Device-Independent Bounds for Hardy’s Experiment

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2012-10-31

Citations: 86

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.109.180401

Abstract

In this Letter, we compute an analogue of Tsirelson's bound for Hardy's test of nonlocality, that is, the maximum violation of locality constraints allowed by the quantum formalism, irrespective of the dimension of the system. The value is found to be the same as the one achievable already with two-qubit systems, and we show that only a very specific class of states can lead to such maximal value, thus highlighting Hardy's test as a device-independent self-test protocol for such states. By considering realistic constraints in Hardy's test, we also compute device-independent upper bounds on this violation and show that these bounds are saturated by two-qubit systems, thus showing that there is no advantage in using higher-dimensional systems in experimental implementations of such a test.

Locations

  • Physical Review Letters - View
  • arXiv (Cornell University) - View - PDF
  • PubMed - View
  • DataCite API - View

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Self-testing quantum states via nonmaximal violation in Hardy's test of nonlocality 2022 Ashutosh Rai
Matej Pivoluska
Souradeep Sasmal
Manik Banik
Sibasish Ghosh
Martin Plesch
+ Violations of complementarity enable beyond-quantum nonlocality, distinguishability and cloning 2014 F. E. S. Steinhoff
M. C. de Oliveira
+ PDF Chat Device-independent bounds from Cabello's nonlocality argument 2021 Ashutosh Rai
Matej Pivoluska
Martin Plesch
Souradeep Sasmal
Manik Banik
Sibasish Ghosh
+ Symmetric hidden state model for trust-less entanglement witness 2019 Debasis Mondal
Dagomir Kaszlikowski
+ Revealing Incommensurability between Device-Independent Randomness, Nonlocality, and Entanglement using Hardy and Hardy-type Relations 2020 Souradeep Sasmal
Sayan Gangopadhyay
Ashutosh Rai
Dipankar Home
Urbasi Sinha
+ PDF Chat Generalization of the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequality self-testing maximally entangled states of any local dimension 2018 Andrea Coladangelo
+ Self-testing of quantum states using symmetric local hidden state model 2019 Debasis Mondal
Dagomir Kaszlikowski
+ PDF Chat Revealing incommensurability between device-independent randomness, nonlocality, and entanglement using Hardy and Hardy-type relations 2024 Souradeep Sasmal
Ashutosh Rai
Sayan Gangopadhyay
Dipankar Home
Urbasi Sinha
+ PDF Chat Self-testing Quantum States via Non-maximal Bell Violation 2021 Ashutosh Rai
Matej Pivoluska
Souradeep Sasmal
Manik Banik
Sibasish Ghosh
Martin Plesch
+ PDF Chat Maximal violation of a broad class of Bell inequalities and its implication on self-testing 2019 Chellasamy Jebarathinam
Jui-Chen Hung
Shin-Liang Chen
Yeong-Cherng Liang
+ PDF Chat Interplay of Quantum Resources in Nonlocality Tests 2024 Hai-Hao Dong
Yuwei Zhu
Su-Yi Cheng
Xingjian Zhang
Cheng-Long Li
Ying-Zhao Li
Hao Li
Lixing You
Xiongfeng Ma
Qiang Zhang
+ PDF Chat Device-Independent Tests of Structures of Measurement Incompatibility 2019 Marco Túlio Quintino
Costantino Budroni
Erik Woodhead
Adán Cabello
Daniel Cavalcanti
+ PDF Chat Self-testing properties of Gisin's elegant Bell inequality 2017 Ole Andersson
Piotr Badzia̧g
Ingemar Bengtsson
Irina Dumitru
Adán Cabello
+ PDF Chat Improved Nonlocality Certification via Bouncing between Bell Operators and Inequalities 2024 Weikang Li
Ming Hu
Ke Wang
Shibo Xu
Zhide Lu
Jiachen Chen
Yaozu Wu
Chuanyu Zhang
Feitong Jin
Xuhao Zhu
+ PDF Chat Device-independent parallel self-testing of two singlets 2016 Xingyao Wu
Jean-Daniel Bancal
Matthew McKague
Valerio Scarani
+ What is the minimum CHSH score certifying that a state contains the singlet 2019 Xavier Valcarce
Pavel Sekatski
Davide Orsucci
Enky Oudot
Jean-Daniel Bancal
Nicolas Sangouard
+ Noncommuting Observables and Local Realism 2005 James D. Malley
Arthur Fine
+ Loophole-free test of local realism via Hardy's violation 2024 Si-Ran Zhao
Shuai Zhao
Hai-Hao Dong
Wen‐Zhao Liu
Jing‐Ling Chen
Kai Chen
Qiang Zhang
Jian-Wei Pan
+ PDF Chat Self-testing of Pauli observables for device-independent entanglement certification 2018 Joseph Bowles
Ivan Šupić
Daniel Cavalcanti
Antonio Acín
+ Opening the black box: how to estimate physical properties from non-local correlations 2013 Tzyh Haur Yang
Tamás Vértesi
Jean-Daniel Bancal
Valerio Scarani
Miguel Navascués

