Monsters in the dark: predictions for luminous galaxies in the early Universe from the B<scp>lue</scp>T<scp>ides</scp> simulation

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2016-05-16

Citations: 32

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnrasl/slw100

View Chat PDF

Abstract

Using deep Hubble and Spitzer observations Oesch et al. (2016) have identified a bright ($M_{\rm UV}\approx -22$) star forming galaxy candidate at $z \approx 11$. The presence of GN-$z11$ implies a number density $\sim 10^{-6}\,{\rm Mpc^{-3}}$, roughly an order of magnitude higher than the expected value based on extrapolations from lower redshift. Using the unprecedented volume and high resolution of the BlueTides cosmological hydrodynamical simulation, we study the population of luminous rare objects at $z > 10$. The luminosity function in BlueTides implies an enhanced number of massive galaxies, consistent with the observation of GN-$z11$. We find about 30 galaxies at $M_{\rm UV}\approx -22$ at $z = 11$ in the BlueTides volume, including a few objects about 1.5 magnitudes brighter. The probability of observing GN-$z11$ in the volume probed by Oesch et al. (2016) is $\sim 13$ per cent. The predicted properties of the rare bright galaxies at $z = 11$ in BlueTides closely match those inferred from the observations of GN-$z11$. BlueTides predicts a negligible contribution from faint AGN in the observed SED. The enormous increase in volume surveyed by WFIRST will provide observations of $\sim1000$ galaxies with $M_{\rm UV} < -22$ beyond $z = 11$ out to $z = 13.5$.

Locations

  • Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Letters - View - PDF
  • Sussex Research Online (University of Sussex) - View - PDF
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat The properties of the first galaxies in the BlueTides simulation 2017 Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Christopher C. Lovell
D. Waters
+ PDF Chat The descendants of the first quasars in the BlueTides simulation 2017 Ananth Tenneti
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
ThomasJae Garcia
Yu Feng
+ PDF Chat A tiny host galaxy for the first giant black hole:<i>z</i> = 7.5 quasar in BlueTides 2018 Ananth Tenneti
Stephen M. Wilkins
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Yu Feng
+ PDF Chat The MassiveBlack-II simulation: the evolution of haloes and galaxies to z ∌ 0 2015 Nishikanta Khandai
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Evan Tucker
Colin DeGraf
Maosheng Liu
+ PDF Chat The host galaxies of <i>z</i> = 7 quasars: predictions from the <scp>BlueTides</scp> simulation 2020 Madeline A. Marshall
Yueying Ni
Tiziana Di Matteo
J. Stuart B. Wyithe
Stephen M. Wilkins
Rupert A. C. Croft
Jussi K Kuusisto
+ PDF Chat BlueTides simulation: establishing black hole−galaxy relations at high redshift 2018 Kuan‐Wei Huang
Tiziana Di Matteo
Aklant K. Bhowmick
Yu Feng
Chung‐Pei Ma
