Sharing clinical trial data on patient level: Opportunities and challenges

Type: Review

Publication Date: 2014-06-18

Citations: 70

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/bimj.201300283

Abstract

In recent months one of the most controversially discussed topics among regulatory agencies, the pharmaceutical industry, journal editors, and academia has been the sharing of patient‐level clinical trial data. Several projects have been started such as the European Medicines Agency´s (EMA) “proactive publication of clinical trial data”, the BMJ open data campaign, or the AllTrials initiative. The executive director of the EMA, Dr. Guido Rasi, has recently announced that clinical trial data on patient level will be published from 2014 onwards (although it has since been delayed). The EMA draft policy on proactive access to clinical trial data was published at the end of June 2013 and open for public consultation until the end of September 2013. These initiatives will change the landscape of drug development and publication of medical research. They provide unprecedented opportunities for research and research synthesis, but pose new challenges for regulatory authorities, sponsors, scientific journals, and the public. Besides these general aspects, data sharing also entails intricate biostatistical questions such as problems of multiplicity. An important issue in this respect is the interpretation of multiple statistical analyses, both prospective and retrospective. Expertise in biostatistics is needed to assess the interpretation of such multiple analyses, for example, in the context of regulatory decision‐making by optimizing procedural guidance and sophisticated analysis methods.

Locations

  • Biometrical Journal - View - PDF
  • PubMed Central - View
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Bumps and bridges on the road to responsible sharing of clinical trial data 2014 Jesse A. Berlin
Sandra A. Morris
Frank W. Rockhold
Lisa Askie
Davina Ghersi
Joanne Waldstreicher
+ The need for even further progress with clinical trial data sharing efforts: patients are waiting 2015 Sandra A. Morris
Karla Childers
Jesse A. Berlin
Joanne Waldstreicher
+ Sharing Clinical Trial Data 2015 Bernard Lo
+ PDF Chat EFSPI/PSI working group on data sharing: accessing and working with pharmaceutical clinical trial patient level datasets – a primer for academic researchers 2016 Rebecca Sudlow
Janice Branson
Tim Friede
David Morgan
Caroline Whately‐Smith
+ Clinical Trial Transparency and Orphan Drug Development: Recent Trends in Data Sharing by the Pharmaceutical Industry 2013 D So
Yann Joly
Bartha Maria Knoppers
+ PDF Chat Open Data Revolution in Clinical Research: Opportunities and Challenges 2020 Mohamed H. Shahin
Sanchita Bhattacharya
Diego S. Silva
Sarah Kim
Jackson Burton
Jagdeep T. Podichetty
Klaus Romero
Daniela J. Conrado
+ PDF Chat Data sharing in clinical trials - practical guidance on anonymising trial datasets 2015 Christopher Tuck
Steff Lewis
Garry Milne
Sandra Eldridge
Neil Wright
+ The European Medicines Agency's plans for sharing data from clinical trials 2013 Trish Groves
F. Godlee
+ Open Science and Patient Data Sharing 2025 Frank W. Rockhold
Rebecca Wilgus
+ PDF Chat Data sharing and the evolving role of statisticians 2016 Nick Manamley
Stephen Mallett
Matthew R. Sydes
Sally Hollis
Alison Scrimgeour
Hans Ulrich Burger
H. Urban
+ Enhancing the value of clinical trials: the role of data sharing 2016 Christopher B. Granger
E. Magnus Ohman
+ PDF Chat Best practice for analysis of shared clinical trial data 2016 Sally Hollis
Christine Fletcher
Frances Lynn
Hans-Joerg Urban
Janice Branson
Hans‐Ulrich Burger
Catrin Tudur Smith
Matthew R. Sydes
Christoph Gerlinger
+ PDF Chat Deficiencies in the transfer and availability of clinical trials evidence: a review of existing systems and standards 2012 Gert van Valkenhoef
Tommi Tervonen
Bert de Brock
Hans L. Hillege
+ PDF Chat Obtaining and managing data sets for individual participant data meta-analysis: scoping review and practical guide 2019 Matthew Ventresca
Holger J. Schünemann
Fergus Macbeth
Mike Clarke
Lehana Thabane
Gareth Griffiths
Simon Noble
David E. Garcı́a
Maura Marcucci
Alfonso Iorio
+ Impact of data transparency: Scientific publications 2018 Mohit Joshi
Payal Bhardwaj
+ Anonymising Clinical Data for Secondary Use 2023 Irene Ferreira
Chris Harbron
Alex Hughes
Tamsin Sargood
Christoph Gerlinger
+ Data handling in clinical trials: an ongoing debate 1995 PJH Jongen
+ Data Sharing Statements for Clinical Trials 2017 Darren B. Taichman
Peush ‎Sahni
Anja Pinborg
Larry Peiperl
Christine Lainé
Astrid James
Sung‐Tae Hong
Abraham Haileamlak
Laragh Gollogly
Fiona Godlee
+ European Federation of Statisticians in the Pharmaceutical Industry's position on access to clinical trial data 2013 Christine Fletcher
Stefan Driessen
Hans Ulrich Burger
Christoph Gerlinger
Egbert Biesheuvel
+ Challenges and opportunities for exploring patient-level data: Preliminary results 2015 Pedro Lopes
Luís A. Bastião Silva
José Luís Oliveira