Works That Cite This (50)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Hardy's paradox for multisetting high-dimensional systems 2018 Hui-Xian Meng
Jie Zhou
Zhen‐Peng Xu
Hong-Yi Su
Ting Gao
Fengli Yan
Jing‐Ling Chen
+ PDF Chat Dimension-independent bounds for Hardy's experiment 2014 Zhen‐Peng Xu
Hong-Yi Su
Jing‐Ling Chen
+ PDF Chat Device-independent bounds from Cabello's nonlocality argument 2021 Ashutosh Rai
Matej Pivoluska
Martin Plesch
Souradeep Sasmal
Manik Banik
Sibasish Ghosh
+ PDF Chat Tilted Hardy paradoxes for device-independent randomness extraction 2023 Shuai Zhao
Ravishankar Ramanathan
Yuan Liu
Paweł Horodecki
+ PDF Chat “All-versus-nothing” proof of genuine tripartite steering and entanglement certification in the two-sided device-independent scenario 2022 Shashank Gupta
Debarshi Das
Chellasamy Jebarathinam
Arup Roy
S. Datta
A. S. Majumdar
+ PDF Chat One-sided device-independent self-testing of any pure two-qubit entangled state 2018 Suchetana Goswami
Bihalan Bhattacharya
Debarshi Das
Souradeep Sasmal
C. Jebaratnam
A. S. Majumdar
+ Experimental self-testing of entangled states 2018 Wen-Hao Zhang
Geng Chen
Xing-Xiang Peng
Xiao‐Min Hu
Zhibo Hou
Shang Yu
Xiang-Jun Ye
Zong-Quan Zou
Xiao-Ye Xu
Jian‐Shun Tang
+ Sharp Contradiction for Local-Hidden-State Model in Quantum Steering 2015 Jing‐Ling Chen
Hong-Yi Su
Zhen‐Peng Xu
Arun Kumar Pati
+ Certification of Genuine Multipartite Entanglement with General and Robust Device-independent Witnesses 2021 Chao Zhang
Wen-Hao Zhang
Pavel Sekatski
Jean-Daniel Bancal
Michael Zwerger
Peng Yin
Gongchu Li
Xing-Xiang Peng
Lei Chen
Yong‐Jian Han
+ PDF Chat Device- and semi–device-independent random numbers based on noninequality paradox 2015 Hong-Wei Li
Marcin Pawłowski
Ramij Rahaman
Guang‐Can Guo
Zheng‐Fu Han

Works Cited by This (17)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Hardy’s test versus the Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt test of quantum nonlocality: Fundamental and practical aspects 2008 Daniel Braun
Mahn‐Soo Choi
+ Using SeDuMi 1.02, A Matlab toolbox for optimization over symmetric cones 1999 J.F. Sturm
+ PDF Chat Hardy's nonlocality for generalized n-particle GHZ states 2004 José L. Cereceda
+ PDF Chat Realization of Hardy’s Thought Experiment with Photons 2005 William T. M. Irvine
Juan F. Hodelin
Christoph Simon
Dirk Bouwmeester
+ PDF Chat Asymptotic Violation of Bell Inequalities and Distillability 2006 Lluís Masanes
+ PDF Chat Device-Independent Security of Quantum Cryptography against Collective Attacks 2007 Antonio Acín
Nicolas Brunner
Nicolas Gisin
Serge Massar
Stefano Pironio
Valerio Scarani
+ PDF Chat Device-independent state estimation based on Bell’s inequalities 2009 Charles-Edouard Bardyn
T. C. H. Liew
Serge Massar
Matthew McKague
Valerio Scarani
+ PDF Chat Constancy of maximal nonlocal probability in Hardy's nonlocality test for bipartite quantum systems 2011 Kaushik P. Seshadreesan
Sibasish Ghosh
+ PDF Chat Testing Hardy’s nonlocality proof with genuine energy-time entanglement 2011 Giuseppe Vallone
Ilaria Gianani
Enrique B. Inostroza
C. Saavedra
G. Lima
Adán Cabello
Paolo Mataloni
+ PDF Chat Random numbers certified by Bell’s theorem 2010 Stefano Pironio
Antonio Acín
Serge Massar
A. Boyer de la Giroday
Dzmitry Matsukevich
Peter Maunz
S. Olmschenk
David Hayes
Le Luo
T. Andrew Manning