Limits on Planets around Pulsating White Dwarf Stars

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2008-03-17

Citations: 111

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/528672

View Chat PDF

Abstract

We present limits on planetary companions to pulsating white dwarf stars. A subset of these stars exhibit extreme stability in the period and phase of some of their pulsation modes; a planet can be detected around such a star by searching for periodic variations in the arrival time of these pulsations. We present limits on companions greater than a few Jupiter masses around a sample of 15 white dwarf stars as part of an ongoing survey. One star shows a variation in arrival time consistent with a 2MJ planet in a 4.5 yr orbit. We discuss other possible explanations for the observed signal and conclude that a planet is the most plausible explanation based on the data available.

Locations

  • The Astrophysical Journal - View - PDF
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - PDF
  • Texas ScholarWorks (Texas Digital Library) - View - PDF
  • LA Referencia (Red Federada de Repositorios Institucionales de Publicaciones CientĂ­ficas) - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ Limits on Planets Around White Dwarf Stars 2008 Susan E. Mullally
D. E. Winget
Steven DeGennaro
Elizabeth Jeffery
Susan E. Thompson
Dean W. Chandler
+ PDF Chat A refined search for pulsations in white dwarf companions to millisecond pulsars★ 2018 Mukremin Kilic
J. J. Hermes
A. H. CĂłrsico
Alekzander Kosakowski
Warren R. Brown
John Antoniadis
Leila M. Calcaferro
A. Gianninas
L. G. Althaus
Matthew Green
+ PDF Chat LIMITS ON PLANET FORMATION AROUND YOUNG PULSARS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR SUPERNOVA FALLBACK DISKS 2015 M. Kerr
S. Johnston
G. Hobbs
R. M. Shannon
+ PDF Chat Searching for Planets with White Dwarf Pulsations: Spurious Detections 2011 J. Dalessio
J. L. Provencal
H. Shipman
Sonja Schuh
H. Drechsel
U. Heber
+ On the Orbits of Companions to White Dwarfs 2012 Jason Nordhaus
David S. Spiegel
+ A search for planetary companions around 800 pulsars from the Jodrell Bank pulsar timing programme 2022 I. C. NiĹŁu
M. J. Keith
B. W. Stappers
A. G. Lyne
M. B. Mickaliger
+ PDF Chat Detection limits for close eclipsing and transiting substellar and planetary companions to white dwarfs in the WASP survey 2010 F. Faedi
R. G. West
M. R. Burleigh
M. R. Goad
Leslie Hebb
+ Timing of stellar pulsations to search for sub-stellar companions beyond the main sequence 2020 F. Mackebrandt
+ PDF Chat The occurrence of planets and other substellar bodies around white dwarfs using K2 2017 Lennart van Sluijs
Vincent Van Eylen
+ PDF Chat Kepler constraints on planets near hot Jupiters 2012 Jason H. Steffen
Darin Ragozzine
Daniel C. Fabrycky
Joshua A. Carter
Eric B. Ford
Matthew J. Holman
Jason F. Rowe
William F. Welsh
W. J. Borucki
Alan P. Boss
+ PDF Chat Imaging planets around nearby white dwarfs 2002 M. R. Burleigh
Fraser Clarke
S. T. Hodgkin
+ The Range of Masses and Periods Explored by Radial Velocity Searches for Planetary Companions 1998 Andrew Nelson
J. R. P. Angel
+ PDF Chat Detection Limits for Close Eclipsing and transiting Sub-Stellar and Planetary Companions to White Dwarfs in the WASP Survey 2011 F. Faedi
R. G. West
M. R. Burleigh
M. R. Goad
Leslie Hebb
Sonja Schuh
H. Drechsel
U. Heber
+ PDF Chat THREE NEW ECLIPSING WHITE-DWARF-M-DWARF BINARIES DISCOVERED IN A SEARCH FOR TRANSITING PLANETS AROUND M-DWARFS 2012 Nicholas M. Law
Adam L. Kraus
R. A. Street
Benjamin J. Fulton
Lynne A. Hillenbrand
Avi Shporer
Tim Lister
Christoph Baranec
J. S. Bloom
Khanh Bui
+ PDF Chat Detection Limits for Close Eclipsing and transiting Sub-Stellar and Planetary Companions to White Dwarfs in the WASP Survey 2011 F. Faedi
R. G. West
M. R. Burleigh
M. R. Goad
Leslie Hebb
+ Searching for Planets with White Dwarf Pulsations: Spurious Detections 2011 J. Dalessio
J. L. Provencal
H. Shipman
+ No Pulsar Companion Around the Nearest Low Mass White Dwarf 2021 Tilemachos M. Athanasiadis
N. K. Porayko
John Antoniadis
D. J. Champion
O. Wucknitz
B. Ciardi
M. Hoeft
M. Krämer
+ PDF Chat On the orbits of low-mass companions to white dwarfs and the fates of the known exoplanets 2013 Jason Nordhaus
David S. Spiegel
+ Doppler Constraints on Planetary Companions to Nearby Sun-like Stars: An Archival Radial Velocity Survey of Southern Targets for Proposed NASA Direct Imaging Missions 2023 Katherine Laliotis
Jennifer Burt
Eric E. Mamajek
Zhexing Li
V. Perdelwitz
Jinglin Zhao
R. Paul Butler
B. Holden
Lee J. Rosenthal
B. J. Fulton
+ PDF Chat Radio timing constraints on the mass of the binary pulsar PSR J1528-3146 2023 A. Berthereau
L. Guillemot
P. C. C. Freire
M. Kramer
V. Venkatraman Krishnan
I. Cognard
G. Theureau
M. Bailes
M. C. i Bernadich
M. E. Lower