+ PDF Chat The BlueTides simulation: first galaxies and reionization 2015 Yu Feng
Tiziana DiMatteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Simeon Bird
Nicholas Battaglia
Stephen M. Wilkins
+ TRINITY IV: Predictions for Supermassive Black Holes at $z \gtrsim 7$ 2023 Haowen Zhang
Peter Behroozi
Marta Volonteri
Joseph Silk
Xiaohui Fan
James Aird
Jinyi Yang
Feige Wang
Philip F. Hopkins
+ PDF Chat Introducing<scp>romulusc</scp>: a cosmological simulation of a galaxy cluster with an unprecedented resolution 2018 Michael Tremmel
Thomas Quinn
Angelo Ricarte
Arif Babul
Urmila Chadayammuri
Priyamvada Natarajan
Daisuke Nagai
Andrew Pontzen
Marta Volonteri
+ PDF Chat Halo occupation distribution (HOD) modelling of high redshift galaxies using the BlueTides simulation 2018 Aklant K. Bhowmick
Duncan Campbell
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
+ PDF Chat The origin of the most massive black holes at high-z: BlueTides and the next quasar frontier 2017 Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Yu Feng
D. Waters
Stephen M. Wilkins
+ PDF Chat <scp>AbacusHOD</scp>: a highly efficient extended multitracer HOD framework and its application to BOSS and eBOSS data 2021 Sihan Yuan
Lehman H. Garrison
Boryana Hadzhiyska
Sownak Bose
Daniel J. Eisenstein
+ PDF Chat The clustering of z &gt; 7 galaxies: predictions from the BLUETIDES simulation 2017 Aklant K. Bhowmick
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
François Lanusse
+ COSMOS-Web: Intrinsically Luminous z$\gtrsim$10 Galaxy Candidates Test Early Stellar Mass Assembly 2023 Caitlin M. Casey
Hollis B. Akins
Marko Shuntov
O. Ilbert
Louise Paquereau
Maximilien Franco
Christopher C. Hayward
Steven L. Finkelstein
Michael Boylan-Kolchin
Brant Robertson
+ PDF Chat Properties of simulated galaxies and supermassive black holes in cosmic voids 2020 MĂ©lanie Habouzit
Alice Pisani
Andy D. Goulding
Yohan Dubois
Rachel S. Somerville
Jenny E. Greene
+ Sizes and Stellar Masses of the Little Red Dots Imply Immense Stellar Densities 2024 Carl Audric Guia
Fabio Pacucci
Dale D. Kocevski
+ PDF Chat The nature of submillimetre galaxies in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations 2010 Romeel Davé
Kristian Finlator
Benjamin D. Oppenheimer
Mark A. Fardal
Neal Katz
DuĆĄan KereĆĄ
David H. Weinberg
+ PDF Chat Investigating cosmic strings using large-volume hydrodynamical simulations in the context of JWST's massive UV-bright galaxies 2024 Sven P. K. Koehler
Hao Jiao
Rahul Kannan
+ PDF Chat FORECASTOR -- II. Simulating Galaxy Surveys with the Cosmological Advanced Survey Telescope for Optical and UV Research 2024 Madeline A. Marshall
Laurie Amen
Tyrone E. Woods
Patrick CÎté
L. Y. Aaron Yung
M. Amenouche
Emily K. Pass
Michael L. Balogh
Samir Salim
T. Moutard
+ PDF Chat "Little Red Dots" cannot reside in the same dark matter halos as comparably luminous unobscured quasars 2024 Elia Pizzati
Joseph F. Hennawi
Joop Schaye
Anna–Christina Eilers
Huang Jia-mu
Jan–Torge Schindler
Feige Wang

