Urban Cholera Transmission Hotspots and Their Implications for Reactive Vaccination: Evidence from Bissau City, Guinea Bissau

Type: Article

Publication Date: 2012-11-08

Citations: 62

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0001901

Abstract

Background Use of cholera vaccines in response to epidemics (reactive vaccination) may provide an effective supplement to traditional control measures. In Haiti, reactive vaccination was considered but, until recently, rejected in part due to limited global supply of vaccine. Using Bissau City, Guinea-Bissau as a case study, we explore neighborhood-level transmission dynamics to understand if, with limited vaccine and likely delays, reactive vaccination can significantly change the course of a cholera epidemic. Methods and Findings We fit a spatially explicit meta-population model of cholera transmission within Bissau City to data from 7,551 suspected cholera cases from a 2008 epidemic. We estimated the effect reactive vaccination campaigns would have had on the epidemic under different levels of vaccine coverage and campaign start dates. We compared highly focused and diffuse strategies for distributing vaccine throughout the city. We found wide variation in the efficiency of cholera transmission both within and between areas of the city. "Hotspots", where transmission was most efficient, appear to drive the epidemic. In particular one area, Bandim, was a necessary driver of the 2008 epidemic in Bissau City. If vaccine supply were limited but could have been distributed within the first 80 days of the epidemic, targeting vaccination at Bandim would have averted the most cases both within this area and throughout the city. Regardless of the distribution strategy used, timely distribution of vaccine in response to an ongoing cholera epidemic can prevent cases and save lives. Conclusions Reactive vaccination can be a useful tool for controlling cholera epidemics, especially in urban areas like Bissau City. Particular neighborhoods may be responsible for driving a city's cholera epidemic; timely and targeted reactive vaccination at such neighborhoods may be the most effective way to prevent cholera cases both within that neighborhood and throughout the city.

Locations

  • PubMed Central - View
  • Europe PMC (PubMed Central) - View - PDF
  • DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) - View
  • PubMed - View
  • PLoS neglected tropical diseases - View - PDF