Cited by (61)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Unstable low-mass planetary systems as drivers of white dwarf pollution 2018 Alexander J. Mustill
E. Villaver
Dimitri Veras
B. T. Gänsicke
Amy Bonsor
+ PDF Chat Evolutionary and pulsational properties of white dwarf stars 2010 L. G. Althaus
A. H. CĂłrsico
J. Isern
E. Garcı́a–Berro
+ PDF Chat THE WIRED SURVEY. II. INFRARED EXCESSES IN THE SDSS DR7 WHITE DWARF CATALOG 2011 John H. Debes
D. W. Hoard
Stefanie Wachter
David Leisawitz
Martin Cohen
+ PDF Chat NEAR-INFRARED CONSTRAINTS ON THE PRESENCE OF WARM DUST AT METAL-RICH, HELIUM ATMOSPHERE WHITE DWARFS 2008 Mukremin Kilic
Jay Farihi
A. Nitta
S. K. Leggett
+ White Dwarf Period Tables I. Pulsators with hydrogen-dominated atmospheres 2016 Zs. BognĂĄr
Á. Sódor
+ PDF Chat MASSES AND ORBITAL CONSTRAINTS FOR THE OGLE-2006-BLG-109Lb,c JUPITER/SATURN ANALOG PLANETARY SYSTEM 2010 D. P. Bennett
Sun Hong Rhie
S. Nikolaev
B. Scott Gaudi
A. Udalski
Andrew Gould
G. W. Christie
Dan Maoz
Subo Dong
J. McCormick
+ PDF Chat TESS first look at evolved compact pulsators: Known ZZ Ceti stars of the southern ecliptic hemisphere as seen by TESS 2020 Zs. BognĂĄr
S. D. Kawaler
Keaton J. Bell
C. Schrandt
A. S. Baran
Paul A. Bradley
J. J. Hermes
S. Charpinet
G. Handler
Susan E. Mullally
+ PDF Chat ECHOES OF A DECAYING PLANETARY SYSTEM: THE GASEOUS AND DUSTY DISKS SURROUNDING THREE WHITE DWARFS 2010 Carl Melis
M. Jura
LoĂŻc Albert
B. Klein
B. Zuckerman
+ PDF Chat The Pulsating White Dwarf G117-B15A: Still the Most Stable Optical Clock Known 2020 S. O. Kepler
D. E. Winget
Zachary P. Vanderbosch
B. G. Castanheira
J. J. Hermes
Keaton J. Bell
Fergal Mullally
A. D. Romero
Μ. H. Montgomery
Steven DeGennaro
+ PDF Chat Precise determination of stellar parameters of the ZZ Ceti and DAZ white dwarf GD 133 through asteroseismology 2019 J-N Fu
G. Vauclair
Jie Su
L. Fox Machado
F. Colas
S-L Kim
Tianqi Cang
Changjun Li
H. B. Niu
Hui-Fang Xue
+ PDF Chat Anomalous Orbital Characteristics of the AQ Col (EC 05217-3914) System 2022 Tomomi Otani
A. E. Lynas‐Gray
D. Kilkenny
C. Koen
Ted von Hippel
Murat Uzundag
M. Vučković
Clara M Pennock
R. Silvotti
+ PDF Chat Orbital Characteristics of the Subdwarf-B and F V Star Binary EC 20117-4014 (=V4640 Sgr) 2018 Tomomi Otani
T. D. Oswalt
A. E. Lynas‐Gray
D. Kilkenny
C. Koen
M. Amaral
Riley Jordan
+ PDF Chat Long-term eclipse timing of white dwarf binaries: an observational hint of a magnetic mechanism at work 2016 M. C. P. Bours