Cited by (29)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat A minimalist feedback-regulated model for galaxy formation during the epoch of reionization 2017 Steven R. Furlanetto
Jordan Mirocha
Richard H. Mebane
Guochao Sun
+ PDF Chat “Zombie” or active? An alternative explanation to the properties of star-forming galaxies at high redshift 2018 Francesco Gabriele Saturni
Mattia Mancini
Edwige Pezzulli
Francesco Tombesi
+ PDF Chat Halo occupation distribution (HOD) modelling of high redshift galaxies using the BlueTides simulation 2018 Aklant K. Bhowmick
Duncan Campbell
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
+ PDF Chat BlueTides simulation: establishing black hole−galaxy relations at high redshift 2018 Kuan‐Wei Huang
Tiziana Di Matteo
Aklant K. Bhowmick
Yu Feng
Chung‐Pei Ma
+ PDF Chat The early growth of supermassive black holes in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations with constrained Gaussian realizations 2020 Kuan‐Wei Huang
Yueying Ni
Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
+ PDF Chat The Brightest z ≳ 8 Galaxies over the COSMOS UltraVISTA Field 2019 Mauro Stefanon
Ivo Labbé
R. J. Bouwens
Pascal A. Oesch
M. L. N. Ashby
K. I. Caputi
Marijn Franx
J. P. U. Fynbo
G. D. Illingworth
O. Le FĂšvre
+ PDF Chat Dynamical friction modelling of massive black holes in cosmological simulations and effects on merger rate predictions 2021 Nianyi Chen
Yueying Ni
Michael Tremmel
Tiziana Di Matteo
Simeon Bird
Colin DeGraf
Yu Feng
+ PDF Chat Primordial Black Holes and Modification of Zeldovich–Novikov Mechanism 2021 A. D. Dolgov
К. А. ĐŸĐŸŃŃ‚ĐœĐŸĐČ
+ PDF Chat A cosmological solution to the Impossibly Early Galaxy Problem 2018 Manoj K. Yennapureddy
Fulvio Melia
+ PDF Chat Young and turbulent: the early life of massive galaxy progenitors 2017 Davide Fiacconi
Lucio Mayer
Piero Madau
Alessandro Lupi
Massimo Dotti
Francesco Haardt
+ PDF Chat Massive primordial black holes in contemporary and young universe (old predictions and new data) 2018 A. D. Dolgov
+ PDF Chat Not all peaks are created equal: the early growth of supermassive black holes 2021 Yueying Ni
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
+ Two Remarkably Luminous Galaxy Candidates at z ≈ 10–12 Revealed by JWST 2022 Rohan P. Naidu
Pascal A. Oesch
Pieter van Dokkum
Erica J. Nelson
Katherine A. Suess
Gabriel Brammer
Katherine E. Whitaker
G. D. Illingworth
R. J. Bouwens
Sandro Tacchella
+ PDF Chat Dust-obscured star-forming galaxies in the early universe 2017 Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Christopher C. Lovell
P. Thomas
+ PDF Chat The Cosmic Web around the Brightest Galaxies during the Epoch of Reionization 2018 Keven Ren
Michele Trenti
Simon J. Mutch
+ PDF Chat Evidence for GN-z11 as a luminous galaxy at redshift 10.957 2020 Linhua Jiang
Nobunari Kashikawa
Shu Wang
Gregory Walth
Luis C. Ho
Zheng Cai
Eiichi Egami
Xiaohui Fan
Kei Ito
Yongming Liang
+ PDF Chat Massive and supermassive black holes in the contemporary and early Universe and problems in cosmology and astrophysics 2017 A. D. Dolgov
+ PDF Chat Nebular-line emission during the Epoch of Reionization 2020 Stephen M. Wilkins
Christopher C. Lovell
Ciaran Fairhurst
Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Jussi K Kuusisto
Aswin P. Vijayan
P. Thomas
+ PDF Chat Stacking redshifted 21 cm images of H <scp>ii</scp> regions around high-redshift galaxies as a probe of early reionization 2020 James Edward Davies
Rupert A. C. Croft
Tiziana DiMatteo
Bradley Greig
Yu Feng
J. Stuart B. Wyithe
+ PDF Chat QSO obscuration at high redshift (<i>z</i> ≳ 7): predictions from the <scp>bluetides</scp> simulation 2020 Yueying Ni
Tiziana Di Matteo
R. Gilli
Rupert A. C. Croft
Yu Feng
Colin Norman
+ PDF Chat Cosmic variance of <i>z</i> &amp;gt; 7 galaxies: prediction from <scp>bluetides</scp> 2020 Aklant K. Bhowmick
Rachel S. Somerville
Tiziana Di Matteo
Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Ananth Tenneti
+ Primordial Black Holes Around Us Now, Long Before, and Far away 2020 A. D. Dolgov
+ PDF Chat The Diversity of Environments around Luminous Quasars at Redshift z ∌ 6 2021 Keven Ren
Michele Trenti
Madeline A. Marshall
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yueying Ni
+ PDF Chat Forecasts for the<i>WFIRST</i>High Latitude Survey using the BlueTides simulation 2016 D. Waters
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
Stephen M. Wilkins
Rupert A. C. Croft
+ Massive Primordial Black Holes 2019 A. D. Dolgov
+ PDF Chat Dark-ages reionization and galaxy-formation simulation– VI. The origins and fate of the highest known redshift galaxy 2016 Simon J. Mutch
Chuanwu Liu
Gregory B. Poole
Paul M. Geil
Alan R. Duffy
Michele Trenti
Pascal A. Oesch
G. D. Illingworth
Andrei Mesinger
J. Stuart B. Wyithe
+ PDF Chat The clustering of z &gt; 7 galaxies: predictions from the BLUETIDES simulation 2017 Aklant K. Bhowmick
Tiziana Di Matteo
Yu Feng
François Lanusse
+ PDF Chat The properties of the first galaxies in the BlueTides simulation 2017 Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Christopher C. Lovell
D. Waters
+ Primordial Black holes and Modification of Zeldovich-Novikov Mechanism 2020 A.D. Dolgov
К. А. ĐŸĐŸŃŃ‚ĐœĐŸĐČ

