Braess paradox in a network of totally asymmetric exclusion processes

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2016-12-21

Citations: 20

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.94.062312

Abstract

We study the Braess paradox in the transport network as originally proposed by Braess with totally asymmetric exclusion processes (TASEPs) on the edges. The Braess paradox describes the counterintuitive situation in which adding an edge to a road network leads to a user optimum with higher travel times for all network users. Travel times on the TASEPs are nonlinear in the density, and jammed states can occur due to the microscopic exclusion principle, leading to a more realistic description of trafficlike transport on the network than in previously studied linear macroscopic mathematical models. Furthermore, the stochastic dynamics allows us to explore the effects of fluctuations on network performance. We observe that for low densities, the added edge leads to lower travel times. For slightly higher densities, the Braess paradox occurs in its classical sense. At intermediate densities, strong fluctuations in the travel times dominate the system's behavior due to links that are in a domain-wall state. At high densities, the added link leads to lower travel times. We present a phase diagram that predicts the system's state depending on the global density and crucial path-length ratios.

Locations

  • Physical review. E - View
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Stochastic Transport Models on Simple Networks: Phase Diagrams and Braess Paradox 2018 Stefan Bittihn
+ PDF Chat Braess paradox in a network with stochastic dynamics and fixed strategies 2018 Stefan Bittihn
Andreas Schadschneider
+ Braess’ Paradox in Networks with Microscopic Stochastic Dynamics and Traffic Information 2020 Andreas Schadschneider
Stefan Bittihn
+ Braess Paradox in Networks of Stochastic Microscopic Traffic Models 2019 Stefan Bittihn
Andreas Schadschneider
+ Exclusion processes on a roundabout traffic model with constrained resources 2023 Ankita Gupta
Arvind Kumar Gupta
+ The Braess Paradox in Dynamic Traffic 2022 Dingyi Zhuang
Yuzhu Huang
Vindula Jayawardana
Jinhua Zhao
Dajiang Suo
Cathy Wu
+ Braess' paradox in a generalised traffic network 2014 Vadim Zverovich
Erel Avineri
+ PDF Chat Totally Asymmetric Simple Exclusion Process on Networks 2011 Izaak Neri
Norbert Kern
Andrea Parmeggiani
+ Theoretical investigation of asymmetric exclusion processes on m-input n-output junctions with random update 2012 Shaoda Li
Ruili Wang
Mingzhe Liu
Yizhang Yin
+ From Individuals to Collectives: Investigating Traffic Flow Dynamics in the Totally Asymmetric Exclusion Process with Driver Behaviour* 2023 Pongrawee Chumworathayee
Watthanan Jatuviriyapornchai
+ PDF Chat A bottleneck model for bidirectional transport controlled by fluctuations 2012 Asja Jelić
CĂ©cile Appert-Rolland
Ludger Santen
+ Traffic Networks: Wardrop Equilibrium and Braess’ Paradox 2021 Vadim Zverovich
+ PDF Chat Braess’ paradox in the age of traffic information 2021 Stefan Bittihn
Andreas Schadschneider
+ Off-ramp on Boundary of Totally Asymmetric Simple Exclusion Process with Different Hopping Rates 2018 Song Xiao
Xiaoyu Chen
Ruquan Liang
Jianhui Shi
Yanna Liu
+ PDF Chat The Braess's Paradox in Dynamic Traffic 2022 Dingyi Zhuang
Yuzhu Huang
Vindula Jayawardana
Jinhua Zhao
Dajiang Suo
Cathy Wu
+ Totally asymmetric simple exclusion process with a shortcut 2007 Yao-Ming Yuan
Rui Jiang
Ruili Wang
Mao-Bin Hu
Qing-Song Wu
+ Braess' Paradox in a Generalised Traffic Network 2012 Vadim Zverovich
Erel Avineri
+ Braess' Paradox in a Generalised Traffic Network 2012 Vadim Zverovich
Erel Avineri
+ PDF Chat The Jammed Phase of the Biham-Middleton-Levine Traffic Model 2005 Omer Angel
Alexander E. Holroyd
James Martin
+ Self-organized criticality in asymmetric exclusion model with noise for freeway traffic 1995 Takashi Nagatani