T. R. Marsh
S. G. Parsons
V. S. Dhillon
R. P. Ashley
J. P. Bento
E. Breedt
T. Butterley
C. CĂĄceres
P. Chote
+ PDF Chat The DODO survey - II. A Gemini direct imaging search for substellar and planetary mass companions around nearby equatorial and Northern hemisphere white dwarfs 2009 Emma Hogan
M. R. Burleigh
Fraser Clarke
+ PDF Chat Detection limits for close eclipsing and transiting substellar and planetary companions to white dwarfs in the WASP survey 2010 F. Faedi
R. G. West
M. R. Burleigh
M. R. Goad
Leslie Hebb
+ PDF Chat VARIABILITY IN HOT CARBON-DOMINATED ATMOSPHERE (HOT DQ) WHITE DWARFS: RAPID ROTATION? 2016 Kurtis A. Williams
Μ. H. Montgomery
D. E. Winget
Ross E. Falcon
Michael Bierwagen
+ PDF Chat The great escape: how exoplanets and smaller bodies desert dying stars 2011 Dimitri Veras
M. C. Wyatt
Alexander J. Mustill
Amy Bonsor
J. J. Eldridge
+ PDF Chat DETECTION OF WEAK CIRCUMSTELLAR GAS AROUND THE DAZ WHITE DWARF WD 1124-293: EVIDENCE FOR THE ACCRETION OF MULTIPLE ASTEROIDS 2012 John H. Debes
Mukremin Kilic
F. Faedi
Evgenya L. Shkolnik
Mercedes López‐Morales
Alycia J. Weinberger
C. L. Slesnick
R. G. West
+ PDF Chat SDSS J084539.17+225728.0: the first DBZ white dwarf with a metal-rich gaseous debris disc 2008 B. T. Gänsicke
D. Koester
T. R. Marsh
A. Rebassa–Mansergas
J. Southworth
+ PDF Chat EXOTIME: searching for planets around pulsating subdwarf B stars 2010 Sonja Schuh
R. Silvotti
Ronny Lutz
BjĂśrn Loeptien
Elizabeth M. Green
R. H. Østensen
S. Leccia
Seung-Lee Kim
G. Fontaine
S. Charpinet
+ PDF Chat Evryscope Science: Exploring the Potential of All-Sky Gigapixel-Scale Telescopes 2015 Nicholas M. Law
O. Fors
Jeffrey K. Ratzloff
Philip J. Wulfken
Dustin Kavanaugh
David J. Sitar
Zachary R. Pruett
Mariah N. Birchard
B. N. Barlow
K. C. Cannon
+ PDF Chat MULTI-SITE OBSERVATIONS OF PULSATION IN THE ACCRETING WHITE DWARF SDSS J161033.64–010223.3 (V386 Ser) 2010 Anjum S. Mukadam
Dean M. Townsley
B. T. Gänsicke
Paula Szkody
T. R. Marsh
E. L. Robinson
Lars Bildsten
A. Aungwerojwit
M. R. Schreiber
J. Southworth
+ PDF Chat KIC 11911480: the second ZZ Ceti in the Kepler field 2014 S. Greiss
B. T. Gaensicke
J. J. Hermes
D. Steeghs
D. Koester
Gavin Ramsay
Thomas Barclay
Dean M. Townsley
+ PDF Chat Simulations of two-planet systems through all phases of stellar evolution: implications for the instability boundary and white dwarf pollution 2013 Dimitri Veras
Alexander J. Mustill
