 2021 David A. Swan
Ashish Goyal
Chloe Bracis
Mia Moore
Elizabeth M Krantz
Elizabeth R. Brown
Fabian Cardozo-Ojeda
Daniel B. Reeves
Fei Gao
Peter B. Gilbert
+ Vaccines that prevent SARS-CoV-2 transmission may prevent or dampen a spring wave of COVID-19 cases and deaths in 2021 2020 David A. Swan
Ashish Goyal
Chloe Bracis
Mia Moore
Elizabeth M Krantz
Elizabeth R. Brown
Fabian Cardozo-Ojeda
Daniel B. Reeves
Fei Gao
Peter B. Gilbert
+ SARS-CoV-2 Infection in Health Care Personnel and Their Household Contacts at a Tertiary Academic Medical Center: Protocol for a Longitudinal Cohort Study 2021 Emily J. Ciccone
Paul N. Zivich
Evans K. Lodge
Deanna Zhu
Elle A. Law
Elyse Miller
Jasmine Taylor
Suemin Chung
Jason Xu
Alexander Volfovsky
+ Retrospective, Observational Studies for Estimating Vaccine Effects on the Secondary Attack Rate of SARS-CoV-2 2023 Marlena S. Bannick
Fei Gao
Elizabeth R. Brown
Holly Janes
+ Household transmission of influenza A and B within a prospective cohort during the 2013ā€2014 and 2014ā€2015 seasons 2021 F. Scott Dahlgren
Ivo Foppa
Melissa S. Stockwell
Celibell Vargas
Philip LaRussa
Carrie Reed
+ SARS-CoV-2 Infection in Health Care Personnel and Their Household Contacts at a Tertiary Academic Medical Center: Protocol for a Longitudinal Cohort Study (Preprint) 2020 Emily J. Ciccone
Paul N. Zivich
Evans K. Lodge
Deanna Zhu
Elle A. Law
Elyse Miller
Jasmine Taylor
Suemin Chung
Jason Xu
Alexander Volfovsky

Works Cited by This (14)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Influenza Transmission in a Cohort of Households with Children: 2010-2011 2013 Joshua G. Petrie
Suzanne E. Ohmit
Benjamin J. Cowling
Emileigh Johnson
Rachel Cross
Ryan E. Malosh
Mark G. Thompson
Arnold S. Monto
+ Household and Community Transmission Parameters from Final Distributions of Infections in Households 1982 Ira M. Longini
James S. Koopman
+ Estimating Vaccine Efficacy From Secondary Attack Rates 2003 M. Elizabeth Halloran
Marie Pierre PrƩziosi
Haitao Chu
+ Models for the Statistical Analysis of Infectious Disease Data 1988 Michael Haber
Ira M. Longini
George Cotsonis
+ PDF Chat A Limited Memory Algorithm for Bound Constrained Optimization 1995 Richard H. Byrd
Peihuang Lu
Jorge Nocedal
Ciyou Zhu
+ PDF Chat Aerosol transmission is an important mode of influenza A virus spread 2013 Benjamin J. Cowling
Dkm Ip
Vicky J. Fang
Piyarat Suntarattiwong
Sonja J. Olsen
Jens Levy
Timothy M. Uyeki
GM Leung
Malik Peiris
Tawee Chotpitayasunondh
+ PDF Chat Factors associated with influenza vaccine receipt in community dwelling adults and their children 2014 Ryan E. Malosh
Suzanne E. Ohmit
Joshua G. Petrie
Mark G. Thompson
Allison E. Aiello
Arnold S. Monto
+ PDF Chat Time Lines of Infection and Disease in Human Influenza: A Review of Volunteer Challenge Studies 2008 Fabrice Carrat
Elisabeta Vergu
Neil M. Ferguson
Magali LemaƮtre
Simon Cauchemez
Jackie Leach Scully
Alainā€Jacques Valleron
+ PDF Chat Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness in the Community and the Household 2013 Suzanne E. Ohmit
Joshua G. Petrie
Ryan E. Malosh
Benjamin J. Cowling
Mark G. Thompson
David K. Shay
Arnold S. Monto
+ PDF Chat Social Contacts and Mixing Patterns Relevant to the Spread of Infectious Diseases 2008 Joƫl Mossong
Niel Hens
Mark Jit
Philippe Beutels
Kari Auranen
Rafael Mikolajczyk
Marco Massari
Stefania Salmaso
Gianpaolo Scalia Tomba
Jacco Wallinga