Works That Cite This (17)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Standardizing data exchange for clinical research protocols and case report forms: An assessment of the suitability of the Clinical Data Interchange Standards Consortium (CDISC) Operational Data Model (ODM) 2015 Vojtech Huser
Chandan Sastry
Matthew Breymaier
Asma Idriss
James J. Cimino
+ PDF Chat Evidence, eminence and extrapolation 2016 Gerald Hlavin
Franz Koenig
Christoph Male
Martin Posch
Péter Bauer
+ PDF Chat Lessons learned from IDeAl — 33 recommendations from the IDeAl-net about design and analysis of small population clinical trials 2018 R.-D Hilgers
Małgorzata Bogdan
Carl‐Fredrik Burman
Holger Dette
Mats O. Karlsson
Franz König
Christoph Male
France Mentré
Geert Molenberghs
Stephen Senn
+ PDF Chat Three general concepts to improve risk prediction: good data, wisdom of the crowd, recalibration 2016 Ivan Kondofersky
Michael Laimighofer
Christoph Kurz
Norbert Krautenbacher
Julia F. Söllner
Philip Dargatz
Hagen Scherb
Donna P. Ankerst
Christiane Fuchs
+ PDF Chat A proposal for a new PhD level curriculum on quantitative methods for drug development 2018 Thomas Jaki
A. Gordon
Patricia Forster
Luc Bijnens
Bjoern Bornkamp
Werner Brannath
Roberto Fontana
Mauro Gasparini
L Hampson
Tom Jacobs
+ PDF Chat Are Novel, Nonrandomized Analytic Methods Fit for Decision Making? The Need for Prospective, Controlled, and Transparent Validation 2019 Hans‐Georg Eichler
Franz Koenig
Peter Arlett
Harald Enzmann
A. J. B. Humphreys
Frank Pétavy
Brigitte Schwarzer‐Daum
Bruno Sepodes
Spiros Vamvakas
Guido Rasi
+ PDF Chat Open Data Revolution in Clinical Research: Opportunities and Challenges 2020 Mohamed H. Shahin
Sanchita Bhattacharya
Diego S. Silva
Sarah Kim
Jackson Burton
Jagdeep T. Podichetty
Klaus Romero
Daniela J. Conrado
+ Making the most of a few small population clinical trials 2020 Konstantinos Pateras
+ PDF Chat Meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials in the era of individual patient data sharing 2018 Takuya Kawahara
Musashi Fukuda
Koji Oba
Junichi Sakamoto
Marc Buyse
+ PDF Chat “Threshold‐crossing”: A Useful Way to Establish the Counterfactual in Clinical Trials? 2016 H‐G Eichler
Brigitte Bloechl‐Daum
Philipp K. Bauer
Frank Bretz
Jeffrey S. Brown
L Hampson
Peter K. Honig
Michael Krams
Hubert G.M. Leufkens
Robyn Lim

Works Cited by This (10)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Statisticians in European regulatory agencies 2009 Eva Skovlund
+ Where Statisticians can Contribute to Address Future Challenges for Drug Regulatory Agencies: A View from the European Medicines Agency (EMEA) 2010 Hans‐Georg Eichler
Robert Hemmings
Spiros Vamvakas
+ Generalized α-investing: Definitions, Optimality Results and Application to Public Databases 2013 Ehud Aharoni
Saharon Rosset
+ Hierarchical False Discovery Rate–Controlling Methodology 2008 Daniel Yekutieli
+ PDF Chat <i>α</i>-Investing: a Procedure for Sequential Control of Expected False Discoveries 2008 Dean P. Foster
Robert A. Stine
+ PDF Chat Selective Inference on Multiple Families of Hypotheses 2013 Yoav Benjamini
Marina Bogomolov
+ PDF Chat Approaches to multiplicity issues in complex research in microarray analysis 2006 Daniel Yekutieli
Anat Reiner‐Benaim
Yoav Benjamini
Gregory I. Elmer
Neri Kafkafi
Noah Letwin
Norman H. Lee
+ PDF Chat Open Clinical Trial Data for All? A View from Regulators 2012 Hans‐Georg Eichler
Éric Abadie
Alasdair Breckenridge
Hubert G.M. Leufkens
Guido Rasi
+ Validation of Statistical Signal Detection Procedures in EudraVigilance Post-Authorization Data 2010 Yolanda Álvarez
Ana Andreina Tacuri Hidalgo
F. Maignen
Jim Slattery
+ PDF Chat The role of biostatistics in the prevention, detection and treatment of fraud in clinical trials 1999 Marc Buyse
Stephen L. George
Stephen Evans
Nancy L. Geller
Jonas Ranstam
Bruno Scherrer
Emmanuel Lesaffre
Gordon Murray
Lutz Edler
Jane L. Hutton