Amy Bonsor
M. C. Wyatt
+ PDF Chat Detectable close-in planets around white dwarfs through late unpacking 2014 Dimitri Veras
B. T. Gänsicke
+ PDF Chat Habitable Planets Around White and Brown Dwarfs: The Perils of a Cooling Primary 2013 Rory Barnes
RenĂŠ Heller
+ PDF Chat A wide binary trigger for white dwarf pollution 2015 Amy Bonsor
Dimitri Veras
+ PDF Chat FORETELLINGS OF RAGNARÖK: WORLD-ENGULFING ASYMPTOTIC GIANTS AND THE INHERITANCE OF WHITE DWARFS 2012 Alexander J. Mustill
E. Villaver
+ An Isolated White Dwarf with a 70 s Spin Period 2021 Mukremin Kilic
Alekzander Kosakowski
Adam Moss
P. Bergeron
Annamarie A. Conly
+ PDF Chat DISCOVERY OF A NOVA-LIKE CATACLYSMIC VARIABLE IN THE<i>KEPLER MISSION</i>FIELD 2010 Kurtis A. Williams
D. de Martino
R. Silvotti
I. Bruni
P. Dufour
Thomas Riecken
Martin Kronberg
Anjum S. Mukadam
G. Handler
+ PDF Chat ASTEROSEISMOLOGICAL STUDY OF MASSIVE ZZ CETI STARS WITH FULLY EVOLUTIONARY MODELS 2013 A. D. Romero
S. O. Kepler
A. H. CĂłrsico
L. G. Althaus
L. Fraga
+ PDF Chat Pulsating low-mass white dwarfs in the frame of new evolutionary sequences 2017 Leila M. Calcaferro
A. H. CĂłrsico
L. G. Althaus
+ Timing by Stellar Pulsations as an Exoplanet Discovery Method 2018 J. J. Hermes
+ PDF Chat Does GD 356 have a terrestrial planetary companion? 2010 D. T. Wickramasinghe
Jay Farihi
Christopher A. Tout
Lilia Ferrario
Richard J. Stancliffe
+ PDF Chat Probing the Structure of Kepler ZZ Ceti Stars with Full Evolutionary Models-based Asteroseismology 2017 A. D. Romero
A. H. CĂłrsico
B. G. Castanheira
F. C. De GerĂłnimo
S. O. Kepler
D. Koester
A. Kawka
L. G. Althaus
J. J. Hermes
Cassiane Cardoso Bonato
+ PDF Chat A NEW TIMESCALE FOR PERIOD CHANGE IN THE PULSATING DA WHITE DWARF WD 0111+0018 2013 J. J. Hermes
Μ. H. Montgomery
Fergal Mullally
D. E. Winget
A. Bischoff‐Kim
+ PDF Chat An extreme-AO search for giant planets around a white dwarf 2015 Siyi Xu
Steve Ertel
Z. Wahhaj
J. Milli
Peter Scicluna
Gesa H.-M. Bertrang
+ PDF Chat <i>SPITZER</i>PLANET LIMITS AROUND THE PULSATING WHITE DWARF GD66 2009 Fergal Mullally
W. T. Reach
Steven DeGennaro
Adam Burrows
+ PDF Chat Limits on Mode Coherence in Pulsating DA White Dwarfs Due to a Nonstatic Convection Zone 2020 Μ. H. Montgomery
J. J. Hermes
D. E. Winget
B. H. Dunlap
Keaton J. Bell
+ PDF Chat A search for variable white dwarfs in large-area time-domain surveys: a pilot study in SDSS Stripe 82 2015 N. P. Gentile Fusillo
J. J. Hermes
B. T. Gänsicke