Similar Works

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Urban Cholera Transmission Hotspots and Their Implications for Reactive Vaccination: Evidence from Bissau City, Guinea Bissau 2012 Andrew S. Azman
Francisco J. Luquero
Amabélia Rodrigues
P. P. Palma
Rebecca F. Grais
Cunhate Na Banga
Bryan T. Grenfell
Justin Lessler
+ PDF Chat Reactive vaccination in the presence of disease hotspots 2014 Andrew S. Azman
Justin Lessler
+ PDF Chat Vaccination strategies for epidemic cholera in Haiti with implications for the developing world 2011 Dennis L. Chao
M. Elizabeth Halloran
Ira M. Longini
+ PDF Chat Cholera Epidemic in Guinea-Bissau (2008): The Importance of “Place” 2011 Francisco J. Luquero
Cunhate Na Banga
Daniel Remartínez
Pedro Pablo Palma
Emanuel Baron
Rebeca F. Grais
+ PDF Chat Achieving coordinated national immunity and cholera elimination in Haiti through vaccination 2019 Elizabeth C. Lee
Dennis L. Chao
Joseph C. Lemaitre
Laura Matrajt
Damiano Pasetto
Javier Perez‐Saez
Flavio Finger
Andrea Rinaldo
Jonathan D. Sugimoto
M. Elizabeth Halloran
+ Cholera Epidemic in Haiti, 2010: Using a Transmission Model to Explain Spatial Spread of Disease and Identify Optimal Control Interventions 2011 Ashleigh R. Tuite
Joseph H. Tien
Marisa C. Eisenberg
David J. D. Earn
Junling Ma
David N. Fisman
+ PDF Chat Spatial clustering of cholera cases in the Kathmandu Valley: implications for a ring vaccination strategy 2020 Mellisa Roskosky
Mohammad Ali
Shyam Raj Upreti
David A. Sack
+ PDF Chat Cholera in Haiti – Authors' reply 2020 Elizabeth C. Lee
Ralph Ternier
Justin Lessler
Andrew S. Azman
Louise C. Ivers
+ PDF Chat The Impact of a One-Dose versus Two-Dose Oral Cholera Vaccine Regimen in Outbreak Settings: A Modeling Study 2015 Andrew S. Azman
Francisco J. Luquero
Iza Ciglenečki
Rebecca F. Grais
David A. Sack
Justin Lessler
+ Estimating effectiveness of case-area targeted response interventions against cholera in Haiti 2019 Edwige Michel
Jean Gaudart
Samuel Beaulieu
Gregory Bulit
Martine Piarroux
Jacques Boncy
Patrick Dély
Renaud Piarroux
Stanislas Rebaudet
+ PDF Chat Geographic Distribution and Mortality Risk Factors during the Cholera Outbreak in a Rural Region of Haiti, 2010-2011 2015 Anne‐Laure Page
Iza Ciglenečki
Ernest Robert Jasmin
Laurence Desvignes
Francesco Grandesso
Jonathan A. Polonsky
Sarala Nicholas
Kathryn Alberti
Klaudia Porten
Francisco J. Luquero
+ Modeling the Influence of Environment and Intervention on Cholera in Haiti 2013 Stephen Tennenbaum
Caroline Freitag
Svetlana Roudenko
+ Modeling the Influence of Environment and Intervention on Cholera in Haiti 2013 Stephen Tennenbaum
Caroline Freitag
Svetlana Roudenko
+ PDF Chat Risk Map of Cholera Infection for Vaccine Deployment: The Eastern Kolkata Case 2013 Young Ae You
Mohammad Ali
Suman Kanungo
Binod Sah
Byomkesh Manna
Mahesh Puri
G. Balakrish Nair
Sujit Bhattacharya
Matteo Convertino
Jacqueline Deen
+ PDF Chat The potential impact of case-area targeted interventions in response to cholera outbreaks: A modeling study 2018 Flavio Finger
Enrico Bertuzzo
Francisco J. Luquero
Nathan Naïbei
Brahima Touré
Maya Allan
Klaudia Porten
Justin Lessler
Andrea Rinaldo
Andrew S. Azman
+ PDF Chat Highly targeted spatiotemporal interventions against cholera epidemics, 2000–19: a scoping review 2020 Ruwan Ratnayake
Flavio Finger
Andrew S. Azman
Daniele Lantagne
Sebastian Funk
W. John Edmunds
Francesco Checchi
+ Spatially explicit modeling of cholera epidemics 2013 Flavio Finger
+ PDF Chat Prioritizing interventions for cholera control in Kenya, 2015–2020 2023 Waqo Boru
Shaoming Xiao
Patrick Amoth
David Kareko
Daniel Langat
Ian Were
Mohammad Ali
David A. Sack
Elizabeth C. Lee
Amanda K. Debes
+ PDF Chat Transmission dynamics and control of cholera in Haiti: an epidemic model 2011 Jason R. Andrews
S Basu
+ PDF Chat Comparing alternative cholera vaccination strategies in Maela refugee camp: using a transmission model in public health practice 2019 Joshua Havumaki
Rafael Meza
Christina R. Phares
Kashmira Date
Marisa C. Eisenberg

Works That Cite This (36)