Citing (22)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat The BlueTides simulation: first galaxies and reionization 2015 Yu Feng
Tiziana DiMatteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Simeon Bird
Nicholas Battaglia
Stephen M. Wilkins
+ PDF Chat THE FORMATION OF MILKY WAY–MASS DISK GALAXIES IN THE FIRST 500 MILLION YEARS OF A COLD DARK MATTER UNIVERSE 2015 Yu Feng
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Ananth Tenneti
Simeon Bird
Nicholas Battaglia
Stephen M. Wilkins
+ Most Luminous z=9-10 Galaxies: A First Determination of the Bright End of the z~9 and z~10 UV Luminosity Functions using all five CANDELS Fields 2015 R. J. Bouwens
Pascal A. Oesch
Ivo Labbé
G. D. Illingworth
G. G. Fazio
Dan Coe
Benne W. Holwerda
Renske Smit
Mauro Stefanon
Pieter van Dokkum
+ PDF Chat COLD FLOWS AND THE FIRST QUASARS 2012 Tiziana Di Matteo
Nishikanta Khandai
Colin DeGraf
Yu Feng
Rupert A. C. Croft
J. LĂłpez
Volker Springel
+ PROBING THE DAWN OF GALAXIES AT<i>z</i>∌ 9-12: NEW CONSTRAINTS FROM HUDF12/XDF AND CANDELS DATA 2013 Pascal A. Oesch
R. J. Bouwens
G. D. Illingworth
Ivo Labbé
Marijn Franx
Pieter van Dokkum
Michele Trenti
M. Stiavelli
Valentino GonzĂĄlez
D. Magee
+ Wide-Field InfrarRed Survey Telescope-Astrophysics Focused Telescope Assets WFIRST-AFTA 2015 Report 2015 David N. Spergel
N. Gehrels
C. Baltay
D. P. Bennett
James B. Breckinridge
Megan Donahue
Alan Dressler
B. Scott Gaudi
Thomas P. Greene
Olivier Guyon
+ PDF Chat The MassiveBlack-II simulation: the evolution of haloes and galaxies to z ∌ 0 2015 Nishikanta Khandai
Tiziana Di Matteo
Rupert A. C. Croft
Stephen M. Wilkins
Yu Feng
Evan Tucker
Colin DeGraf
Maosheng Liu
+ PDF Chat A GEOMETRICALLY SUPPORTED <i>z</i> ∌ 10 CANDIDATE MULTIPLY IMAGED BY THE HUBBLE FRONTIER FIELDS CLUSTER A2744 2014 Adi Zitrin
Wei Zheng
Tom Broadhurst
John Moustakas
Daniel Lam
Xinwen Shu
Xingxing Huang
J. M. Diego
H. C. Ford
Jeremy Lim
+ PDF Chat A magnified young galaxy from about 500 million years after the Big Bang 2012 Wei Zheng
Marc Postman
Adi Zitrin
John Moustakas
Xinwen Shu
S. Jouvel
O. HĂžst
A. Molino
Larry Bradley
Dan Coe
+ PDF Chat The EAGLE project: simulating the evolution and assembly of galaxies and their environments 2014 Joop Schaye
Robert A. Crain
R. G. Bower
Michelle Furlong
Matthieu Schaller
Tom Theuns
Claudio Dalla Vecchia
Carlos S. Frenk
Ian G. McCarthy
John Helly
+ PDF Chat THE ABUNDANCE OF STAR-FORMING GALAXIES IN THE REDSHIFT RANGE 8.5-12: NEW RESULTS FROM THE 2012 HUBBLE ULTRA DEEP FIELD CAMPAIGN 2012 Richard S. Ellis
R. J. McLure
J. S. Dunlop
Brant Robertson
Yoshiaki Ono
Matthew A. Schenker
Anton M. Koekemoer