Citing (22)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Low‐Luminosity Companions to White Dwarfs 2005 Jay Farihi
E. E. Becklin
B. Zuckerman
+ An Empirical Initial-Final Mass Relation from Hot, Massive White Dwarfs in NGC 2168 (M35) 2004 Kurtis A. Williams
Michael Bolte
D. Koester
+ PDF Chat Cool Customers in the Stellar Graveyard. III. Limits to Substellar Objects around nearby White Dwarfs using the Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope 2006 John H. Debes
Jian Ge
Christ Ftaclas
+ PDF Chat A Possible Brown Dwarf Companion to the White Dwarf GD 1400 2004 Jay Farihi
M. H. Christopher
+ PDF Chat A CCD Time‐Series Photometer 2004 R. E. Nather
Anjum S. Mukadam
+ PDF Chat Axion cooling of white dwarfs 1992 J. Isern
M. Hernanz
E. GarcĂ­a-Berro
+ PDF Chat A Catalog of Spectroscopically Identified White Dwarf Stars in the First Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey 2004 S. J. Kleinman
Hugh C. Harris
Daniel J. Eisenstein
James Liebert
A. Nitta
J. Krzesiński
Jeffrey A. Munn
C. C. Dahn
Suzanne L. Hawley
Jeffrey R. Pier
+ PDF Chat A Catalog of Spectroscopically Confirmed White Dwarfs from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 4 2006 Daniel J. Eisenstein
James Liebert
Hugh C. Harris
S. J. Kleinman
A. Nitta
Nicole M. Silvestri
Scott A. Anderson
John C. Barentine
H. Brewington
J. Brinkmann
+ PDF Chat The Fourth Data Release of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey 2006 Jennifer Adelman-McCarthy
Marcel A. AgĂźeros
S. Allam
Kurt S. Anderson
Scott F. Anderson
James Annis
Neta A. Bahcall
I. K. Baldry
John C. Barentine
Andreas A. Berlind
+ PDF Chat Keck Speckle Imaging of the White Dwarf G29-38: No Brown Dwarf Companion Detected 1998 Marc J. Kuchner
C. Koresko
Michael E. Brown
+ PDF Chat The analysis of indexed astronomical time series -- X. Significance testing of O -- C data 2005 C. Koen
+ PDF Chat The USNO-B Catalog 2003 D. G. Monet
S. E. Levine
B. Canzian
H. D. Ables
Alan R. Bird
C. C. Dahn
H. H. Guetter
Hugh C. Harris
A. A. Henden
S. K. Leggett
+ PDF Chat A <i>Spitzer</i> White Dwarf Infrared Survey 2007 Fergal Mullally
Mukremin Kilic
W. T. Reach
Marc J. Kuchner
Ted von Hippel
Adam Burrows
D. E. Winget
+ PDF Chat Can Planets Survive Stellar Evolution? 2007 E. Villaver
Mario Livio
+ PDF Chat Are There Unstable Planetary Systems around White Dwarfs? 2002 John H. Debes
Steinn SigurĂ°sson
+ PDF Chat On the Purity of the ZZ Ceti Instability Strip: Discovery of More Pulsating DA White Dwarfs on the Basis of Optical Spectroscopy 2004 P. Bergeron
G. Fontaine
M. Billères
S. Boudreault
E. M. Green
+ PDF Chat The potential of the variable DA white dwarf G117?B15A as a tool for fundamental physics 2001 A. H. CĂłrsico
+ PDF Chat Measuring the Evolution of the Most Stable Optical Clock G 117‐B15A 2005 S. O. Kepler
J. E. S. Costa
B. G. Castanheira
D. E. Winget
Fergal Mullally
R. E. Nather
Mukremin Kilic
Ted von Hippel
Anjum S. Mukadam
D. J. Sullivan
+ PDF Chat The open-cluster initial--final mass relationship and the high-mass tail of the white dwarf distribution 2005 Lilia Ferrario
D. T. Wickramasinghe
James Liebert
Kurtis A. Williams
+ PDF Chat Cool Customers in the Stellar Graveyard. I. Limits to Extrasolar Planets Around the White Dwarf G29‐38 2005 John H. Debes
Steinn SigurĂ°sson
B. E. Woodgate
+ PDF Chat Imaging planets around nearby white dwarfs 2002 M. R. Burleigh
Fraser Clarke
S. T. Hodgkin
+ PDF Chat White dwarf mass distribution in the SDSS 2007 S. O. Kepler
S. J. Kleinman
A. Nitta
D. Koester
B. G. Castanheira
O. Giovannini
A. F. M. Costa
L. G. Althaus