Action Title Year Authors
+ PDF Chat Micro-hotspots of Risk in Urban Cholera Epidemics 2018 Andrew S. Azman
Francisco J. Luquero
Henrik Salje
Nathan Naibei Mbaïbardoum
Ngandwe Adalbert
Mohammad Ali
Enrico Bertuzzo
Flavio Finger
Brahima Touré
Louis Albert Massing
+ PDF Chat Climate-driven endemic cholera is modulated by human mobility in a megacity 2016 Javier Perez‐Saez
Aaron A. King
Andrea Rinaldo
Mohammad Yunus
Abu Syed Golam Faruque
Mercedes Pascual
+ PDF Chat Temporo-spatial dynamics and behavioural patterns of 2012 cholera epidemic in the African mega-city of Conakry, Guinea 2018 Alexandre Blake
Véronique Sarr Keita
Delphine Sauvageot
Mamadou Saliou
Berthe Marie Njanpop
Fode Sory
Bertrand Súdre
Lamine Koivogui
Martin Mengel
Bradford D. Gessner
+ PDF Chat Highly targeted spatiotemporal interventions against cholera epidemics, 2000–19: a scoping review 2020 Ruwan Ratnayake
Flavio Finger
Andrew S. Azman
Daniele Lantagne
Sebastian Funk
W. John Edmunds
Francesco Checchi
+ PDF Chat Seasonal Population Movements and the Surveillance and Control of Infectious Diseases 2016 Caroline O. Buckee
Andrew J. Tatem
C. Jessica E. Metcalf
+ PDF Chat Optimal allocation of the limited oral cholera vaccine supply between endemic and epidemic settings 2015 Sean M. Moore
Justin Lessler
+ PDF Chat Neighborhood-targeted and case-triggered use of a single dose of oral cholera vaccine in an urban setting: Feasibility and vaccine coverage 2017 Lucy Anne Parker
John Rumunu
Christine Jamet
Yona Kenyi
Richard Laku Lino
Joseph Francis Wamala
Allan Mpairwe
Vincent Müller
Augusto E. Llosa
Florent Uzzeni
+ PDF Chat Evaluation of Targeted Mass Cholera Vaccination Strategies in Bangladesh: A Demonstration of a New Cost-Effectiveness Calculator 2014 Christopher Troeger
David A. Sack
Dennis L. Chao
+ PDF Chat Mobile phone data highlights the role of mass gatherings in the spreading of cholera outbreaks 2016 Flavio Finger
Tina Genolet
Lorenzo Mari
Guillaume Constantin de Magny
N.M. Manga
Andrea Rinaldo
Enrico Bertuzzo
+ PDF Chat What is a Hotspot Anyway? 2017 Justin Lessler
Andrew S. Azman
Heather McKay
Sean M. Moore

Works Cited by This (10)

Action Title Year Authors
+ Immune responses following one and two doses of the reformulated, bivalent, killed, whole-cell, oral cholera vaccine among adults and children in Kolkata, India: A randomized, placebo-controlled trial 2009 Suman Kanungo
Allison Paisley
Anna Lena Lopez
Mihir Kumar Bhattacharya
Byomkesh Manna
Deok Ryun Kim
Seung Hyun Han
Stephen R. Attridge
Rodney Carbis
R. Prabhakar Rao
+ Antigen-Specific Memory B-Cell Responses in Bangladeshi Adults after One- or Two-Dose Oral Killed Cholera Vaccination and Comparison with Responses in Patients with Naturally Acquired Cholera 2011 Mohammad Murshid Alam
M. Asrafuzzaman Riyadh
Kaniz Fatema
Mohammad Arif Rahman
Nayeema Akhtar
Tanvir Ahmed
Mohiul Islam Chowdhury
Fahima Chowdhury
Stephen B. Calderwood
Jason B. Harris
+ PDF Chat Time is of the essence: exploring a measles outbreak response vaccination in Niamey, Niger 2007 Rebecca F. Grais
Andrew J. K. Conlan
Matthew J. Ferrari
Ali Djibo
Arnaud Le Menach
Ottar N. Bjørnstad
Bryan T. Grenfell
+ PDF Chat Cholera Epidemic in Guinea-Bissau (2008): The Importance of “Place” 2011 Francisco J. Luquero
Cunhate Na Banga
Daniel Remartínez
Pedro Pablo Palma
Emanuel Baron
Rebeca F. Grais
+ PDF Chat Effectiveness of Mass Oral Cholera Vaccination in Beira, Mozambique 2005 Marcelino Lucas
Jacqueline Deen
Lorenz von Seidlein
Xuan-Yi Wang
Julia S. Ampuero
Mahesh Puri
Mohammad Ali
M. Ansaruzzaman
Juvenaldo Amos
Arminda Macuamule
+ PDF Chat Inference from Iterative Simulation Using Multiple Sequences 1992 Andrew Gelman
Donald B. Rubin
+ Design and Analysis of Vaccine Studies 2009 M. Elizabeth Halloran
Ira M. Longini
Claúdio J. Struchiner
+ PDF Chat Hyperinfectivity: A Critical Element in the Ability of V. cholerae to Cause Epidemics? 2005 David Hartley
J. Glenn Morris
David L. Smith
+ Cholera Modeling 2012 Yonatan H. Grad
Joel C. Miller
Marc Lipsitch
+ JAGS: A program for analysis of Bayesian graphical models using Gibbs sampling 2003 Martyn Plummer