A Historical Note On The Proof Of The Area Of A Circle

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2011-03-15

Citations: 2

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19030/tlc.v8i3.4119

Abstract

Proofs that the area of a circle is ?r2 can be found in mathematical literature dating as far back as the time of the Greeks. The early proofs, e.g. Archimedes, involved dividing the circle into wedges and then fitting the wedges together in a way to approximate a rectangle. Later more sophisticated proofs relied on arguments involving infinite sequences and calculus. Generally speaking, both of these approaches are difficult to explain to unsophisticated non-mathematics majors. This paper presents a less known but interesting and intuitive proof that was introduced in the twelfth century. It discusses challenges that were made to the proof and offers simple rebuttals to those challenges.

Locations

  • Journal of College Teaching & Learning (TLC) - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Area inside a Circle: Intuitive and Rigorous Proofs 2017 M. Vali Siadat
+ Area Inside A Circle: Intuitive and Rigorous Proofs 2017 M. Vali Siadat
+ Area Inside A Circle: Intuitive and Rigorous Proofs 2017 M. Vali Siadat
+ PDF Chat Some Comments On: A Historical Note On The Proof Of The Area Of A Circle 2011 Jaideep T. Naidu
John F. Sanford
+ Why is it that the Ratio of Any Circle’s Circumference to its Diameter is a Constant? 2022 F. M. S. Lima
P. G. F. JordĂŁo
+ Circular reasoning: who first proved that $C/d$ is a constant? 2013 David Richeson
+ PDF Chat On Heron’s Formula for the Area of a Plane Triangle 2024 Chris Sangwin
+ A correct visual proof of area of trapezium 2011 Michael De Villiers
+ A constante π 2015 Messias Antônio da Silva
+ Finding the Area of a Circle: Didactic Explanations in School Mathematics. 2009 Kaye Stacey
Jill Vincent
+ $Ď€$ and Arc-Length 2021 Joseph Amal Nathan
+ A constructive proof of the circle theorem 1989 S. D. Nigam
T. Amaranath
+ The fruit of the meditations of a young Lieutenant of the Engineers: A Theorem of Major Impact and Its Applications. Two Centuries from the Discovery of the Nine-Point Circle 2021 Bogdan D. SuceavÇŽ
+ PDF Chat From a Doodle to a Theorem: A Case Study in Mathematical Discovery 2023 Juan Fernández González
Dirk Schlimm
+ Art of π: Mathematical History and Literary Inspiration 2012 Tatiana Bonch-Osmolovskaya
+ The First Impossibility Proof 2023 Jesper LĂĽtzen
+ A Mechanical Derivation of the Area of the Sphere 2001 David Garber
Boaz Tsaban
+ A Mechanical Derivation of the Area of the Sphere 2001 David Garber
Boaz Tsaban
+ PDF Chat A blind spot in undergraduate mathematics: The circular definition of the length of the circle, and how it can be turned into an enlightening example 2022 Alexei Vernitski
+ A blind spot in undergraduate mathematics: The circular definition of the length of the circle, and how it can be turned into an enlightening example 2021 Alexei Vernitski