R. A. A. Bowler
Masami Ouchi
A. B. Rogers
+ PDF Chat Introducing the Illustris Project: simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe 2014 Mark Vogelsberger
Shy Genel
Volker Springel
Paul Torrey
Debora Sijacki
D. Xu
Greg Snyder
Dylan Nelson
Lars Hernquist
+ PDF Chat A REMARKABLY LUMINOUS GALAXY AT Z = 11.1 MEASURED WITH HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE GRISM SPECTROSCOPY 2016 Pascal A. Oesch
Gabriel Brammer
Pieter van Dokkum
G. D. Illingworth
R. J. Bouwens
Ivo Labbé
Marijn Franx
Ivelina Momcheva
M. L. N. Ashby
G. G. Fazio
+ PDF Chat THE BRIGHT END OF THE ULTRAVIOLET LUMINOSITY FUNCTION AT<i>z</i>∌ 8: NEW CONSTRAINTS FROM CANDELS DATA IN GOODS-SOUTH 2012 Pascal A. Oesch
R. J. Bouwens
G. D. Illingworth
Valentino GonzĂĄlez
Michele Trenti
Pieter van Dokkum
Marijn Franx
Ivo Labbé
C. M. Carollo
D. Magee
+ PDF Chat An empirical model for the galaxy luminosity and star formation rate function at high redshift 2015 Natalie Mashian
Pascal A. Oesch
Abraham Loeb
+ PDF Chat ON THE INTERPLAY BETWEEN STAR FORMATION AND FEEDBACK IN GALAXY FORMATION SIMULATIONS 2015 Oscar Agertz
Andrey V. Kravtsov
+ PDF Chat Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function 2003 G. Chabrier
+ PDF Chat FIRST FRONTIER FIELD CONSTRAINTS ON THE COSMIC STAR FORMATION RATE DENSITY AT<i>z</i>∌ 10—THE IMPACT OF LENSING SHEAR ON COMPLETENESS OF HIGH-REDSHIFT GALAXY SAMPLES 2015 Pascal A. Oesch
R. J. Bouwens
G. D. Illingworth
Marijn Franx
S. Mark Ammons
Pieter van Dokkum
Michele Trenti
Ivo Labbé
+ PDF Chat HUBBLE FRONTIER FIELDS FIRST COMPLETE CLUSTER DATA: FAINT GALAXIES AT<i>z</i>∌ 5-10 FOR UV LUMINOSITY FUNCTIONS AND COSMIC REIONIZATION 2015 Masafumi Ishigaki
Ryota Kawamata
Masami Ouchi
Masamune Oguri
Kazuhiro Shimasaku
Yoshiaki Ono
+ THE MOST LUMINOUS<i>z</i>∌ 9-10 GALAXY CANDIDATES YET FOUND: THE LUMINOSITY FUNCTION, COSMIC STAR-FORMATION RATE, AND THE FIRST MASS DENSITY ESTIMATE AT 500 Myr 2014 Pascal A. Oesch
R. J. Bouwens
G. D. Illingworth
Ivo Labbé
Renske Smit
Marijn Franx
Pieter van Dokkum
Ivelina Momcheva
M. L. N. Ashby
G. G. Fazio
+ PDF Chat UV LUMINOSITY FUNCTIONS AT REDSHIFTS<i>z</i>∌ 4 TO<i>z</i>∌ 10: 10,000 GALAXIES FROM<i>HST</i>LEGACY FIELDS 2015 R. J. Bouwens
G. D. Illingworth
Pascal A. Oesch
Michele Trenti
Ivo Labbé
Larry Bradley
C. M. Carollo
Pieter van Dokkum
Valentino GonzĂĄlez
Benne W. Holwerda
+ PDF Chat THE EVOLUTION OF THE GALAXY STELLAR MASS FUNCTION AT z = 4–8: A STEEPENING LOW-MASS-END SLOPE WITH INCREASING REDSHIFT 2016 Mimi Song
Steven L. Finkelstein
M. L. N. Ashby
A. Grazian
Yu Lu
Casey Papovich
Brett Salmon
Rachel S. Somerville
Mark Dickinson
K. J. Duncan