Works That Cite This (15)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Braess Paradox in Networks of Stochastic Microscopic Traffic Models 2019 Stefan Bittihn
Andreas Schadschneider
+ Theoretical analysis of the distribution of isolated particles in the TASEP: Application to mRNA translation rate estimation 2017 Khanh Dao Duc
Zain H. Saleem
Yun S. Song
+ Dynamics in multi-lane TASEPs coupled with asymmetric lane-changing rates 2017 Yuqing Wang
Bin Jia
Rui Jiang
Ziyou Gao
Wan-He Li
Ke-Jie Bao
Xianze Zheng
+ PDF Chat Braess paradox in a network with stochastic dynamics and fixed strategies 2018 Stefan Bittihn
Andreas Schadschneider
+ PDF Chat Theoretical quantification of interference in the TASEP: Application to mRNA translation shows near-optimality of termination rates 2017 Khanh Dao Duc
Zain H. Saleem
Yun S. Song
+ PDF Chat Exclusion process on two intersecting lanes with constrained resources: Symmetry breaking and shock dynamics 2021 Akriti Jindal
Arvind Kumar Gupta
+ Study of nonequilibrium phase transitions mechanisms in exclusive network and node model of heterogeneous assignment based on real experimental data of KIF3AC and KIF3CC motors 2022 Yuqing Wang
Chang Xu
Mo-Lin Fang
Tianze Li
Liwen Zhang
Da-Sen Wei
Kaichen Ouyang
Tun-Yu Zhang
Chu-Zhao Xu
Hao-Song Sun
+ Braess’ Paradox in Networks with Microscopic Stochastic Dynamics and Traffic Information 2020 Andreas Schadschneider
Stefan Bittihn
+ Rule Derivation for Agent-Based Models of Complex Systems: Nuclear Waste Management and Road Networks Case Studies 2018 García Hernández
Jorge Andrés
+ Theoretical analysis of the distribution of isolated particles in totally asymmetric exclusion processes: Application to mRNA translation rate estimation 2018 Khanh Dao Duc
Zain H. Saleem
Yun S. Song

Works Cited by This (14)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Asymmetric simple exclusion processes with complex lattice geometries: A review of models and phenomena 2012 Mingzhe Liu
Shaoda Li
Ruili Wang
+ Effect of unequal injection rates on asymmetric exclusion processes with junction 2011 Song Xiao
Mingzhe Liu
王建军
Wang Shi Hua
+ PDF Chat Nonequilibrium steady states of matrix-product form: a solver's guide 2007 Richard A. Blythe
M. R. Evans
+ Asymmetric exclusion processes on -input -output junctions with parallel update 2009 Mingzhe Liu
Ruili Wang
+ PDF Chat Totally Asymmetric Simple Exclusion Process on Networks 2011 Izaak Neri
Norbert Kern
Andrea Parmeggiani
+ Totally asymmetric exclusion process on chains with a double-chain section in the middle: Computer simulations and a simple theory 2004 J.G. Brankov
Nina Pesheva
Nadezhda Bunzarova
+ PDF Chat Modeling Cytoskeletal Traffic: An Interplay between Passive Diffusion and Active Transport 2013 Izaak Neri
Norbert Kern
Andrea Parmeggiani
+ PDF Chat Exact solution of a 1D asymmetric exclusion model using a matrix formulation 1993 Bernard Derrida
M. R. Evans
Vincent Hakim
Vincent Pasquier
+ PDF Chat Effects of junctional correlations in the totally asymmetric simple exclusion process on random regular networks 2014 Yongjoo Baek
Meesoon Ha
Hawoong Jeong
+ Understanding totally asymmetric simple-exclusion-process transport on networks: Generic analysis via effective rates and explicit vertices 2009 B. Embley
Andrea Parmeggiani
Norbert Kern